Aa
beta blocker alternatives
I currently take Norvasc (10mg) and Tenoretic (25 mg). Norvasc is at least my 6th drug for blood pressure. It is usually controlled for a month or 2 then uncontrolled going to 200/100. They added the beta blocker which controlled it efficiently but then i was hospitalized with hyponatremia and hypokalemia. The musle cramps were incredibly severe and frequent and the fatigue was overwhelming along with dry mouth. My doctor moved on and now i am seeing another doctor (internist) and he has put me back on the Tenoretic but at 1/2 the dose. It was fine for about a month. I had some minor muscle fatigue but tried combatting it by taking potassium and eating healthy. It is growing worse. I now have daily muscle ache and dry mouth. I do strength training 3 times a week and have a very healthy, active lifestyle but cannot attend this week because of the pain. I don't want to feel this way anymore. I am far too young to feel so old and achy. Walking up the stairs causes pain in my thighs as if I have just had a very hard work out or ran a marathon. Brushing my hair makes my arms ache the same way. The cramps are slowly returning to my face and feet. What alternatives can i ask my physician to try? The beta blocker controls my blood pressure quite well (for the 1st time in at least 15 yrs!). There must be an alternative though. I need good questions/facts to share with my physician so i can get back to healthy! Thank you very much!! Christian Nichols
My husband has serious side effects from many BP medications and
have discovered over the years that magnesium citrate (170 mg) taken on an empty stomach or inbetween meals (for him 4 days a week as he is on dialysis) has been extremely helpful for his body to deal with some of the BP medications he really needs as it is known as the "stress mineral" and a precursor of the "stress B vitamins" with over 300 enzymes needed to use the b vitamins it can help the body to deal with all types of stress. He literally cannot tolerate any meds without it.
have discovered over the years that magnesium citrate (170 mg) taken on an empty stomach or inbetween meals (for him 4 days a week as he is on dialysis) has been extremely helpful for his body to deal with some of the BP medications he really needs as it is known as the "stress mineral" and a precursor of the "stress B vitamins" with over 300 enzymes needed to use the b vitamins it can help the body to deal with all types of stress. He literally cannot tolerate any meds without it.
How about those perscribed BB for reasons other than high BP? I have Tetrollogy of the Fallot and for the first time I'm having frequent palpitations. My doctor perscribed a BB, but with all the side effects I'm reading about- I'm hesitent to try them. I'm only 28 and enjoy triathlons and want to go into the Navy. Being on BB will exclude me
I have been on atenelol for about 2 years now (I am 45). It is a Beta Blocker. I had the muscle fatigue in the beginning, especially since I need a high dose for it to work. ( 50mg x 2 a day. Most of that got better after around 6 months. It has a big side effect at that dose of lowering my pulse to 40 beats a minute less than normal though. Luckily, my HR before meds is in the 90's resting, so Doc says 50's resting is OK.
As for the bananas, I think "natural beta-blocker" is quite an exaggeration and not a very good analogy. However, there are lots of studies that foods high in potassium can help combat some of the bad effects of sodium on BP. Of course, this is in tandem with an excellent diet, weight control, excercise, etc. They do not stop your body from producing Norepinephrine ,which beta blockers do. Oh, and for the record, if you do want to increase potassium intake......bananas are great....but half a cup of raisins have 50% more potassium, and a medium sized white potato with skin has double that of a banana.
On last note, I tried many meds for around 5 years to get a med that works....of course the doc started with the newest (and most expensive) ones first and ended up on with one of the most affordable beta blockers out there, the atenelol. So, don't give up hope. I am sure you will get the right plan eventually.
Mark
As for the bananas, I think "natural beta-blocker" is quite an exaggeration and not a very good analogy. However, there are lots of studies that foods high in potassium can help combat some of the bad effects of sodium on BP. Of course, this is in tandem with an excellent diet, weight control, excercise, etc. They do not stop your body from producing Norepinephrine ,which beta blockers do. Oh, and for the record, if you do want to increase potassium intake......bananas are great....but half a cup of raisins have 50% more potassium, and a medium sized white potato with skin has double that of a banana.
On last note, I tried many meds for around 5 years to get a med that works....of course the doc started with the newest (and most expensive) ones first and ended up on with one of the most affordable beta blockers out there, the atenelol. So, don't give up hope. I am sure you will get the right plan eventually.
Mark
Chrissie67,
Sorry to hear you are struggling with meds and BP control. I experienced the muscle fatigue when I first started taking an ACE inhibitor so I think I understand your frustration. Has your doctor suggested a different BB? I took BB's for a long time and had the most success and comfort with Inderal. While a lot of patients have had great success with tenormin, it gave me awful side effects to my central nervous system. Since the BB seems to help with the BP, maybe just trying a different would help.
As you probably know, too much or too little potassium can lead to complications. Since bananas are loaded with potassium, be careful not to consume more than you need. Potassium is an important electrolyte for muscle cells and nerves, but having a stable level is equially important. Have you had recent blood work to get a current potassium level? Best of luck in finding the right combination of medication, exercise, etc.
smurfy925,
I'm not sure where you heard/read that bananas are a natural beta blocker. I agree that bananas may provide a calming effect, but I would not equate them to beta blockers. Some people find that bananas can reduce anxiety, but as far as I know, they have no medicinal effect on BP. Can you let us know where you heard that bananas are BB's? Thanks!! Have a great day!!
connie
Sorry to hear you are struggling with meds and BP control. I experienced the muscle fatigue when I first started taking an ACE inhibitor so I think I understand your frustration. Has your doctor suggested a different BB? I took BB's for a long time and had the most success and comfort with Inderal. While a lot of patients have had great success with tenormin, it gave me awful side effects to my central nervous system. Since the BB seems to help with the BP, maybe just trying a different would help.
As you probably know, too much or too little potassium can lead to complications. Since bananas are loaded with potassium, be careful not to consume more than you need. Potassium is an important electrolyte for muscle cells and nerves, but having a stable level is equially important. Have you had recent blood work to get a current potassium level? Best of luck in finding the right combination of medication, exercise, etc.
smurfy925,
I'm not sure where you heard/read that bananas are a natural beta blocker. I agree that bananas may provide a calming effect, but I would not equate them to beta blockers. Some people find that bananas can reduce anxiety, but as far as I know, they have no medicinal effect on BP. Can you let us know where you heard that bananas are BB's? Thanks!! Have a great day!!
connie
Have an Answer?
You are reading content posted in the Heart Disease Community
Is a low-fat diet really that heart healthy after all? James D. Nicolantonio, PharmD, urges us to reconsider decades-long dietary guidelines.
Can depression and anxiety cause heart disease? Get the facts in this Missouri Medicine report.
Fish oil, folic acid, vitamin C. Find out if these supplements are heart-healthy or overhyped.
Learn what happens before, during and after a heart attack occurs.
What are the pros and cons of taking fish oil for heart health? Find out in this article from Missouri Medicine.
How to lower your heart attack risk.
