If this were my child, I would definitely consider Accutane. I understand your concerns, which I take up with my patients and their parents all the time. The risks are real, but very rare. Keep in mind that Accutane has been used very extensively for over 21 years, and was tested for years before that. In my own experience, the number of Accutane patients I've seen with brain swelling is zero. As for depression, the jury is still out as to whether there is even a clear-cut cause and effect relationship between Accutane and depression. (Some teenagers get depressed anyway, unfortunately.) Also, you have to balance the risks, whatever they are, against the reality of multiple injections and embarrassing cystic acne that may well last for years and perhaps scar your child's nose.
As for the FDA warning, there are many reasons for warnings. You should consider the matter seriously, but weigh your own guilt and fear against your child's needs and the considered judgment of your doctors.
Take care.
Dr. Rockoff
My son has been on Accutane now for 2 1/2 weeks and his acne is doing SO much better. I can see the difference every day. He has only had dry lips (which is no real problem) No other side effects. Although a 5 month course seems a long time (I still don't like giving my kid this drug) we are going to stick it out if no other problems come up. Happy for now....
I just asked another question on this site because now at 1 month into Accutane my son started to get a huge amount of dandruff and a very itchy scalp. So much that he just could not stand the itching any more. I called the derm and he said to stop the accutane. I talked to several pharmasists about it and they said yes this is a problem with accutane. The derm on this site seems to disagree and says he never has heard of dry scalp problems. This doesn't make sense to me since everything else gets dry (skin, lips, eyes etc.) The accutane worked but my son was going crazy with intence itching of his head. Don't know what will happen next. Going to see the derm in a week but for now he is off the accutane.