Hepatitis C Community
SVR, sustained suppression or elimination?
About This Community:

This forum is for questions about medical issues and research aspects of Hepatitis C such as, questions about being newly diagnosed, questions about current treatments, information and participation in discussions about research studies and clinical trials related to Hepatitis. If you would like to communicate with other people who have been touched by Hepatitis, please visit our new Hepatitis Social/Living with Hepatitis forum

Font Size:
A
A
A
Background:
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank Blank

SVR, sustained suppression or elimination?

I guess that is the million dollar question. I was reading another thread where someone mentioned that it was about suppression of the virus rather then it's elimination.

It seems like there would be evidence that our immune system was actively suppressing the virus after we stopped taking the treatment drugs. I suppose the immune system response might be undetectable though.

also found it interesting that someone mentioned in another thread that their relatives virus may have come back after svr because of using immunosuppressant drugs to combat another illness. I would expect that would mean that we would be advised to avoid immunosuppressant drugs after svr and that there would be evidence at this point that those drugs could risk long term svr.


Blank
179856_tn?1333550962
I personally am not into the whole occult virus thing because I believe if it were true we would see a lot of SVRs go south in time and that is not the case.

I believe that it is eliminated.  Personally, I've done a bunch of things that supposedly could make it come back (Ie: long course prednisone, drinking alcohol) and it hasn't in almost 4 years.

I sure like that because it means CURED and not remission and that makes me much happier.

Just my opinion.
Related Discussions
33 Comments Post a Comment
Blank
Avatar_m_tn
I guess the question would apply to many illnesses, especially viruses. Are they eliminated or surprresed.
Blank
179856_tn?1333550962
I personally am not into the whole occult virus thing because I believe if it were true we would see a lot of SVRs go south in time and that is not the case.

I believe that it is eliminated.  Personally, I've done a bunch of things that supposedly could make it come back (Ie: long course prednisone, drinking alcohol) and it hasn't in almost 4 years.

I sure like that because it means CURED and not remission and that makes me much happier.

Just my opinion.
Blank
87972_tn?1322664839
Hi Dave—

You mentioned “…also found it interesting that someone mentioned in another thread that their relatives virus may have come back after svr because of using immunosuppressant drugs to combat another illness...”

The gal that heads up our local HCV support group *insists* that her disease reappeared as well in similar circumstances. After completing antiviral therapy for GT-1 HCV, she tested negative for virus at six months post treatment, but this was in 2004, and they used the bDNA test which is sensitive to >615 IU/mL. After the six month test, she was hospitalized for her (I think) lupus, and required bolus IV prednisone. At nine months post treatment, she tested her HCV again, which was then positive. She denies any engaging in risky behavior, and feels strongly that the immunosupressent ‘reactivated’ her disease.

I suggested she might have never fully eliminated the virus to begin with, and that she may have had low level viremia that wasn’t quantifiable through the nine months post therapy.

Who knows; she has since retreated and now appears SVR.

An argument against this is the number of transplant patients that achieve SVR post-TP; they are loaded with antirejection meds, all of which flatten immune response, but still attain SVR status. In here, Mikesimon is an example to this.

Good topic, though; I imagine researchers like Pham have combed through this already, huh?

Bill
Blank
96938_tn?1189803458

I look st SVR and suppression like a very sad life event, like a death or a serious illness in the family.  You don't suppress a laugh or a smile because there is nothing joyus or funny.  For HCV, the immune system in not suppressing anything because there is nothing to suppress.
Blank
87972_tn?1322664839
Hmm… I guess I’ll attribute my typos and syntax errors to the new keyboard I bought yesterday :o).

--Bill
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
I believe SVR to mean cured as well.  Even if a few of those weakened, powerless occult rascals are running around in the body there are so many studies to support liver damage is halted unless of course a person is drinking excessively or pounding  the OTC pain medication or pain pills with acetaphetamine or ibuprofen.  This is a primarily a disease associated with the liver and no more liver damage is good enough for me, especially when the damage is late stage before the SVR.

Trinity
Blank
Avatar_m_tn
I choose deb as the best answer because I want to be cured if I svr regardless of what the real truth is, and mostly because Deb looks really good in a Bikini.

Of course at the time Trin had not commented, so well just have to call if a tie for best answer. This is the first time I have chosen best answer I think, it just evoked so much emotion (the bikini I mean)

Seriously though, I guess this question has been running through this forum and the drs and scientists minds for a while.

- Dave


Blank
Avatar_m_tn
Your point is well taken. If damage ceases or reverses and the virus is undetectable then it enough for me. I certainly won't spend my remaining years being concerned about it if I svr.

