Cholesterol reduction and oatmeal

[wildcat27]

I can never seem to get a straight answer on this one...

Is the regular Quaker Oatmeal that comes in the big cylinder better at helping reduce cholesterol levels than the instant stuff that comes in the box and has different flavors?

I have been eating oatmeal for breakfast for this purpose for a while...but don't want to continue eating the instant if it doesn't really work...

Thanks

[anacyde]

For those who aren't oatmeal fans, Cheerios are an excellent alternative.  High fiber, low fat, that's the way to go.

[wildcat27]

could I get the same positive benefit from eating something else with the same amount of soluble fiber...cereal, etc?

[Sweetwaterguy]

Please excuse me for not remembering the source, although I do believe it may be the South Beach Heart Program.  The author indicated regular oat meal was best and slightly better than the quick cook oat meal.  The instant packets have too much sugar and are recommended even less.  Both the regular and quick cook oatmeal are  labled 100% rolled oats, so I don't know why one might be better than the other.  

[anacyde]

DON'T EAT THE INSTANT OATMEAL.  If you want lower cholesterol, that stuff will push you in the wrong direction.  The trans fat in instant oatmeal (seen as partially hydrogenated oil) will RAISE your cholesterol.  It not only negates the positive effect of oatmeal, it causes more problems.

Case in point: my husband cut out nothing but trans fat from his diet, after the doctor recommended a statin since his number was pushing 200.  Three months later, after changing nothing but trans fat removal, his cholesterol was 134.  No kidding.  It has remained in the 130-150 range for several years now.  We're trans fat-free here.  We do eat Quaker oats regularly, the kind you buy plain and cook on the stove.

[Pepperliveson]

Trader Joes sells an instant oatmeal called "Heart Healthy Oatmeal" - blueberry or cranberry flavored w/ no partially hydrogenated oils (so no trans fats).  It's quite good - also has plant stanols in it but I think the jury is still out on whether those lower cholesterol.

[myowncrazybeat]

I once read, on a frugal mom's website, the flavored packets of oatmeal are the same as the large old-fashioned oats, they are just cut down more and of course flavored.  I like the idea of checking the fiber content.  :)  If you like the taste/texture of the packets, you can use a food chopper or processor to cut the larger oats down and then flavor it yourself.  I often do this for my children... and myself.  :)

[Pepperliveson]

It's the soluble fiber in oatmeal that lowers your cholesterol.  Check out how many grams of soluble fiber each one has and than eat the one with the most.  It has worked wonders for me.

[Rag123]

I can't say for sure if one reduces more than the other, but I eat the original oatmeal, not the flavored one because it has no artificial flavorings and has a higher nutrient count and zero sodium.

I would take an educated guess that the more natural one will have more of an impact on your overall chloresteral.
It's just a heathier product...