You had a second angiogram where it showed the fractured stent. I assume that although it contains fractures, the cardiologist is happy with there being little restriction to blood flow through the stent. It has come to light that perhaps cardiologists need to rethink blockage sizes. At present anything 70% and above is treated with stents or bypass, but anything left is not seen as urgent. It is now apparent that some people feel discomforts with blockages of small sizes. Lots of patients go to hospital with chest pains, yet only small blockages are found on angiograms and other reasons are searched for. In most cases, there are no other reasons so it is assumed that smaller blockages can cause angina.
The cardiologist who mentioned scar tissue was correct, and this is a big problem with bare metal stents. In an ideal situation, you want the artery to grow a nice new smooth lining through the stent. However, scar tissue forms first and this grows quickly and to enough of a degree in many cases to form a serious blockage. This is exactly why the newer drug eluting stents were developed. They have a drug coating which inhibits scar tissue from forming, but allows the new smooth lining to grow.
I would seek a second opinion and tell them you definitely have strong angina symptoms which is ruining your quality of life. They can access a copy of your angiogram if you tell them the hospital before hand, to give them time to get the copy for your meeting.
I think its sometimes possible to put a drug eluting stent inside a bare metal stent, but I'm guessing it wouldn't be wise if it's fractured. I do believe there are special tools and methods to extract stents, they basically have hooks which collapse the stent into a sheath for extraction. Again, probably tricky with fractures but the second opion should cover all these topics. Please let us know what they say and be tough, it's your life. You don't want to spend the rest of it feeling like you do.
Get a second opinion for sure. One would think that a cath would be in order to make sure the area hasn't occluded again. A CT scan or MRI might also help to make sure it's not causing problems. Best of luck.