Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum. ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
Gastroenterology (Expert Forum)
Role of Lactobaccilli (Acidophillus) and Celiac Sprue
Answered by
Kevin Pho, MD - Internal Medicine
KevinMD.com
This forum is for questions regarding Gastroenterology issues such as Acid Reflux (GERD), Barretts Esophagus, Colitis, Colon/Bowel Disorders, Crohn's Disease, Diverticulitis/Diverticulosis, Digestive Disorders, IBS, Stomach Pain.
Role of Lactobaccilli (Acidophillus) and Celiac Sprue
by fullmergavin, Apr 12, 2005 12:00AM
While the structure of this question may be a bit odd, I was hoping that you would be able to offer some insight into these questions.
The problem I have w/ Celiac Sprue are the known sensitivities w/ baking soda (Sodium bicarbonate). There is nothing in bs that leads one to suspect that it may contain gluten. To my understanding, if there has ever been one ingrediant to which Celiacs are more sensitive, it has proven to be baking soda.
Based on the secondary possibilities that could be involved with the gliadin antibody test(MSG, or all lectins, etc), the one area of fascination for me now is Lactobaccilli (Acidophillus).
If damage to the villi or Galt tissue (ETC.) takes place, is it possible the real problem behind Celiac could be an issue with Lactate? While the health food stores are telling us that "We can't get enough of Acidophillus," what is being ignored is that Lactobaccilli is already put into all of the dairy and wheat products at a greater ratio than other foods, to my understanding. In the presence of a "Leaky gut," wouldn't lactate than be hitting the blood?Across the internet, I have managed to find only one article covering Lactobaccilli overgrowth (A "Step short" of Lactic Acidosis). According to the physician, the effective treatment is antibiotics and sodium bicarbonate.
My question is, why would those with Celiac respond negatively to baking soda? The signs of "Candida" are just swarming around the case studies relating to Celiac, but now I can't help but wonder whether or not some of these Candida (The conveniant label)overgrowths may not be Lactobaccilli. And if that would be the case, may the only requirement than be a "Leaky gut" for this to become a systemic issue?
But again, if this was part of the problem, why would they ever respond to baking soda (Alkaline) negatively, in the same way as gluten (Acidic)? Could you explain what you know about the differences in stomach/intestinal PH, and that of blood PH? I know it is preferable to maintain an acidic lower GI, but that's about it.
Why do some acidic foods have an acidic effect on the system, while other acidic foods (Vinegar, certain forms of barley, etc) actually have an alkaline affect on the blood stream? While many believe that Lactobaccilli (Acid=end product lactate)produce an acidic affect on the intestines, they go onto say this does the opposite w/ the bloodstream (Lacticacidosis=acidic lower bowel, yet leads to an alkaline effect on the bloodstream). Seems to be a common pattern in other words=Some acidic foods have a reverse effect on the bloodstream, while others do not. With alkaline foods, they seem to = alkaline blood across the board. WOuld all of these beliefs still hold true if there was any damage to the mucus layer ("Leaky gut", etc)?
Finally, based on historical literature,is it beneficial or bad for those with a history of lowerGI/stomach (Celiac, bacteria ulcers, etc)to take Hydrocholric Acid/Pepsin? Thanks
The problem I have w/ Celiac Sprue are the known sensitivities w/ baking soda (Sodium bicarbonate). There is nothing in bs that leads one to suspect that it may contain gluten. To my understanding, if there has ever been one ingrediant to which Celiacs are more sensitive, it has proven to be baking soda.
Based on the secondary possibilities that could be involved with the gliadin antibody test(MSG, or all lectins, etc), the one area of fascination for me now is Lactobaccilli (Acidophillus).
If damage to the villi or Galt tissue (ETC.) takes place, is it possible the real problem behind Celiac could be an issue with Lactate? While the health food stores are telling us that "We can't get enough of Acidophillus," what is being ignored is that Lactobaccilli is already put into all of the dairy and wheat products at a greater ratio than other foods, to my understanding. In the presence of a "Leaky gut," wouldn't lactate than be hitting the blood?Across the internet, I have managed to find only one article covering Lactobaccilli overgrowth (A "Step short" of Lactic Acidosis). According to the physician, the effective treatment is antibiotics and sodium bicarbonate.
My question is, why would those with Celiac respond negatively to baking soda? The signs of "Candida" are just swarming around the case studies relating to Celiac, but now I can't help but wonder whether or not some of these Candida (The conveniant label)overgrowths may not be Lactobaccilli. And if that would be the case, may the only requirement than be a "Leaky gut" for this to become a systemic issue?
But again, if this was part of the problem, why would they ever respond to baking soda (Alkaline) negatively, in the same way as gluten (Acidic)? Could you explain what you know about the differences in stomach/intestinal PH, and that of blood PH? I know it is preferable to maintain an acidic lower GI, but that's about it.
Why do some acidic foods have an acidic effect on the system, while other acidic foods (Vinegar, certain forms of barley, etc) actually have an alkaline affect on the blood stream? While many believe that Lactobaccilli (Acid=end product lactate)produce an acidic affect on the intestines, they go onto say this does the opposite w/ the bloodstream (Lacticacidosis=acidic lower bowel, yet leads to an alkaline effect on the bloodstream). Seems to be a common pattern in other words=Some acidic foods have a reverse effect on the bloodstream, while others do not. With alkaline foods, they seem to = alkaline blood across the board. WOuld all of these beliefs still hold true if there was any damage to the mucus layer ("Leaky gut", etc)?
Finally, based on historical literature,is it beneficial or bad for those with a history of lowerGI/stomach (Celiac, bacteria ulcers, etc)to take Hydrocholric Acid/Pepsin? Thanks
Doctor's Answer
by Kevin Pho, MD, Apr 14, 2005 12:00AM
, Apr 14, 2005 12:00AM
The concept of "leaky gut" syndrome and candida in the GI tract has not been conclusively proven in the medical literature.
Celiac disease is caused by an abnormal reaction of the immune system to gluten - and clears up once gluten is removed from the diet.
I am not aware of a connection between Celiac disease and the ingestion of baking soda.
To diagnose the disease, you can consider blood tests looking for endomysial antibodies to confirm the diagnosis.
Treatment should be focused on eliminating gluten from the diet, rather than the acidy and alkalinity of foods. This can be discussed with your personal physician or in conjunction with a nutritionist.
Followup with your personal physician is essential.
This answer is not intended as and does not substitute for medical advice - the information presented is for patient education only. Please see your personal physician for further evaluation of your individual case.
Kevin, M.D.
Medical Weblog:
kevinmd_b
Celiac disease is caused by an abnormal reaction of the immune system to gluten - and clears up once gluten is removed from the diet.
I am not aware of a connection between Celiac disease and the ingestion of baking soda.
To diagnose the disease, you can consider blood tests looking for endomysial antibodies to confirm the diagnosis.
Treatment should be focused on eliminating gluten from the diet, rather than the acidy and alkalinity of foods. This can be discussed with your personal physician or in conjunction with a nutritionist.
Followup with your personal physician is essential.
This answer is not intended as and does not substitute for medical advice - the information presented is for patient education only. Please see your personal physician for further evaluation of your individual case.
Kevin, M.D.
Medical Weblog:
kevinmd_b
For me avoiding everything that contains any of the 3 is working brilliantly. My breathing is clear as a bell and my gut is very content. I might be able to narrow down the problem to just soy or maybe not - i'm feeling so good I don't want to rock the boat at the moment.
best of luck