Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum. ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
HIV Prevention (Expert Forum)
ars rash?
Answered by
Edward W Hook, MD - HIV Prevention, stds
ars rash?
by joejack269, Aug 11, 2009 01:31PM
Hi Doctor,
I had unprotected sex (insertive vaginal) with a woman who I now know had two previous unprotected encounters. A few weeks later, I developed a red, slightly raised rash on one side of my face. It doesn't seem to be bumpy anywhere, just red, flat and raised.
It started out as a small red area, about the size of a nickel. The next day it had spread, and was now blotchy and covered most of my cheek. It felt hot and tingled slightly. The next day it had spread just behind my ear and slightly down my neck. It was now less blotchy and looked more like a few solid thick red streaks on my face. It became more and more itchy over the next few days. I eventually saw my GP who was stumped, but prescribed 1% hydrocortisone cream, which seems to have brought it down to the point where it doesn't itch and is just barely noticeable. The rash has lasted about 10 days, the last three of which it's been hardly there.
I was tested for std's, and I was treated for gonorrhea/chlamydia. This was after the rash appeared. At that point, I also had a HIV rapid-test done, which was negative. This was at about 3 weeks post-exposure. Other than the rash, I've had no ARS symptoms (fever, swollen glands, etc).
My questions are:
1. Does this rash sound like it could be HIV related? I know with only one exposure, the odds are in my favor. I've heard that the rash is usually more on the trunk as well as the face and neck, is not unilateral, and isn't itchy..but I've also read that it can be.
2. If it were an ARS related rash, would it respond to hydrocortisone?
3. How likely is it to have acute HIV and have a rash as the only symptom? Do the rash and fever usually go hand-in-hand, or is it possible to only have the rash?
4. I know 3 months is the ideal time for rapid testing. However, I've also read that if symptoms are present, it's likely to test positive. If indeed the rash was HIV related, would it have shown up in the test, or is it still too soon after the exposure?
Thanks
I had unprotected sex (insertive vaginal) with a woman who I now know had two previous unprotected encounters. A few weeks later, I developed a red, slightly raised rash on one side of my face. It doesn't seem to be bumpy anywhere, just red, flat and raised.
It started out as a small red area, about the size of a nickel. The next day it had spread, and was now blotchy and covered most of my cheek. It felt hot and tingled slightly. The next day it had spread just behind my ear and slightly down my neck. It was now less blotchy and looked more like a few solid thick red streaks on my face. It became more and more itchy over the next few days. I eventually saw my GP who was stumped, but prescribed 1% hydrocortisone cream, which seems to have brought it down to the point where it doesn't itch and is just barely noticeable. The rash has lasted about 10 days, the last three of which it's been hardly there.
I was tested for std's, and I was treated for gonorrhea/chlamydia. This was after the rash appeared. At that point, I also had a HIV rapid-test done, which was negative. This was at about 3 weeks post-exposure. Other than the rash, I've had no ARS symptoms (fever, swollen glands, etc).
My questions are:
1. Does this rash sound like it could be HIV related? I know with only one exposure, the odds are in my favor. I've heard that the rash is usually more on the trunk as well as the face and neck, is not unilateral, and isn't itchy..but I've also read that it can be.
2. If it were an ARS related rash, would it respond to hydrocortisone?
3. How likely is it to have acute HIV and have a rash as the only symptom? Do the rash and fever usually go hand-in-hand, or is it possible to only have the rash?
4. I know 3 months is the ideal time for rapid testing. However, I've also read that if symptoms are present, it's likely to test positive. If indeed the rash was HIV related, would it have shown up in the test, or is it still too soon after the exposure?
Thanks
Doctor's Answer
by Edward W Hook, MD, Aug 11, 2009 02:01PM
, Aug 11, 2009 02:01PM
The likelihood that what you have is ARS is miniscule. That your partner had other partners before you is not abnormal, it is normal. In addition, you had only a single exposure. Since I presume that if this women was an IV drug user you would have said so, my guess is that the odds of your partner having HIV are less than 1 in 1000 and that your risk from a single episode of vaginal sex is 1 in a thousand, even before we start to consider your symptoms, your risk of HIV form the encounter you describe is 1 in a million or less.
As for your symptoms, they do not sound like ARS. The rash is only one part of the ARS; when people have the ARS they also have fevers, muscle aches and the rash is typically present over the trunk, back and abdomen, not just the face. Your rash really has none of the typical characteristics of the rash associated with HIV.
One question form me however before I address your questions. Did you have gonorrhea or chlamydia or was the doctor just treating your anxiety about this exposure?
As for your specific questions:
1. No, your rash really has none of the typical characteristics of the ARS rash.
2. No, the rash of ARS would not be expected to respond to hydrocortisone.
3. Unlikely. There are no real statistics on this however.
4. In your situation, a blood test at any time 6-8 weeks following exposure can be assumed to be an accurate reflection of your HIV status. If you get tested at that time, when the result is negative, believe them.
Hope this helps. there really is nothing in the events you describe to suggest that there is any risk for HIV or that your rash might be related to HIV. I hope my comments help. EWH
As for your symptoms, they do not sound like ARS. The rash is only one part of the ARS; when people have the ARS they also have fevers, muscle aches and the rash is typically present over the trunk, back and abdomen, not just the face. Your rash really has none of the typical characteristics of the rash associated with HIV.
One question form me however before I address your questions. Did you have gonorrhea or chlamydia or was the doctor just treating your anxiety about this exposure?
As for your specific questions:
1. No, your rash really has none of the typical characteristics of the ARS rash.
2. No, the rash of ARS would not be expected to respond to hydrocortisone.
3. Unlikely. There are no real statistics on this however.
4. In your situation, a blood test at any time 6-8 weeks following exposure can be assumed to be an accurate reflection of your HIV status. If you get tested at that time, when the result is negative, believe them.
Hope this helps. there really is nothing in the events you describe to suggest that there is any risk for HIV or that your rash might be related to HIV. I hope my comments help. EWH
To answer your question, I had symptoms of gonorrhea (painful urination, yellow discharge) and was treated. I haven't received the results yet, but I think it's fair to assume it was positive.