Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum.  ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
 | 

cig smoking 2 cents worth

by stangshelly, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
just to let you know if you have been smoking a long time your body has adapted to this and by quitting you are actually signalling your body to clear extra toxins and putting yourself at a higher risk...smoking and  disease are genetically predisposed..how many people do you know that quit smoking and all of a sudden they are in the hospital with heart attack, stroke and other issues...moderation is the key..i have smoked 10 a day for 25+ years and had a recent cxr..and they couldn't even tell i smoked..just my opinion..
Member Comments (40)

by lilmoma, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: strngshelly
My mom smoked 5 packs a day!!! Yes, she was a chain smoker. She NEVER even had a cold that I can remember. Doc always told her she had great lungs.
Now I smoke too, chance are not as high for me to get "lung cancer" because it does not run in the family. I have tried to quit many times, I can quit, but cant stay quit,...I dont know why.
I would never advocate smoking, (my daughter thinks its awful)
I do believe certain habits and diseases we have a predisposition for. Alcohoism runs amuck in my family, so it was not surprising that it became an issue for me. I no longer drink.

by Snookmiester, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: All the smokers
Heres a little link fo you to read, even just a few cigarettes increase likelyhood of disease, and added health risks.
<a href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4265600.stm">cigarette link</a>

I just don't know why people attempt to justify ignorance? Cigarettes are bad for your health, your personal hygiene, and overall character. Point blank. If people that smoke regularly did not think that themselves, they wouldn't attempt to stop, or keep making excuses as to why they do it. If you want to kill yourself slowly and look like a fool in the process, more power to ya!!! But please, quite making excuses as to how it does no harm! Really, it's pathetic!

by lilmoma, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
I agree 100% about the health part. As to whether I possess "bad character" because I smoke,.........I think that is going a little far.

Whats your vice?
Eat too much?
Swear?
Watch too much TV?
Wear 100% polyester suits?

by lilmoma, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: rocker
Sounds like youve lived a HARD life!!
LOL

by fishdoc, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
since we're chipping in our two cents worth, the old farts here, I don't have an opinion on.  They got hooked before they knew any better.  Young people on the other hand, I kinda agree with snook.  If I smell smoke on someone interviewing to work in my lab, thats about three black marks. I assume they are stupid, or why would they start something when they know the outcome?  As for quitting causing some kind of chain reaction, as a biologist, thats not believable.  Yall old farts remember ul brynner.... "if you don't smoke, don't start. If you do smoke, quit" just before he died.  My hubby believed him.

by honey11, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
I also agree with Snook but do have to say,,,To quit is a hard road  and yes we all do have some addiction of something or lean on something to some degree.  Some people just love the habit too much to put down or they are willing to take the chance of risking their life.  My dad smoked from a young age until 60 and then his problems started,,,,Dr told him to quit as there were some spots showing up on lungs,,,,then the enphesema came in and he said thinking back all those years back to his younger days,,,,he has no idea how he even got started on such a bad habit except back in the day,,,,it was the thing to do!

by Snookmiester, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: Rocker
Funny, I also started young, about 13... I smoked marlboro reds, before switching to Newports. I smoke till about 21, when I started waking up hacking and coughing up the same wonderful stuff. Quit within a week, and never looked back. My buddies always smoke out on the boat, or when we're out, and of course I still get a little craving, but will NEVER fall back into the pattern. Not gonna die of something I brought on myself!

by lilmoma, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
Some say people with lung cancer have noone else to blame but themselves.

some others say people with hepC have noone else to blame but themselves.

It is easy to judge others,

Stand and be judged,.............how well would any of us fare under the microscope?

by lilmoma, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: reformed smoker
It all makes sense now

by dijay, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
Hi it's good that you are attempting to stop smoking and good on you for being so honest.

You are failing to stop smoking because you are trying to justify your smoking with excuses of healthy family history.

The truth is you and anyone who smokes are doing themselves harm! Smoking harms your whole body by robbing it of oxygen (every cell, internal organ and blood) each cigarette you smoke is causing you harm.

Smoking is not only physically addictive it is very habit forming and psychological addictive. You need to remember you are chemically addicted (physical); emotionally addicted (habit formed) and psychological addicted (your brain and body are fooling each other into believing you enjoy and need cigarettes to feel better).

This is the hardest addiction to beat *however* you can do it if you know how!

