DERMATOLOGY EXPERT FORUM
hair pull test question

hair pull test question

I’m not looking for a diagnosis.  I’m not looking to go to a dermatologist to get any sort of additional tests done.  I simply need some clarification.  I am a person who likes to ask things twice.
I am almost 29 years-old and am a white male.  There is no appearance of balding on my scalp.  However, I do have (and have had) a portion of my hair at the crown area that lays flat.  This has been described to me as a sort of “reverse” cowlick.  Rather than sticking straight up, this section of hair growth swings at an angle and lays down flat against my scalp.
My question revolves around a hair-pull test in this specific area.  My physician was doing a hair-pull test, and noted that the results did NOT indicate active balding or miniaturization on my scalp.  At the area where my hair lays flat, however, she commented on something unusual.  She did a hair-pull test in this area, and only pulled out a very few hairs.  She remarked that the hairs that actually did come out looked like a few vellus hair.  I asked her what this meant.  She stated that even though thicker, actively growing hairs were prevalent, the hair-pull test only showed the removal of a few vellus hairs because of the way my hair grows in that location.  She explained that because the hair grows at an angle and lies flat, it is more difficult to pull straight up on the hair to perform the test.  As a result, the only hairs that were pulled out during that portion of the test were a few vellus hairs since they are already shallowly rooted and possibly more exposed because of the way my hair lays flat.  She said that the removal of these few vellus hairs was not an indication of balding or miniaturization.  Rather, it was simply a result of the way that my hair grows and lies in that area.
My question is:
Does this explanation from my physician make sense to you as a dermatologist?  Is this a reasonable sounding explanation?
Thank you.
Related Discussions
242489_tn?1210500813
Yes, it does make sense.  The hair pull test is not a very precise one, however.  It rally doesn't tell you whether you're balding, at least whether you're losing your hair in a genetic way, since that kind of hair loss is slow and you wouldn't get a lot of hairs on a pull test, vellus or otherwise.  I think what your doctor meant to say is that getting some vellus hairs on a pull doesn't mean much, which I agree with.  

Best.

Dr. Rockoff
Blank
Continue discussion Blank
Go
MedHelp Health Answers
Submit
Blank
Weight Tracker
Reach your weight goal faster
Start Tracking Now
RSS Expert Activity
1741471_tn?1329053231
Blank
Love, endorphins and biochemistry. ... Blank
22 hrs ago by Michael Gonzalez-WallaceBlank
1684282_tn?1311133646
Blank
Pregnancy and Addiction
Feb 14 by Julia M Aharonov, DOBlank
514494_tn?1329196433
Blank
What's the Best Type of Mattress?
Feb 13 by Adam Tanase, D.C.Blank