Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum. ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
Doctors Disagree!
by TexJimbo, Nov 10, 2009 06:21PM
November 3, 2009
Hepatitis C: Curable or Incurable Disease?
Learn about the legitimate reasons to believe Hepatitis C is curable - and reasons to believe otherwise.
by Nicole Cutler, L.Ac.
Since its identification in the 1980s, Hepatitis C has been established as a major worldwide health problem. The gravity of this disease is especially poignant, because an estimated 85 percent of those infected go on to develop a chronic infection. While researchers are continually developing, testing and refining the available treatments for Hepatitis C, there is still considerable confusion over our ability to "cure" Hepatitis C.
As of Fall 2009, the current standard treatment for Hepatitis C is antiviral combination therapy consisting of pegylated interferon and ribavirin. Approximately half of those who are eligible for this treatment are able to achieve a sustained viral response. According to Schering Corporation, a sustained viral response is the inability to detect Hepatitis C genetic material for at least six months after Hepatitis C therapy is completed.
Because it is the best measure we currently have for evaluating the elimination of Hepatitis C, many physicians believe attaining a sustained viral response is the same as a cure. Others exhibit more caution in proclaiming their patients are cured.
Evidence for a Cure
In order for a sustained viral response to be called a cure, the inability to detect Hepatitis C six months after treatment completion must be permanent. Unfortunately, only time and repeated testing can confirm the permanence of viral absence.
Hope for pegylated interferon and ribavirin therapy representing a Hepatitis C cure took root in the Spring of 2007. In a study led by Mitchell Shiffman, M.D., professor in the Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) School of Medicine, and chief of Hepatology and medical director of the Liver Transplant Program at the VCU Medical Center, nearly 1,000 patients were followed for up to seven years after they achieved a sustained viral response. Their results were the most encouraging thus far that Hepatitis C is curable.
According to Shiffman, "The use of peg-interferon alone, or in combination with ribavirin, points to a cure for Hepatitis C. This paper strongly suggests, for the first time, that Hepatitis C is a curable disease. After treatment, 99.6 % of the patients remained virus undetectable for over five years." In Schiffman's study, eight patients who achieved sustained viral response tested positive for Hepatitis C at an average of two years following treatment completion. However, it is unknown why this occurred.
Reason for Caution
The primary reason that some physicians avoid using the term "cure" in relation to sustained viral response with Hepatitis C, is the possibility of giving false hope.
Our ability to detect the Hepatitis C virus is not absolute. While Hepatitis C tests examine the blood for viral particles, they are not sophisticated enough to be able to test for signs of the virus in other organs, the lymphatic system or other parts of the body where the virus is believed to hide. Thus, it is difficult to know if Hepatitis C is truly eradicated or if a microscopic virion has found a good hiding place.
This doubt exists because there have been cases where people have achieved sustained viral response only to test positive for Hepatitis C years later. In such instances, it is unknown if these people experienced a relapse of the virus or if they were re-infected. People who believe they are cured might assume they can resume liver damaging habits and that they can no longer transmit Hepatitis C. If their liver infection does return, believing they were cured of Hepatitis C could lead to a medical lawsuit. This also explains why anyone who has ever tested positive for Hepatitis C is not permitted to donate blood.
Doctors Disagree
Based on a study published in the April 2008 edition of the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, investigators from Georgetown University looked at how many physicians used the term "cure" in their discussions with Hepatitis C patients. They found the following:
· 63 percent of physicians used the word "cure" in 38 percent of visits involving response discussions.
· "Cure" most frequently meant "absolute cure" and occurred more commonly in visits conducted before therapy initiation, and with patients having favorable genotypes.
· Physicians hedged the meaning of "cure" in 29 percent of visits.
These statistics demonstrate that some doctors discuss hope for a cure with their patients, while others are still hesitant to use this terminology.