The truth is your withdrawal symptoms feel similar to feelings of anger, anxiety and agitation; so every time you feel under stress, have an argument or get over stimulated your brain associates those feelings with feelings of withdrawal; so your brain sends messages to tell you to smoke a cigarette to feel better, calmer and more relaxed.
*In reality you can not feel calmer or more relaxed while smoking as (nicotine is a stimulant) not a relaxant. The nicotine makes your heart race faster, at the same time your veins close smaller, and you are robbing yourself of oxygen because smoke is full of carbon monoxide this is placing your heart, brain and veins under stress and increasing your chances of heart attack and/or suffering a stroke.

*Caffeine is a stimulant and should be avoided while you are trying to stop smoking*

You are also increasing your chance of cancer, lung diseases (asthma, bronchitis, emphysema, cancer) and thrombosis (blood clots) which increase the possibility of heart attacks, stroke, and amputations. I hope you are more informed and more likely to understand how addiction works and why you are failing in your attempts to stop smoking.

**Try hypnosis or positive self-talk (every night) while lying in bed before sleep; repeat a positive phrase about how you want to stop smoking, and how you will be successful. Imagine spending the extra money you will save on a nice holiday.

by wMich, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: stangshelly
Good morning and this is just my take here too. I've heard the "quitting smoking can be bad for you" argument a number of times through the years and really don't think it holds much water. I do agree that some of us, myself included, are unusually sensitive to addiction and I've wrestled with my share of them. As for genetic predisposition, you surely can't pick your parents but you can't get hooked on cigarettes unless you smoke them either. I quit a 30 year, pack and a half a day habit six years ago and in doing so did not shock my system into any diseases or into the hospital. I know many other people who have quit smoking who, like myself, got nothing but good results from doing so. Any negative effects from quitting smoking really stem from smoking, not quitting. Actually I felt better almost immediately, started waking up mornings without hacking and feeling like a brick was on my chest, and have saved almost $10K from not buying the damned things. 10 a day? More power to ya! I guess I just don't have that moderation gene :)   - Lee

by lilmoma, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
I couldn't agree more,...on every point!!!
I guess, all excuses aside,...........
I just don't want to quit bad enough, I still enjoy some aspect of it.
For those that have reached that point where they could quit, my hat is off to you. We all grow at different rates. I have discovered truths that some still have yet to learn, forgive me that you have grown faster in this area of your life than I have.

by cajunlady, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: All
I have smoked since I was 17 and am 51 now.  Don't preach at me about additions.  Most of us have had one or another.  I have tried the patch, the gum, anything on the shelf.  Did not help me to quit and your suggestion of hypnosis; I've done that too.  I hate that I smoke; but honestly when I work, unless I tell them I smoke, they don't know and are shocked. I do not smoke at work. I do not smoke in my vehicles, nor do I smoke in my house, this has been since my kids were born over 16 yrs.  And going out of my way and making it harder to smoke did not help.  I have 16 years sobriety and this is the only one addiction that I have had the hardest time with. I have come to the conclusion that if they do not open a detox center for smokers to quit.  Well, that is I believe the only thing that will conquer this for me.  Unless you have some Miracle I do not know about.  

Let me explain, its awesome that some of you are able to quit.  But, it can be way harder for others.  Our bodies are different, our lives are different.

Just my opinion.

Cajun

by Kalio1, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
This is such an American "problem" to go around JUDGING other people and their habits! I know many people raised in other countries who find this fact about America laughable.
So far not ONE perfect person has been born. Those casting stones need to look in the mirror. To claim you "care" about them dying or getting cancer from smoking is just bogus. You could care less you just want to toot your own horn and feel superior, period.
You don't like smoke? Too bad. I don't like your smelly breath or your too loud voice or your enormous rear end that takes up two places at the ball park but I was taught to be polite and keep it to myself because I was taught that the ONLY judging I was to do was of MYSELF. People use "health concerns" to justify their rude behavior and smoking is the easiest to wave your self righeous banner over, it used to be drinking and I am sure some other thing will catch the attention of the self righeous in the future. Unless and until YOU are free of "bad habits" which INCLUDE being a buttinsky and thinking you are superior to others for ANY reason then you should check yourself. He who is free of fault can cast the first stone and he has yet to be born.
You want to worry about your health, go for it, other than that mind your own business. If you believe in God you should reread the Bible, read the part about judging others.
ANYONE who smokes is harming their health, PERIOD but that is THEIR business. So what if you aren't genetically predisposed to lung cancer, you dang well can get Emphyesema and a whole list of other ailments but that is YOUR business. We are all dying one way or another regardless of smoking or any other behavior. You can never engage in a bad habit in your life and you will still die of something.


by Kalio1, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: PS
Many doctors do NOT advise trying to quit smoking while doing tx. Before or after is fine.

by jmjm530, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: Cajun/All/How to Quit if You Want To
I smoked 1-2 packs a day for 20 years but stopped 20 years ago. I understand how hard it is to quit because I literally tried over 50 times.

