Are doctors legally and ethically allowed to treat a problem symptomatically in the absence of a medical diagnosis?
I’ve had recurring severe inflammation in extra-ocular muscles for about ten years. An attack typically involves degrees of muscle paralysis, diplopia and orbital swelling and will leave me, for all intents and purposes, partially blinded and incapacitated for anywhere from two months to a year. I’ve had more than 3 dozen appointments with more than a dozen doctors (neurologists, neuro-ophthalmologists, ophthalmologists, rheumatologists, ENT specialists) who have given me every imaginable test (multiple MRIs, carotid ultrasounds, EKGs, full sinus and inner ear exams, paranasal CT scans, comprehensive neurological tests, extensive rheumatology tests, etc.). Everything always came back normal with the exception of a positive histone antibody test.
I still don’t have a diagnosis and have had little that can be called focused treatment. What treatment I had was limited to two periods of extended use of high levels of prednisone to relieve significant episodes of orbital swelling in order to avoid permanent loss of eyesight. That would partially relieve the problem for the period I was taking the medicine and for a handful of months afterwards, but it would always return.
I accidentally discovered a few years ago that a relatively small amount of prednisone (10 mg every other day) and two ibuprofen tablets a day keep me 100 percent symptom free with no apparent side effects. They only work in combination; neither prednisone nor ibuprofen does much of anything on its own (a fact that strikes me as diagnostically interesting). It’s also worth mentioning that I also get relief from what I think are hypothyroid symptoms: excessive and unexplained weight gain; severe tinnitus; edema; skin lesions on the legs and abdomen; problems with muscle response; excessively high blood pressure; etc. I have never noted any negative side effects.
In the absence of a diagnosis I’m unable to get a prescription for the $18 a year of prednisone that would leave me symptom-free and allow me to function normally. Doctors tell me, perhaps understandably in this litigious age, that they can’t prescribe if they can’t identify the illness that they’re prescribing for. The practical result is that I’m sitting here incapacitated, unable to drive and barely able to read, and only marginally able to function even though I know that there’s something that actually relieves the problem. What do I do?
Wow, this is tough one to respond to. I'm sorry about all your problems. In 12 years of practice I've had 2 patients I remember well who had similar type orbital problems - just as in your case, however, we were never able to absolutely pin down any specific findings or diagnosis. Perhaps the best advice I can give is to pick the very best doctor out of the all the one you see - the one who listens the best, the one who has the best skill and grasp on your situation and try to build a relationship with him/her. At some point the doctor may be able to get to know you and your situation better and be better able to deal with it. Sometime trial and error is needed. You're not going to be able to treat this alone - you need a doctor you can work with together. Doctors can treat symptoms alone but they have to be convinced that the treatment won't hurt you - not just for medical legal reason - but just to do the right thing. Be very careful of all the numerous prednisone side effects - weight gain, hypertenion, secondary diabetes, osteoporosis, bleeding peptic ulcer disease, cataracts, glaucoma etc, etc. I wish you the best.
Michael Kutryb, MD
Thanks for the advice. I know that prolonged prednisone use is not wise even when it is only 10 mg every other day. I despise the stuff and, in fact, stopped using it on my own and sought out a doctor with whom to discuss the odd results I was getting and to set up a relationship where I could continue that or a comparable treatment under their supervision. Not much luck there. I haven’t had a very good run of luck finding doctors who will listen to me.
As a practical matter, the problems of not using prednisone seem to me to be far worse than the risks associated with using it. When using the low dose prednisone-ibuprofen combination, I’ve had complete relief of orbital swelling, full recovery of ocular muscle movement, elimination of tinnitus, elimination of edema and loss of 60 pounds, reduction of blood pressure from 190/110 to 120/80, elimination of skin lesions, and elimination of impaired muscle response times. I also had vast improvements in my mood, ability to concentrate, and general mental acuity. I don’t know what it’s doing (I suspect it’s mildly suppressing my overall immune response – a task that my cigarette smoking probably performed twelve years ago before I quit), but I know it works. Somehow, though, the reasoning of my doctors seems to be that it is better for me to live with these symptoms and risk stroke, severe hypertension and renal failure, vision-induced accidents, loss of eyesight, inability to work, and profound depression than to risk the dangers associated with a pulsed dose of 10 mg of prednisone every other day. The logic, I'm afraid, just escapes me.
This site complies with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information.
The Content on this Site is presented in a summary fashion, and is intended to be used for educational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended to be and should not be interpreted as medical advice or a diagnosis of any health or fitness problem, condition or disease; or a recommendation for a specific test, doctor, care provider, procedure, treatment plan, product, or course of action. Med Help International, Inc. is not a medical or healthcare provider and your use of this Site does not create a doctor / patient relationship. We disclaim all responsibility for the professional qualifications and licensing of, and services provided by, any physician or other health providers posting on or otherwise referred to on this Site and/or any Third Party Site. Never disregard the medical advice of your physician or health professional, or delay in seeking such advice, because of something you read on this Site. We offer this Site AS IS and without any warranties. By using this Site you agree to the following Terms and Conditions. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your physician or 911 immediately.