Nutrition Health Chat: Tuesday, Dec. 8th, 5-6 PM Eastern. Learn how vitamins, minerals, and phytonutrients affect your health. Free live Q&A. Join us!
Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum.  ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
 | 

Looking for hope

by Freechipmunk, Dec 04, 2008 09:46PM
My mother has urged me to join the Army since I turned 18.  I have always had a problem with my weight so I had been reluctant to talk to a recruiter.  I did not want to waste his or her time.  Recently I have been successful in dropping 40 lbs and have been keeping to an exercise regimen.  Under my current plan if I continue, I would meet the qualifications within 4-5 months at most.  I decided to go see a recruiter finally and learned that it is not my weight that would be an issue as that can be changed or rather, my physical fitness can be improved.  I scored 83 on the computerized pretest at the recruiting station and I'm sure that I can do better with study.  But I fear that my continued commitment to losing weight will not amount to anything because of my history of depression.  It is frustrating for me because I chose to see a mental health professional to improve myself, but in the long run this is reason for disqualification.  I am not sure what to do at this point.  As unbelievable as it may sound, they seem to give out medication for perceived mental illness without a full diagnosis.    Somehow I don't see how a 20 point questionnaire is sufficient in diagnosis.  And the diagnosis seems to vary depending on which medical professional evaluates you.  Can anyone recommend a course of action for me?  Should I seek a neurologist for brain imaging?  I just want to know for sure that I have a chemical imbalance that requires medication for treatment. I am willing to accept that I have to choose a different path in life if mental illness is my cross to bear.  I had hoped to serve in the Army for four to six years and eventually move to the FBI or NSA as an analyst, either in intelligence or finance.  But neither of these careers will even be possible if I have this label over my head for the rest of my life.  
Member Comments (2)

by monkeyc, Dec 04, 2008 10:08PM
Ok first question.

What is your diagnosis ?

Second Question - who diagnosed you?

If it was a family doctor thats not a diagnosis its at best a guess but I wonder what you consider a full diagnosis?

A psychiatrist will talk to you, they may or may not use the 20 question test (many do as a first step though I hate it) then look at your history and your symptoms and make a diagnosis based on that, there are not all that many blood tests or other tests for many mental illnesses and brain imaging is not really much use in most mental illnesses - its usefull for neurological problems but depsite what the many companies who do this (oh how I love the US health profit system) claim and the hopes of so many its not really producing any real results or conclusive diagnosis and for a chemical imbalance theyre going to be pretty much useless.

You say you have a history of depression?  Well this history alone will exempt you from military service (and if that is hard to understand you might want to consider why giving someone with depressive episodes a weapon is a bad idea) and police and a lot of other jobs - mental illness is a killer for these for very good reason (refer to previous comment vis a vis weapons).

Sadly if you have a mental illness or a history of depression you may hjave to choose another career, this is normal for all of us and it ***** quite frankly (ask me about adoption sometime and I might be able to maintain composure long enough to explain how that feels)

There are 3 questions you need to answer to yourself.

1. Do i suffer from depression
2. Does this get better when I am medicated
3. Is my goal realistic based on 1 and 2.

If you can answer no to 1 and 2 and get a diagnosis confirmed that you are not suffering from a mental illness then go and chase the dream but remember that if you are wrong or try to hide it and bluff through the process it may hurt more than your career.  

by Freechipmunk, Dec 05, 2008 07:34AM
To: Monkeyc
I have seen 6 psychiatrists in 15 years.  Initial diagnosis was major depressive disorder.  Most recent diagnosis is Bipolar II.  I have been steadily on medication for around one and a half years now without improvement.  Initially I was on Lexapro, gradually increasing from 10mg to 30mg over a six month period.  As a mood stabilizer I was given Lamictal, again gradually increasing from 50mg to my current dose of 200mg.  I have seen 3 different psychiatrists in the last year alone and every single one suggest some new medication.  The antidepressant has since changed from Lexapro to Cymbalta and now Effexor (75mg).  My moods have been much notably irratic on the medication and I am prone to crying without reason when alone.  I only sought treatment again in 2006 in the first place because I wanted a good foundation for the crappy job (complaints in retail) that I was promoted to.  I thought that an antidepressant and mood stabilizer would assist me in keeping issues in perspective.  I have a habit of taking other people's problems to seriously and get upset that I cannot help.  I understand that it takes many weeks before medication can be effective.  Do I have to start over in self evaluating the effectiveness every time my dose is increased or changed?  I see my psychiatrist every 2-3 weeks and the dose is always increased.  Again I am just frustrated.  I HATE having this label over my head all the time.  It would be different for me if I felt better, but I don't.  If things go bad, sometimes I get sad.  If things go well, I'm happy.  Sometimes I become energized by a new idea.  Sometimes I make bad decisions in relationships and finances, but who doesn't?  I can see why they would not want to give someone prone to depression a gun, but when I read the anonymous posts of soldiers who did get in, I don't understand why there isn't a place in the military for me too when I want to serve.  
Related discussions
Post Comment
To
Comment
Post Comment
Recent Activity
drifter0213 commented on snow
1 hr ago
Cherie762 gots either flu or food poisioning
Jade59 is calm and peaceful...a rare moment and I am savoring it....
BD63085 is ...hopeful
MrsMacDugle commented on 12-3-09
9 hrs ago
Dazon50 commented on photo
10 hrs ago
Jade59 commented on 12-3-09
10 hrs ago
Mood Tracker: I believe I shared my head rush?
10 hrs ago by Krisiness
RSS Expert Activity
When the Mexican Drug Trade Hits th...
16 hrs ago by Arnold L Goldman, D.V.M.
In the ER: Coffee, anyone?
Dec 02 by Jon Geller, D.V.M.
My animal blogs! 
Dec 02 by Justine Lee, D.V.M., DACVECC
Community Members