There is a misconception that because you've tried unsuccessfully to quit in the past, you won't be able to quit in the future. In fact, at least one study concluded that the more times someone tries to quit the more likely they are to be successful. In other words, your chances of quitting the 50th time may be greater than the first. Or, another words, persistence really does pay off.

My second most successful "quit" was through an organization called "Smokenders". http://www.smokenders.com/ Can't recommend this approach enough. Got me to quit for over two years. A year later, I put down cigarettes for good by going cold turkey. Without "Smokenders" don't think I would have been able to. It's a group program -- and I personally hate group programs -- but one day the relization hit me I wasn't going to be able to lick this problem on my own.

For all those who have tried to stop, who want to stop, but have given up -- remember, it doesn't matter how many times you've failed in the past, you only have to be successful ONCE. If gum, patches, and cold turkey doesn't work, try Smokenders. If Smokenders doesn't work try hypnosis. If that doesn't work, look at a picture of your children, or in the mirror, or talk to your pastor or rabaii. Just keep trying and you will be rewarded.

-- Jim

by jmjm530, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: Study suggests lower SVR in Some Smokers
Probably as good a place as any to mention that cigarette smoking is associated with fibrosis progression and lower SVR rates in genotypes 2 and 3 in one very large study.

From the Win-R trial: "Tobacco smokers with genotype 2 or 3 HCV had significantly lower SVR rates than non-smokers. However, this difference was not observed among genotype 1 patients... Smoking data was available for 2865 out of 4223 patients (68%) included in the primary efficacy analysis; of these, 894 (31%) were smokers and 1971 (69%) were non-smokers. and used data collected from almost 2900 smokers. More here: http://www.hivandhepatitis.com/2006icr/ddw/docs/060206_a.html







by willows, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
As I violenty chew my nicorette gum and fidget in this chair, I have to say I understand the goodness in quitting the smokes, whether it be the way my clothes smell or how well my lungs will serve me the rest of my Hep C impacted life.  Please just don't judge me if I fail to quit again, we all have experienced sooo much judgement for our virus and I'm not even sure how I contracted it.  So while I enjoy my humanity and how imperfect we all are and how those imperfections link us all together, I will keep chewing this gum and going totally out of my gourd.  Ya'll have a great, smoke free day.  I know I will, and resent every freaking, stressed,climbing the walls, frustrating minute of it!!
Willow

by rochammer, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: jmjm
If you going to quote this study quote the rest of it as the study suggest it needs to be look into more.

It not fact yet.

The study was not designed for that purpose  

http://www.hivandhepatitis.com/2006icr/ddw/docs/060206_a.html

“The researchers recommended that additional studies be conducted to further explore how cigarette smoking influences treatment response and the effect of smoking cessation prior starting hepatitis C therapy.”

The only thing worse than smoking is an ex smoker telling smoker to quit against a doctors advise during tx

ENOUGH WITH THIS

by wMich, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: rattled smokers and those who feel "judged"
As far as knowing how hard is is to quit smoking goes, most of us who have smoked for a long time and have quit successfully do know how hard it is to quit and stay quit. We don't always talk about failed efforts through the years, but more often about when and how we were finally able to quit and the benefits of doing so. I quit at age 47 after trying numerous times in my twenties, thirties and forties. Having been there, we also realize just how irritating it is to smokers and those struggling to quit for non-smokers and ex-smokers to jump up on a soapbox and start preaching and scolding about smoking. There are always some don't see it that way too. When I finally got clean and sober from 20 years of drug and alcohol addiction, I watched over and over as newcomers preaching the "gospel" of sobriety too loudly often ended loaded or dead within a few months. In my experience theres few better ways to push an addict away from help than to preach and scold to him. Encouragement and empathy, without compromising honesty, almost always work better. Telling it like it is without being preachy is an art. However, co-signing addict bulls**t only enables addicts to stay sick.