Defining whether or not Hepatitis C is a curable disease depends on your perspective. If there is fear of false hope, it is premature to consider Hepatitis C curable. However, based on the best measure we currently have to assess the presence of this infection, there is a 50/50 chance of curing Hepatitis C. Obviously, this debate has not yet been settled. Nonetheless, more and more people are achieving a sustained viral response and remaining free of the virus for increasingly longer periods of time. As this trend continues and improvements in testing are made, more doctors will be convinced that curing Hepatitis C has become a reality.
References:
http://hcvadvocate.org/hepatitis/factsheets_pdf/Brief_History_HCV_2006.pdf, A Brief History of Hepatitis C, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Hepatitis C Support Project, 2009.
http://nationalhepatitis-c.org/kevdialogue-hm.htm, Although A True Cure May Be Elusive, There is Still Hope for Controlling Hepatitis C!!!, Kev Krueger, National Hepatitis C Coalition, Inc., 2009.
http://www.crossbennett.com/CM/Articles/Articles148.asp, Hepatitis C Virus Information, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Cross & Bennett, LLC, 2009.
http://www.csmc.edu/10698.html, Hepatitis C, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Cedars-Sinai Health System, 2009.
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/71704.php, Hepatitis C Cure Announced By VCU Researcher, Retrieved October 29, 2009, MediLexicon International Ltd., May 2007.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18277894?itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum&ordinalpos=2, How physicians describe outcomes to HCV therapy: prevalence and meaning of "cure" during provider-patient in-office discussions of HCV, Hamilton HE, et al, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, April 2008.
http://www.pegintron.com/peg/application?event=content_display&event_input=avoiding_relapse&namespace=main, Avoiding Relapse, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Schering Corporation, 2009.
This discussion is related to The truth...what next?.
Hepatitis C: Curable or Incurable Disease?
Learn about the legitimate reasons to believe Hepatitis C is curable - and reasons to believe otherwise.
by Nicole Cutler, L.Ac.
Since its identification in the 1980s, Hepatitis C has been established as a major worldwide health problem. The gravity of this disease is especially poignant, because an estimated 85 percent of those infected go on to develop a chronic infection. While researchers are continually developing, testing and refining the available treatments for Hepatitis C, there is still considerable confusion over our ability to "cure" Hepatitis C.
As of Fall 2009, the current standard treatment for Hepatitis C is antiviral combination therapy consisting of pegylated interferon and ribavirin. Approximately half of those who are eligible for this treatment are able to achieve a sustained viral response. According to Schering Corporation, a sustained viral response is the inability to detect Hepatitis C genetic material for at least six months after Hepatitis C therapy is completed.
Because it is the best measure we currently have for evaluating the elimination of Hepatitis C, many physicians believe attaining a sustained viral response is the same as a cure. Others exhibit more caution in proclaiming their patients are cured.
Evidence for a Cure
In order for a sustained viral response to be called a cure, the inability to detect Hepatitis C six months after treatment completion must be permanent. Unfortunately, only time and repeated testing can confirm the permanence of viral absence.
Hope for pegylated interferon and ribavirin therapy representing a Hepatitis C cure took root in the Spring of 2007. In a study led by Mitchell Shiffman, M.D., professor in the Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) School of Medicine, and chief of Hepatology and medical director of the Liver Transplant Program at the VCU Medical Center, nearly 1,000 patients were followed for up to seven years after they achieved a sustained viral response. Their results were the most encouraging thus far that Hepatitis C is curable.
According to Shiffman, "The use of peg-interferon alone, or in combination with ribavirin, points to a cure for Hepatitis C. This paper strongly suggests, for the first time, that Hepatitis C is a curable disease. After treatment, 99.6 % of the patients remained virus undetectable for over five years." In Schiffman's study, eight patients who achieved sustained viral response tested positive for Hepatitis C at an average of two years following treatment completion. However, it is unknown why this occurred.
Reason for Caution
The primary reason that some physicians avoid using the term "cure" in relation to sustained viral response with Hepatitis C, is the possibility of giving false hope.