Still makes one wonder about the few that have reported that possibly immunosuppressant drugs reactivated the virus,

- Dave
Blank
87972_tn?1322664839
Hey, if I wore a bikini, I’m sure it’d evoke strong emotion in you as well, Dave…
Blank
Avatar_m_tn

"Hey, if I wore a bikini, I’m sure it’d evoke strong emotion in you as well, Dave…"
hahaha
Blank
220090_tn?1379170787
At my last visit to Mt  Sinai, lat June, I asked this same question.  The opinion at Mt Sinai is that in most cases, the virus is eliminated.  In some people, the virus does persist at an undetectable level.  When SVR people take heavy immune system suppressants, a small number will relapse.  In very rare cases, SVR people do relapse with no identifiable cause.  This from Dr Ds assistant.
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
I've gone to my happy place and threw up a little in my mouth
Blank
148588_tn?1405690829
Multiple studies have shown that 85-90% of people who become serum undetectible, whether with IFN or clearing it on their own, will still show a recognizable form of the virus either in their liver, their spinal fluid, or their lymph system. There is now a series of blood tests you can do that will predict with a high degree of accuracy whether or not you carry occult virus and you can skip the spinal biopsy. If it matters to you.
Personally, serum UND works for me.
Blank
979080_tn?1323437239
"There is now a series of blood tests you can do that will predict with a high degree of accuracy whether or not you carry occult virus "

What is the name of these tests ?
Blank
179856_tn?1333550962
Dave it's cool, Trin and I will share - we're friends so it means sharing the good and the bad and all in between.

Either way you have to realize even if the concept of occult is actually true - so what if there are a few of them floating about in your big toe.......as long as the damage is halted and your liver can even get better who cares. (Although I really dont believe it is true).

I wouldn't want to know if it's in there or not as long as I test UND I am fine and happy with that completely. (But I had such a hard time getting to UND and then post EOT getting back a false positive I am sure I would be one to get this positive result - since it makes no difference but would probably drive me crazy, I wouldn't take that test for all of the world).
Blank
Avatar_m_tn
I agree Deb-
I don't want to know if it's in my big toe either. If I svr, and I am not getting sicker any longer that's what is important to me. And if it is eating at my brain what can I do anyway, I don't think they have figured out how to do a brain transplant at this point. I just found the whole subject interesting.  

If it was going to pick up residence somewhere I would prefer something disposable like a toe rather then a liver.  



Blank
Avatar_f_tn
Deb, that's for sure about sharing the good, bad and in between.  You never kicked me to the curb and that speaks volumes.

Trin
Blank
979080_tn?1323437239
It matters to me.
Never heard of any high accuracy blood test for "occult HCV infection".
How do you know this and what are the test names ?

Blank
Avatar_f_tn
Bali, why would it matter?  Even if occult exits what the hell can anyone do about it anyway?  SVR is durable and if your liver is not under siege any longer and possibly regenerating isn't that the most important thing?

What does a person say?  Oh Hi, my name is Bali and I'm SVR but I have occult Hepc
virus and go into this big long explanation that really has no significance in the big scheme of things?

Blank
Avatar_m_tn
"Even if occult exits what the hell can anyone do about it anyway?  SVR is durable and if your liver is not under siege any longer and possibly regenerating isn't that the most important thing?"

That's exactly my thought. Nothing can be done anyhow, so why sweat it.

Personally, I believe we will never be completely rid of ACTIVE virus (keyword ACTIVE), as study after study has found viral RNA in SVR patients even > 5+ years post SVR.

But if the net effect is nothing, then who cares? Personally, when I SVR I'll worry about it no more. The damage stops, and that's all I care about.

Oh, and to address an earlier comment about not being able to detect the immune system surpressing things - your immune system surpresses thousands of invaders every day, Hep C or not. That's the job of the immune system.

The way you detect that is the absence of widespread systemic infection and the mortality that follows :-) If your immune system was severely compromised, you could find that a paper cut resulted in your untimely demise.

Robert
Blank
Avatar_m_tn
Ahh, nuts. So much for proofreading. This:

"Personally, I believe we will never be completely rid of ACTIVE virus (keyword ACTIVE), "

Should have been:

"Personally, I believe we will never be completely rid of INACTIVE virus (keyword INACTIVE), "

Kinda spoiled my whole point of view there.
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
Well I can't wait to be svr.  It will be a while, since i am only shot 14 tonight, but I know that once I am "cured" sitting on my back porch with a glass of good wine in my hand and enjoying the scenery will mean a whole lot more to me than it ever did in the past.~:0)
Blank
979080_tn?1323437239
the concept of "occult HCV infection " is new to me and I will further investigate it
before I come to any conclusions.
For example I was just reading a medical paper
from a few years back that looked at occult infection and found that even with
HCV RNA negative in serum an occult infection sometimes existed in the liver
They took liver tissue and found HCV still replicating but called it a mild form
of the disease.What this means , I have no clue  . In some individuals enzymes were still elevated even with HCV RNA negative in serum and no other burden on the liver present but occult infection.
Why do I want to know ?
Because I am investing a great deal into this disease and I am interested in EVERY
aspect. Even if for the time being  there is nothing you I do about an occult
infection it is my personal preference to know everything I can about it.

So if desrt or anybody else is aware of any accurate bloodtests regarding the
matter I would love to take a look at it.