I don't subscribe to the notion that smokers only harm themselves. The effects of smoking, second hand smoke and rising insurance and medical costs affect us all. I'm wondering if my two cats who died of cancer years ago didn't suffer from my smoking. Food for thought. I've sure had my role in adding to everyone's health care costs too and am still using an inhaler for COPD after 6 yrs off cigarettes.  Guess if you ever need my insurance premiums to help pay for your ventilator costs, you're welcome to them. I'm sure glad someone somewhere coughed up the $35K for my HCV Tx over the last year. Peace out and hey, did my last peg last night! A week of Riba and I'm done....
- Lee

by jmjm530, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: roch
I posted the full-link to the study in my post above, so anyone interested could read. I have also never told anyone to stop smoking during treatment against their doctor's advice. Nor, in fact have I told anyone to stop smoking, as I firmly believe that as adults these are individual decisions.  Just trying to put a study and some of my experiences out there that hopefully will help others. Had I started treatment as a smoker, I doubt I would have been able to stop during treatment. For me, treatment was about survival, and probably would have tried anything within reason -- including smoking -- if it helped me continue. In fact, my doc recommended that I smoke Pot (actually medical marijuana) for nausea early on, and the only reason I declined was because pot doesn't agree with me. Hope this clarifies.

-- Jim

by Kalio1, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: all
No one has EVER quit a habit because of any other reason than they alone decide to, period. Addiction does not respond to "shame on you" self righeous judgements and does not respond to attempts from others to shame them into it through guilt. People quit if and when they are ready and no amount of hot air preaching will change that. No aw will change that.ZERO chance of success. All it does is serve to make you feel superior to your fellow man. Admonitions are worthless with addictions, ask any recovered addict. MYOB is still the best thing you can do. You have NO power over others actions. Anyone casting stones at anyone is wasting their breath and should tend their own garden. When you walk on water, maybe someone would listen but I doubt it.

by Kalio1, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: wilow
I wonder if the stress of quitting is more deadly than the smokes. Hey, another excuse for yet another study! All we need are participants willing to die, some get to smoke the rest have to quit.
LOL
pick your poison.
Personally I don't want to live so long my eyes and my mobility **** out while my lived a clean life shell of a body lives on.
I plan to go out laughing, hopefully just after engaging in a romp in the hay and not before my post coital smoke and glass of wine.

;)

by Kalio1, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: all
It is not smoking per se that shortens your life, it is the AMOUNT you smoke. Less than 10 a day has NO negligible health affect, that is fact.

Stp smoking and in 5 years your life expectancy is the SAME as a nonsmoker, that's a fact.

by GoofyDad, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: Kalio
Probs with post coital smoking? <a href="http://www.k-y.com/true_romance/index.jsp">Try this</a>.

by Pdilly, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: all
I smoked for 25 years and smoked 1 1/2 packs a day and was a bartender for 6 years in one of those very smoky basement bars.  The only way to quit is to quit.  I tried for 10 years before I finially made up my mind.  Went on a two week vacation (no one else smoked) and was able to keep away from most of those trigger points.   I found that once I was sucessful that it was me the whole time that would not let me stop smoking before.  I use to find every excuse under the sun to keep smoking.   Unfortunatly until someone is ready to make that decision for themselves it does not matter what anyone says or what article they read they won't do it.  They have to want to  do it for themselves and their families.

by sfbaygirl, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: Chevy/goof/all
I think someone is out to get someone here to give up smoking. It won't be me this week. I can't catch my breath with this anemia, yet I can light up a smoke? Stupid? Yep! I just don't feel it is the right time to quit and neiter does my Doc. Actually, he wrote the book, "The Idiot's Guide to Quitting Smoking". I think he knows more than I do on the subject.

I quit in the late eighties for over 15 years. I came to a point in my life when I said this is it. Those don't come to often, but they do come to most smokers. I used gum and did it cold turkey one day.

Four years ago I stupidly let someone talk me into smoking a cigarette on a cruise to mask the smoke of their pot. I did it. I haven't stopped yet. My husband hates it, I hate it. When I am ready I will quit, most likely AFTER tx. This is hard enough.

Goof;  You think that KY will help? That link crashed my Firefox program!

by lilmoma, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
Yanno, I was just innocently answering a post with "whatever" rolled off the tip of my brain.

Sorry everybody is so worked up, Im not. I went out to lunch while this dumb conversation continued.

Im sorry I ever answered the post.

I will be more careful next time.

by can-do-man, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: All
I always thought this was a support forum.

I'm not here to judge anyone, nor do i have the right.

I'm not here to preach to anyone, nor do i have the right.

As far as name calling, i have little grandkids. And when they start that i put and end to it. For adults to resort to name calling. Well their parents ought to me proud.

by mikesimon, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: can-do-man
I'm with you there can-do even though I have been close to name calling here lately, but there wasn't going to be any preaching - of that I can assure you. But after reading your post I am going to  restain myself. Thanks, Mike

by jmjm530, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: CDM
Well said! I'd just add, try if possible to turn the other cheek -- cause a lot of very sick folks here and the treatment drugs can make it worse.

cdm -- speaking of turning the other cheek, I finally quit my adddition to Creme d' Nuit, in spite of your judgemental attitude and name calling. LOL.

by can-do-man, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: Mike/chev
Mike, for as much stress you were/are under. When you been there done that and know what your up against. I have often wondered how you have so much restraint. But believe me it don't go unnoticed. you have always had my respect. Best to you and your family.

