Battle of the Therapies for Bipolar and Fibromylagia(fibromyalgia)

[Sue031]

I think when I first introduced myself I wasn't very clear on my fears about treatment. I was so busy trying to help everyone understand what I was suffering from which doesn't really matter compared to everyone els' pain that I didn't make myself understood.

With my Bipolar I am being treated conventionally with the normal chemical mediation which has taken 11 years to find so you will excuse me for being a bit against trying anything new after only just stabilising. Hence my question about alternative therapy for my Fibromyalgia. I understand that Homeopathy has a relative high success rate helping with the different issues. But this would be a problem for me because there is no way I can mix the two without severe consequences. I know that alternative therapy offers much more than that which I am definately looking into.

Basically I would just like some feedback from some of the different sufferers out there that have tried Homeopathy to let me know their opinion on it from personal experience.

Thanks. I think I got it right this time.
Sue.

[Paxiled]

There is absolutely no data on how well homeopathy works for anything.  That's not to say there isn't any research on homeopathy, there is in other countries, especially lately France, but anything that lacks patentability has very little money for the kind of research that would determine in double blind studies how well any natural remedy.  Quite frankly, the data on  medication is quite deficient, using very small samples and very short term experiments.  Most medication has, at best, a 30% success rate, as measured by the few studies on depression funded by NIH.  It's tough when profit is the motivation and source of the funding.  Not much profit in homeopathy.  But it's unlikely any homeopathic remedy would interfere with any medication, since there are no active ingredients in homeopathy.  Now, amino acids, nutrients, and herbs can interfere with medication, at least theoretically, since they often target the same neurotransmitters.  For example, many herbal relaxants target GABA, the same thing targeted by benzos, so it can be a theoretical problem.  The same with serotonin targeting medications if you want to take 5htp or St. John's Wort, and of course MAOs interact badly with all kinds of things.  The best thing for homeopathy, the only thing, is to see a homeopathic physician.  Most homeopaths are trained as physicians, so they have some understanding of medication.  If you see a naturopath, they should know of these contraindications, but again, it depends on who you see and how good they are.  And doctors are downright ignorant and hostile to natural medicine, so they have no interest in these problems, for the most part.  But if you google any remedy you're considering, you should find a site that includes the theoretical contraindications.  Again, best of luck in your search.  Also, I should add that much of the natural treatment of fibromyalgia isn't remedy based, it's more nutrition and exercise and lifestyle based.  They use elimination diets and such to try to elevate energy as much as possible, keep the liver clean, which you can't do as long as you're on medication, keep the colon clean, and keep the body as uninflamed as possible.  I managed health food stores for 18 years, and my customers with fibromyalgia who did the best usually did it with nutrition more than remedies, so perhaps a visit to a holistic nutritionist might be useful.

[stella5349]

I think you might benefit some by looking at hormonal disfunctions with both BiPolar and Fibro symptoms. The thyroid really controls alot of thos symptoms.