Aa
Aa
A
A
A
Close
Avatar universal

your opinion please.

Hello Doctor. I posted a few weeks ago on an a single episode of brief (less than a minute) unprotected vaginal sex with a friend of unknown status. I am aware of the forum rules and I will not be posting again after this, I just had some follow up questions. To refresh your memory I am a white, male, hetero, non drug user, no STDs. The girl is hetero, non drug user. When I told you of my episode I said that my only symptoms reflected a bronchitis infection I had simultaneously with the episode. Now that I look back I remember that day or two after the episode, I noticed minor nail pitting (several small pin sized indents) on one of my fingernails. I am not sure how long it takes for HIV to infect the fingernails but I heard that nail pitting is a sign of psoriasis which is can be an early indicator of HIV. I have no discoloration or pitting on any other nail, just several small indents on a single nail. I have had minor nail pitting every now and then even way before this episode ever happened, I guess this time just worries me because it happened coincidentally with an unprotected episode.
  I have also done some research on HIV transmission among low risk heteros. I found many articles that support the idea that the only risk heteros have is when they put themselves at risk with a member of a high risk group (secondary transmission). Any other transmission following that would be considered tertiary transmission (meaning the infected low risk person passing it on to another low risk heterosexual.) Many people suggest that tertiary transmission simply does not happen and when it does it is due to repeated exposure. A big advocate of this theory is Michael Fumento (author of "Myth of Heterosexual AIDS"). Since authors can write whatever they want it is hard to trust them. I figure since you are a doctor and have an STD clinic, you can answer some follow up questions I have. And then I promise I'll leave you alone.

1) Would HIV cause psoriasis to flare up as quick as two days? And is minor nail pitting alone enough to diagnose psoriasis?

2) Would having bronchitis during my sexual episode increase my vulnerability to HIV?

3) Do you agree with those who say that tertiary transmission, or any heterosexual transmission for that matter, requires repeated exposure to HIV to have a significant chance of infection?

4) Is an episode of vaginal sex lasting less than a minute usually long enough to transmit enough of the virus to the male to become infected? given that she even has HIV.

5) In all your practicing years have you ever handled or heard of a case of a low risk heterosexual male becoming infected after a single episode of vaginal sex with a low risk female. especially a brief one?

Your service is amazing and very helpful. Being a college student, after this experience and seeing doctors like you who care, I am strongly considering going into the medical field. Thank you very much.
3 Responses
Sort by: Helpful Oldest Newest
239123 tn?1267647614
MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL
1) If psoriasis can be a harbinger of HIV infection, it is news to me.  If so, it certainly is very rare.  Nail pitting due to psoriasis (or anything else) cannot appear in 2 days.  The pits develop under the nail bed, where the nail is being formed and are not visible until nail growth brings them onto the external part of the nail, i.e. several weeks at minimum.

2) I doubt bronchitis increases the risk of HIV infection, but no data are available.

3) "Tertiary transmission" is not a standard term and despite your explanation, I don't know what you mean by it.  HIV transmission risk is low for any kind of sexual exposure, but of course increases with the number of exposures.  Fumento was wacko and his book discredited 20 years ago.

4) Could it happen?  Sure.  Does it happen with measurable frequency?  No.  Should you worry about HIV if that is your only exposure?  You know the answer.

5) Nope.

No follow-up questions, please.  Even this one was right at the edge of being deleted without response.  Let it go.

HHH, MD
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
I believe psorisis is also hereditary.  Does anyone else in your family have it?  I know my grandfather, aunt, and a few cousins have it.  My grandfather died of old age.  And my aunt and cousins are hiv negative.  Jeez, everything is an early sign of hiv these days.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
From my research and what I have been told, your chances of getting HIV are extremely low (1/2000) and that is if your partner is infact infected.  The odds are extremely less considering that you don't know your partners HIV status.  

Helpful - 0

You are reading content posted in the HIV - Prevention Forum

Popular Resources
Condoms are the most effective way to prevent HIV and STDs.
PrEP is used by people with high risk to prevent HIV infection.
Can I get HIV from surfaces, like toilet seats?
Can you get HIV from casual contact, like hugging?
Frequency of HIV testing depends on your risk.
Post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) may help prevent HIV infection.