Chev, you ok gal? bet you been busy in your garden. Take care girl.

by can-do-man, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: jmjm
said......speaking of turning the other cheek, I finally quit my adddition to Creme d' Nuit, in spite of your judgemental attitude and name calling.............

Turn the other cheek???????? Just where was you putting that creme d nut at? Anyway glad you gave it up.:)

BTW, did you decide to keep your SHORT bed or did you have the doc go with the full size extended cab????????

Sometimes i just can't hep myself.

by jmjm530, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
cdm: Just where was you putting that creme d nut at? Anyway glad you gave it up.:)
---------------------

Went coldcream turkey.

by way, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
try lobelia

by beamishboy, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
To: 2 cents
you couldn't rent an 'old stoggie i have found' for 2 cents...i was gonna quit when they went to a $1 a pack,maybe tomorrow--King of the Road

by OnAPrettyPoison, Jun 24, 2006 12:00AM
Ha, I kinda got to agree with Kalio about not quitting a habit of any kind unless YOU want to quit it.  If someone rags me to do something, I am most likely to dig in my heels and do the opposite of what they ask me.  Color me stubborn and really hard headed!  

Actually there is a new drug coming out really soon - it was originally scheduled to come out in Spring, I think it is called Recombiant, that works on the pleasure center of the brain.  It has been tested for smoking cessation, alcoholism, drug addiction, as well as weight loss.  Clinicla trials indicate that it works really well.

by shadoww, Jun 25, 2006 12:00AM
Here is my 2 cent worth about smoking.... I too was a smoker  and a drinker at one stage....Before i treated i thought it would be fair to show some RESPECT for life...unless i stopped drinking they wouldnt treat me, before i quit smoking i wouldnt treat myself because it wasnt fair, and didnt make sense. I mean if u dont respect ur LIFE then why even bother TREATING for hep c, when really smoking will most probably get u first... If it were me, i would treat someone that had no RESPECT for his or her life, U CAN QUIT the CIGS, IF u respect ur life....

  my 19th shot thus far, feeling alright cept for obvious hair loss....
    God Bless Ya alll

by susan400, Jun 25, 2006 12:00AM
I used to smoke and when I quit, immediately after stopping, my food tasted better, my hair and my clothes smelt better, my breathing improved, etc.  Also, I read somewhere that actually your chances of a heart attack lessen within a matter of days after stopping of smoking and continue to decrease the longer you stay quit.  This drops even more if you start an exercise program (such as walking), right when you're trying to quit.  The walking helps too with the stress from trying to quit.  There's just too many good reasons to quit and not enough to keep smoking.

Susan

by Forseegood, Jun 25, 2006 12:00AM
To: Onaprettypoison/all
Hey, now we're talking! Pleasure centers, I could get behind that...the only thing I'd look out for is if it has any side effects, etc...if not, sign me up!!!

As far as smoking, I feel really bad for people who do , cause I've talked to junkies and almost each one of them said heroin was far easier to give up....

I really like that post by Djay I think, where he explained addictions and withdrawl symptoms, how they are all inter-related, etc...I really do think they'll come up with something chemical to help the psychological reasons, to help people stop if they want to...I always feel so bad for people clutching together outside of buildings in the cold...gotta be rough...

Just life is can be really tough on all of us, hope everone gets through it as easily and as happily as they can...

And as much compassion I have for anybody dealing with any addiction toxic to their systems, I do not want to be around someone who is smoking, and I hope they are okay with that, and they usually are...once they stomp it out, let's talk! I just hate the smell...but the smokers I know are usually very polite about these types of things...hope everyone is enjoyin their weekend...
Related discussions
Post Comment
To
Comment
Post Comment
Recent Activity
margypops commented on photo
25 mins ago
margypops commented on photo
26 mins ago
margypops commented on photo
29 mins ago
margypops commented on photo
30 mins ago
margypops commented on photo
31 mins ago
margypops commented on photo
32 mins ago
margypops commented on photo
33 mins ago
zmombomb is taking Low dose Naltrexone and doing well!
RSS Expert Activity
What You Don't Know About Breathing...
Nov 24 by Steven Y Park, MD
Thanksgiving
Nov 23 by Thomas Dock, Vet. Technician
Snoring As Your Internal Smoke Alar...
Nov 22 by Steven Y Park, MD
Community Members