Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum.  ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.

Hepatitis C Community

This forum is for questions about medical issues and research aspects of Hepatitis C such as, questions about being newly diagnosed, questions about current treatments, information and participation in discussions about research studies and clinical trials related to Hepatitis. If you would like to communicate with other people who have been touched by Hepatitis, please visit our new Hepatitis Social/Living with Hepatitis forum
 | 

Xanax Or Valium?

by William05, Mar 07, 2005 12:00AM
I have cirhossis due to Alpha-1 Antitripsin Defincieny. I am currently taking .5 mgs of Xanax once or twice daily for anxiety. Would Valium be a safer choice considering the condition of my liver?
Member Comments (22)

by Tony-z, Mar 07, 2005 12:00AM
To: William05


I also take a dose of Xanax daily. I have asked my Dr. and Pharmacist which Benzodiazepines was best for the liver, both responded that they are all about the same on the liver.



Xanax is prescribe alot for helping during TX so I would think the Hepatologist would give the safest one.





       God Bless!



       TonyZ



by whoaisme, Mar 07, 2005 12:00AM
To: William
My husband was told by a doctor that Valium was not liver friendly. That's all I can say about it.

by bluepeng, Mar 07, 2005 12:00AM
Looking at the half-life of every benzo, Valium has a long one (20+ hours) Where Xanax is 6-12.  There is also the concept of first-pass meatabolism, etc.   I think Valium is a multi-pass.  This table may give you an idea.  I'd imagine you'd want something that cleared your body quickly.  



http://web4health.info/en/answers/bio-benzo-overview.htm



by DRAGON SLAYER, Mar 07, 2005 12:00AM
To: William05


I was on Tx for 26 weeks; had HCV 2B. My shrink prescribed the following meds with the approval of my Hepatologist:

1.Xanax 0.5mg x 2/day.

2.Ambien 10mg at bedtime.

3.Lexapro 20/day.



I cleared the virus & my LFT's were normal first time in 30+ years.

My conclusion is that my med profile was not that strenuous on my liver.

Good luck all,

Ben

by Forseegood, Mar 07, 2005 12:00AM
Hi, new to this board. I have heard that zanax is a little better benz than valium, but let's face it, neither are very good for the liver, and I only use them if it's an emergency, otherwise I try to use other natural forms of relaxation. I'm not on tx though. Also, what concerned me more was the diet I've seen on this thread, pizza and pasta? maybe a lot of tomatoes and mult grain pasta, something a little more liver friendly, diet is so important for the liver.

by Atomic, Nov 18, 2007 03:21AM
To: William5
Totally agree with Forseegood.
Here is you can get xanax though generic one
http://www.ez-medicals.com/prices.php?aff_id=6562&sub=347

by Xenigma, Nov 18, 2007 03:12PM
XANAX!!
I've used both over the years and Xanax is superior to Valium for anxiety and irritability.
I find Valium is a wonderful muscle relaxer,  NEVER take both together or in the same day.
You will get sick.

by kate400, Dec 18, 2007 10:01AM
To: All
Best Xanax Pharmacies

http://www.cleopsa.com/pharmacies/xanax.html

Best Valium Pharmacies

http://www.cleopsa.com/pharmacies/valium.html

by toughluck, Dec 18, 2007 10:07AM
To: all
I take Klonopin for anxiety and will use it during TX, I do not get the Valium hangover and moves through my system quickly, also if you want to stop sx is not as bad.

by B-bunch, Dec 24, 2007 03:28AM
To: Dragonslayor
How did you get yourself off all those drugs without checking into detox? Are you still on them? All those drugs are trouble to get off you know. You will have to have a doctor help you taper-off, probably in a hospital.
Good Luck everybody.
p.s. My doc offered me Neurontin, he said it does the same things that Xanax does without the addictive danger. He also recommended Klonopin. He said it has a longer half life so detox and tapering won't be so difficult. Effexor is another really dangerous drug. You'll have to check in to detox for that one too. At least they help when we are on the TX but are a real bear to get off without MAJOR detox episodes.

by B-bunch, Dec 24, 2007 03:32AM
To: Dragonslayor
Sorry, I forgot to tell you that Neurontin is processed through your kidneys not your liver. Give it a try.

by midnightrider, Dec 29, 2007 10:15AM
To: Dragonslayor
neurontin almost killed me. my feet swelled like footballs.i was sick and toxic.this is a dangerous drug.
i have been on xanax for a long time i have horrible panic attacks.
when i got bursitius in my shoulder, i was prescribed valium for the muscle spasms. i was amazed at how much the pain was resolved but also the calming effects lasted longer than xanax.i was instructed by my pharmacy NOT to take the 2 together so i know it was the valium working better.
im going to talk to my dr about switching from xanax to valium.

i have been on all the other"monkey dope"(i.e klinopin, atarax,atavan,buspar,lexapro,all the anti depressant/anxiety "joke"pills)i call them" monkey dope" because they just dont work and some of them make your heart race and i already have A FIB .

if you have true  severe panic attacks you would find that they dont work at all they make u sleepy and thats all. youre sleepy and just scared to fall asleep.theese drugs such as valium and xanax get bad names because ppl take them for party purposes, not for the real issues, and for us with the REAL  problems "monkey dope" doesnt work.
i have had panic attacks so bad before that i would of drank yak **** if a dr said it would ease it.
i have been on xanax on and off for 10 years and never been addicted or had withdrawls. this is because i take it for the right reasons and i dont take more than im supposed to,actually i take it PRN not on a scheduled daily basis.

anyone wanting to try another route other than xanax or"monkey dope"ask your dr to  try you on  valium, works wonders.

by PRINCESS5121, Dec 29, 2007 06:19PM
To: all
general comment.im taking 1 mg xanax for the anxiety i suffered prior to TX,and still on same dose,with no side affects.valium never did a thing for me.good luck all.....

by TomD575, Jan 23, 2008 02:30PM
I would avoid Benzodiazepines for a long term treatment
About 10 years ago, a Doctor prescribed Xanax for a sleep disorder, the first couple of months were great, but my tolerance built up quickly and had to continue increasing the dosage to get the same effect, after six months I felt like a zombie.
I tired to quit cold turkey, but the withdrawal symptoms were so severe I had to go back on it.
I finally had to take 2 weeks off work to get off that poison.
The first week was unbearable, I literally couldn't leave my apartment for the first 3 days due to anxiety, severe jittery feeling, confusion, etc.
It took me 2 months before I was feeling back to normal.
Just my own experience.

by B-bunch, Jan 23, 2008 10:03PM
To: All
Stay far away from XANAX. It stays in your system and affects your nerves for years after you stop. If you have to do anything, try Klonopin or Valium, they are a little easier to detox from. Unless you enjoy hallucinations.