Our ability to detect the Hepatitis C virus is not absolute. While Hepatitis C tests examine the blood for viral particles, they are not sophisticated enough to be able to test for signs of the virus in other organs, the lymphatic system or other parts of the body where the virus is believed to hide. Thus, it is difficult to know if Hepatitis C is truly eradicated or if a microscopic virion has found a good hiding place.
This doubt exists because there have been cases where people have achieved sustained viral response only to test positive for Hepatitis C years later. In such instances, it is unknown if these people experienced a relapse of the virus or if they were re-infected. People who believe they are cured might assume they can resume liver damaging habits and that they can no longer transmit Hepatitis C. If their liver infection does return, believing they were cured of Hepatitis C could lead to a medical lawsuit. This also explains why anyone who has ever tested positive for Hepatitis C is not permitted to donate blood.
Doctors Disagree
Based on a study published in the April 2008 edition of the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, investigators from Georgetown University looked at how many physicians used the term "cure" in their discussions with Hepatitis C patients. They found the following:
· 63 percent of physicians used the word "cure" in 38 percent of visits involving response discussions.
· "Cure" most frequently meant "absolute cure" and occurred more commonly in visits conducted before therapy initiation, and with patients having favorable genotypes.
· Physicians hedged the meaning of "cure" in 29 percent of visits.
These statistics demonstrate that some doctors discuss hope for a cure with their patients, while others are still hesitant to use this terminology.
Defining whether or not Hepatitis C is a curable disease depends on your perspective. If there is fear of false hope, it is premature to consider Hepatitis C curable. However, based on the best measure we currently have to assess the presence of this infection, there is a 50/50 chance of curing Hepatitis C. Obviously, this debate has not yet been settled. Nonetheless, more and more people are achieving a sustained viral response and remaining free of the virus for increasingly longer periods of time. As this trend continues and improvements in testing are made, more doctors will be convinced that curing Hepatitis C has become a reality.
References:
http://hcvadvocate.org/hepatitis/factsheets_pdf/Brief_History_HCV_2006.pdf, A Brief History of Hepatitis C, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Hepatitis C Support Project, 2009.
http://nationalhepatitis-c.org/kevdialogue-hm.htm, Although A True Cure May Be Elusive, There is Still Hope for Controlling Hepatitis C!!!, Kev Krueger, National Hepatitis C Coalition, Inc., 2009.
http://www.crossbennett.com/CM/Articles/Articles148.asp, Hepatitis C Virus Information, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Cross & Bennett, LLC, 2009.
http://www.csmc.edu/10698.html, Hepatitis C, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Cedars-Sinai Health System, 2009.
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/71704.php, Hepatitis C Cure Announced By VCU Researcher, Retrieved October 29, 2009, MediLexicon International Ltd., May 2007.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18277894?itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum&ordinalpos=2, How physicians describe outcomes to HCV therapy: prevalence and meaning of "cure" during provider-patient in-office discussions of HCV, Hamilton HE, et al, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, April 2008.
http://www.pegintron.com/peg/application?event=content_display&event_input=avoiding_relapse&namespace=main, Avoiding Relapse, Retrieved October 29, 2009, Schering Corporation, 2009.
This discussion is related to The truth...what next?.
Post Comment
Related Communities
Recent Videos
Related Expert Forums
Recent Activity
Most Popular Trackers
RSS
Expert Activity
Community Members
Popular Groups
The post-"cure" biopsy I just suffered thru showed a very low level of activity of the virus but I am told that even that level continues to cause problems (newest diagnosis: chronic low level anemia) along with all the other problems this "CURE" has created.
btw, reapplying for LIAHIP at the local welfare office (or whatever they call it today) brought a good discussion with the worker. I said "cured" of C and he quizzed me on the sudden ability of the med gurus having found a "cure".
p.s. Hope all here who have helped me are taking this "cure" well or at least day by day blessings.
f