which one is bad? hbsag pos and hbsab neg or hbeag neg and hbeab pos

Just want to know which senario is better and why,
senario 1
HBsAg POS with HBsAb NEG  

HBeAg NEG with HBeAb POS  

or
senario 2

HBsAg POS with HBsAb NEG

HBeAg POS with HBeAb NEG

[kc00]

Both are bad..Being HBV free is better

[stevenNYer]

You are asking that if you have HepB, is it better to be

HBeAg NEG with HBeAb POS

or

HBeAg POS with HBeAb NEG

This is an irrelevant question.  There is no good or bad.  But rather do you have active hepatitis under both these scenerios.

In a nutshell, for HepB, we all start out as HBeAg POS with HBeAb NEG.  Then it usually changes to  HBeAg NEG with HBeAb POS   over the years.  Usually this progression is a good thing but some still have active hepatitis if the the virus mutated (this is not good).