Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum. ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
Dermatology (Expert Forum)
Cyst Removal
Answered by
Alan Rockoff, MD - dermatology, Child Skin Problems
The Rockoff Dermatology Center
Brookline - MA
Welcome to the DERMATOLOGY FORUM! Questions in this forum are answered by Dermatologists from St. Luke's Roosevelt Hospital, under the direction of Andrew Alexis, M.D., M.P.H.
Cyst Removal
by Tmcag, Aug 24, 2002 12:00AM
Sorry to bother you, but I a question about some scalp (apparently standard-issue epidermal) cysts. I had two develop a few years ago. One doesn't really bother me, it's pretty small and innocuous, but the other is in a rather prominent area where the hair is particularly thin (not related to the cysts), and it has gotten somewhat larger over the past year.
The doctors at my HMO advised me that either I should get used to it, or go in for full surgical excision. I attempted to pursue surgery, in spite of the scarring potential, I figured it wouldn't be any worse than the cyst, which is pretty noticable on its own. The problem is, when I actually went in for the surgery, I was told that scarring on the scalp would be substantially worse than on elsewhere on the body, due to the toughness of the skin (which would require a different kind of stitches used on the scalp) and the presence of hair follicles. I was a little perturbed by this (not least because I was not told anything like that when I had consulted with the surgeon until the day when the procedure was supposed to have taken place,) and put off the procedure.
Sorry about the exposition, but it leads up to several questions I had about this. Firstly, will the scarring on the scalp be substantially worse than elsewhere on the body if I have the procedure done? Secondly, are there any treatment options for removal other than full surgical excision? I've read of a few other treatments in what seemed to be credible sources, involving such processes as minimal excision technique, which might reduce the scarring due to stitches. I scheduled a later appointment with the same surgeon to ask him about these; he said he didn't know anything about it, and said I had likely misinterpreted something on draining cysts (I went back to the article, and I'm certainly not a doctor, but it seems to be a distinct procedure from drainage.) Anyhow, after talking to the surgeon, they referred me back to a regular dermatologist to discuss these options. Given the options I was given the first time around, I'm not terribly optimistic. I'd just like to note I was not demanding any particular procedure when dealing with the HMO physicians; my primary goal, which I told them, was to be able to make an informed decision, whether or not it the procedure was covered. Finally, if it's not covered, and if it can't be answered on this site, that's fine, what is the general price range for the procedures?
This whole thing has been extremely frustrating for me. Sorry, I'm normally not skeptical of doctors, but I really do feel like I've been getting the runaround on this from my HMO. I would deeply appreciate some independent opinion on the risks and options on my case, thanks. I know its not exactly a huge issue, but it really has bothered me for awhile. Thanks.
The doctors at my HMO advised me that either I should get used to it, or go in for full surgical excision. I attempted to pursue surgery, in spite of the scarring potential, I figured it wouldn't be any worse than the cyst, which is pretty noticable on its own. The problem is, when I actually went in for the surgery, I was told that scarring on the scalp would be substantially worse than on elsewhere on the body, due to the toughness of the skin (which would require a different kind of stitches used on the scalp) and the presence of hair follicles. I was a little perturbed by this (not least because I was not told anything like that when I had consulted with the surgeon until the day when the procedure was supposed to have taken place,) and put off the procedure.
Sorry about the exposition, but it leads up to several questions I had about this. Firstly, will the scarring on the scalp be substantially worse than elsewhere on the body if I have the procedure done? Secondly, are there any treatment options for removal other than full surgical excision? I've read of a few other treatments in what seemed to be credible sources, involving such processes as minimal excision technique, which might reduce the scarring due to stitches. I scheduled a later appointment with the same surgeon to ask him about these; he said he didn't know anything about it, and said I had likely misinterpreted something on draining cysts (I went back to the article, and I'm certainly not a doctor, but it seems to be a distinct procedure from drainage.) Anyhow, after talking to the surgeon, they referred me back to a regular dermatologist to discuss these options. Given the options I was given the first time around, I'm not terribly optimistic. I'd just like to note I was not demanding any particular procedure when dealing with the HMO physicians; my primary goal, which I told them, was to be able to make an informed decision, whether or not it the procedure was covered. Finally, if it's not covered, and if it can't be answered on this site, that's fine, what is the general price range for the procedures?
This whole thing has been extremely frustrating for me. Sorry, I'm normally not skeptical of doctors, but I really do feel like I've been getting the runaround on this from my HMO. I would deeply appreciate some independent opinion on the risks and options on my case, thanks. I know its not exactly a huge issue, but it really has bothered me for awhile. Thanks.
Doctor's Answer
by Alan Rockoff, MD, Aug 25, 2002 12:00AM
, Aug 25, 2002 12:00AM
I'm not much of a surgeon, but I remove scalp cysts pretty often and they seem to heal fine, with little noticeable scarring. The technique I use (annd this may be the "minimal" one you read about, is to make a small incision, squeeze the cysts contents out to decompress it, and then pull the cyst wall out through the small hole. Surgeons tend to make longer incisions, which would explain their comment about the extensiveness of the scar.
Anyhow, your dermatologist may well be able to expand on or do this. I can certainly understand why you'd want a prominent protrusion removed from your head. I think you'll be able to get satisfactory results, and in my experience, when it comes to things that grow on the face and scalp, insurance usually covers. If it doesn't, I'd guess the fee to be in the $2-300 range, though this is of course just a guesstimate.
Good luck.
Dr. Rockoff
Anyhow, your dermatologist may well be able to expand on or do this. I can certainly understand why you'd want a prominent protrusion removed from your head. I think you'll be able to get satisfactory results, and in my experience, when it comes to things that grow on the face and scalp, insurance usually covers. If it doesn't, I'd guess the fee to be in the $2-300 range, though this is of course just a guesstimate.
Good luck.
Dr. Rockoff
After a few weeks of this, it finally had a very small 'head' on it, and I was able to remove it myself. (a very gross thing to see on yourself, and to do) I have a very tiny scar where it was, but it has not come back since.
I have heard positive and negative things about what I had done, but the end result was ok. Was there a possible risk??