Cheers
b




Blank
Avatar_f_tn
Well, I should have known when it involves any type of test you will be in the forefront. :)


Blank
Avatar_m_tn
Although our immune system suppresses invasion all the time, part of the diagnosis of certain diseases besides the obvious symptoms and distress of the patient is based in part on immune system response, wbc count, specifically which white blood cells, platelet levels, rbc levels.

I actually wasn't thinking of occult infection when I started the thread. I was thinking that perhaps in the same manner that combos of drugs suppress (not eliminate) hiv and hep b, that hcv tx teaches our immune system to suppress the continual attempt of the virus to replicate.

Perhaps that is what is meant by occult infection, but I thought it meant there may be hcv remnants in our body tissue, but that it is not replicating or trying to replicate.
Blank
148588_tn?1405690829
Sorry, I had to rush back to work. I knew I should have taken the time to pst the link.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20648609
Blank
979080_tn?1323437239
that`s great , thank you  :-)
Blank
419309_tn?1326506891
I do equate SVR to cure, but that being said, it is an interesting if academic question regarding suppression v. elimination.

Perhaps an inappropriate analogy, but my mind keeps going back to chicken pox -- most of us clear chicken pox, end of story... but there are those who develop shingles later in life when the virus 'reactivates' in a 'perfect storm' situation.  But millions of people have chicken pox and never have shingles, right?

Perhaps the same is true of hcv and SVR... millions of people never relapse after clearing infection, but some do if their bodies are harbors of 'perfect storms'?  Science still can't explain why some sustain SVR while others relapse... so it shouldn't be a foregone conclusion that once declared SVR that relapse is not possible.  SVR is durable, but not absolute, imho.  Medical terminology being "Sustained Viral Response" implies to me the virus is still present -- otherwise, it wouldn't be called 'response.'

My thinking is that SVR is suppression of viral activity and therefore elimination of the disease, but it may not correlate to 100% elimination of the virus in all cells.
Blank
1130586_tn?1316269892
J Med Virol. 2010 Sep;82(9):1554-9.

Diagnosis of occult hepatitis C without the need for a liver biopsy.
Castillo I, Bartolomé J, Quiroga JA, Barril G, Carreño V.

Foundation for the Study of Viral Hepatitis, 28015 Madrid, Spain.

Abstract
The diagnosis of occult hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is based on the presence of HCV-RNA in the liver. This study aimed to evaluate the use of combining non-invasive assays to diagnose occult HCV. A total of 122 patients with occult HCV (HCV-RNA in the liver without detectable anti-HCV and serum HCV-RNA) and 45 patients with cryptogenic chronic hepatitis (without HCV-RNA in the liver and negative for anti-HCV and serum HCV-RNA) were included. HCV-RNA was tested in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) and in 2 ml of ultracentrifuged serum. Anti-core HCV was examined by a non-commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. All controls were negative for the three HCV markers studied. Among patients with occult HCV, 36% were anti-core HCV positive, 57% had serum HCV-RNA after ultracentrifugation, and 61% had HCV-RNA in PBMCs. Combining the results of the assays, 91% of the patients were positive for at least one marker. Intrahepatic HCV-RNA load was significantly higher in patients who were positive simultaneously for the three HCV markers than in patients who were negative for all markers (P = 0.006) and than in those with one or two HCV markers (P = 0.039). Replication of HCV in liver was detected more frequently in patients with three (93%, P = 0.002), two (82%, P = 0.001), and one HCV marker (73%, P = 0.011) than in those without markers (27%). In conclusion, testing for all these markers allows diagnosis of occult HCV without the need for a liver biopsy and these assays may help to elucidate the clinical significance of occult HCV infection.

PMID: 20648609 [PubMed - in process]


I guess it's a matter or perception .

What factors define "cure" ? Suppression or total eradication , big toes excluded ......

The point being , if 1a and very lucky to achieve SVR , what is the course of action, or, non action after Tx ?

If Tx is finished and after 6 months & still SVR , do you just say ... ok , i'll never ever check this again yahoo ! ! Or do regular check up's ?

Why would a person check later in life after  having SVR'd if they are "cured" ?

As we all know, this virus and how it acts or reacts ,,,  at the end of the day , nobody  really does know .... do they ....
Blank
Post a Comment
To
Blank
Weight Tracker
Weight Tracker
Start Tracking Now
Hepatitis C Community Resources
RSS Expert Activity
233488_tn?1310696703
Blank
New Cannabis Article from NORTH Mag...
Jul 20 by John C Hagan III, MD, FACS, FAAOBlank
242532_tn?1269553979
Blank
3 Reasons Why You are Still Binge E...
Jul 14 by Roger Gould, M.D.Blank
242532_tn?1269553979
Blank
Emotional Eating: What Your Closet ...
Jul 09 by Roger Gould, M.D.Blank
Top Hepatitis Answerers
Avatar_f_tn
Blank
dontworry_behappy1
163305_tn?1333672171
Blank
orphanedhawk
Rural Mural, CA
Avatar_f_tn
Blank
nan535
Brooklyn, NY
446474_tn?1404424777
Blank
HectorSF
CA
1815939_tn?1377995399
Blank
pooh55811
96938_tn?1189803458
Blank
FlGuy
South, FL