Aa
A
A
Close
Blank
1891512 tn?1321137699
Has anyone tried 5-HTP or St. John's Wort to treat their depression
I'm considering using either 5-HTP, St. John's Wort or a type of homeopathic or another type of herbal or natural remedy for my depression instead of paxil.  I've been on paxil for over 10 years now, on and off, and right now I'm in a major depression relapse.  I was majorly depressed as a teen and the depression has come back full force.  The paxil helps a little bit but it just isn't helping enough.  Has anyone tried these or any other natural remedies?  Thanks
Cancel
6 Answers
6 Answers
Page 1 of 1
Avatar universal
I would ask a pharmacist what they think. My doc didn't recommend them to me, but she has told me of 2 OTC remedies to use for a different problem, so she is not against OTC if proven to work. Ergo, she doesn't think you should mess with OTC antidepressants.
As an example of how natural cures are not always safe, you can make natural herbal cortisol and drink it for sore joints but a physiotherapist told me there is nothing natural or safe about self controlling your cortisol levels.
OTC have not gone through trials, so the manufacturers can make any claim. There is not even a purity standard so you can't tell if one batch has the same potency as another.
Comment
Cancel
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
1891512 tn?1321137699
really - the potency could be different for each batch? i didn't even know that or think of that.  that is something to look into, thank you
Comment
Cancel
1891512 tn?1321137699
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
Avatar universal
It has never run clinical trials either.
Read my journal of Nov 23, 2009. http://www.medhelp.org/user_journals/index/676326?personal_page_id=890501
Comment
Cancel
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
1110049 tn?1409405744
I have tried both, but as I have bad clinical depression, they did not help, and I had to go back onto anti-depressants.  I think they work on mild depression, but not severe depression.  Perhaps you need to take a higher dosage of Paxil, or talk to doctor about changing your medication.  Some people say your body gets used to a drug and after a time it is not so efficient.  I have been on many, many different anti depressants over the past 20 years.
Comment
Cancel
1110049 tn?1409405744
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
Avatar universal
No idea why you are convinced they work on mild depression. It has never even been trialled. Read the link I provided. http://www.medhelp.org/user_journals/index/676326?personal_page_id=890501
Comment
Cancel
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
1042930 tn?1253202796
I have been taking 5-htp and st johns wort together and they seem to be working well.

I have tried prescription anti depressants before in the past and always decided to stop taking them after a while because the withdrawl would be horrendous when I would miss a dosage much worse than my depression in the first place.

I would say my depression is mild because I haven't been extremely suicidal or anything before getting help. I would say it has changed my life. Just making it possible to smile( was impossible for me before) and more likable and confident has been enormous. It has also given me energy to be able to function during the day. Before I was so exhausted I went to the doctor repeatedly getting labs and things looking for answers for why I was exhausted all the time.

I'm not sure why there are so many negative comments up here but they seem like they are mostly from people that haven't even tried it.
Comment
Cancel
1042930 tn?1253202796
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
Your Answer
1891512 tn?1321137699
Answer
Know how to answer? Tap here to leave your answer...
Answer
Submit Answer
A
A
Recent Activity
5938899 tn?1453692297
Blank
otakugenx added the Weight Tracker
2 hrs ago
2020005 tn?1417986816
Blank
KTowne Definitely starting to feel... Comment
4 hrs ago
2020005 tn?1417986816
Blank
KTowne commented on Des_a_rae's status
11 hrs ago
Blank
Mood Tracker
Track your mood over time
Start Tracking Now
Top Mood Disorders Answerers
Avatar m tn
Blank
Paxiled
Arlington, VA
1551327 tn?1414146344
Blank
Bubulous
Tompkinsville, KY
1415482 tn?1459706314
Blank
Kayannaboo
Kingston, Jamaica
Depression Community Resources
RSS Expert Activity
233488 tn?1310696703
Blank
Marathon Running Done Over Many Yea...
May 21 by John C Hagan III, MD, FACS, FAAOBlank
233488 tn?1310696703
Blank
New Article on Multifocal IOL vs &q...
May 21 by John C Hagan III, MD, FACS, FAAOBlank
748543 tn?1443740527
Blank
TMJ/TMJ The Connection Between Teet...
01/15 by Hamidreza Nassery , DMD, FICOI, FAGD, FICCMOBlank
Top Mood Disorders Answerers
Avatar m tn
Blank
Paxiled
Arlington, VA
1551327 tn?1414146344
Blank
Bubulous
Tompkinsville, KY
1415482 tn?1459706314
Blank
Kayannaboo
Kingston, Jamaica