This forum is for questions about medical issues and research aspects of
Hepatitis C such as, questions about being newly diagnosed, questions about current treatments, information and participation in discussions about research studies and clinical trials related to Hepatitis. If you would like to communicate with other people who have been touched by Hepatitis, please visit our new
Hepatitis Social/Living with Hepatitis forum
Life expectancy for someone diagnosed with compensated Cirrhosis is around 15-20 years, once you decomp about 1/2 will be dead within 2 years.
The easiest way to get Cirrhosis is to have hep c and drink alcohol.
was a social drinker for 32 of those yrs. I am so greatful that I diden't know I had the virus for 30 of those yrs I might have been too worried about the virus to have had all my wonderful children. Once you know then it is always in the back of your mind. I tried 48 wks of the popular posion It did do me some good but I diden't clear. Holding out for the new drugs,
ROCK ON
Social drinking should not be a problem per "Monto" article (fifth down) but heavy drinking can damage your liver so make sure you're not deceiving yourself regarding how much you drink.
http://www.clevelandclinicmeded.com/hcv/litreview1.htm
Most of us here have no medical background, so see a liver speicialist (hepatologist) for medical advice and to diagnose and monitor the condition of your liver. Hepatologist are usually found at your larger, teaching hospitals. They may want you to treat or simply keep an eye on things and wait for newer drugs.
HCV is not the end of the world. I didn't know I had it for over 30 years and had a pretty normal life. Treated last year and now I'm clear of the virus.
Treatment has its risks just like Hep C, so the risks of one have to be weighed against the risk of the other.
All the best,
-- Jim
You always post the same measly article where ONE doctor claims it is OK but never post the 100's of articles saying that NO ALCOHOL for anyone with Hep C or a damaged liver is far superior and you wonder why people think you encourage alcohol use. It would be one thing if you posted a balanced view at least instead of always giving the message that some alcohol is OK when it is NOT KNOWN exactly what a "safe" amount is. There is NO safe amount that can be verified.
You are the ONLY person on this board who tells people it is OK to drink with Hep C. It is not a good idea to drink AT ALL when you have Hep C, as studies show it can hasten this disease.
-----------------
I wish you would stop personalizing everything as is your habit and simply make your points, arguments on a given subject. As to "balanced", you are probably one of the most unbalanced and opinionated posters here.
-- Jim
"Alcohol is rocket fuel for hep C!!!"
"Drinking with hep C is like pouring gasoline on a fire"
Where do these experts get there information?
From other alarmists,but not from research.
My personal belief is don't drink,but that 2 or 3 units a week won't make any difference to disease progression.
My doctor says have the odd one,but I don't.
Some authorities suggest that cardiac benefits of a little red wine outweigh the possible downside even in HVC patients.
Rock: I'm not advocating drinking, I was lucky I had minimal liver damage but everyone is different. You mention the gout and I wonder if you have another side effect of hep c or it's non-related. Find out what type of hepc you have as far as genotype and what the biopsy report shows for liver damage. That can give you a better idea of life expectancy. You are so young this is the time to try and treat and get better!
Godd luck
Bug
I really wonder when people say they had it for over 35 years if it is really true. Just because someone had a transfusion or did IV drugs a few times 35 years ago does not mean that that is when they got HEPC unless they actually experienced acute symptoms at that time. They may have gotten it only 10 or 15 years ago from something else. There are studies that show anyone drinking heavily has a good chance of getting HEPC.
My doc says I probably got it in the military (vietnam era)30 years ago. I was a heavy drinker up until 10 years ago, who knows especially if you can get it from a razor or a toothbrush not to mention a cut during an accident or bar fight where two peoples blood come together, or at the dentist.
Sorry for going on. Whenever you got it the best thing is to try and get rid of it ASAP.
Bug
---------------------------------------------
Actually, I've posted a couple of articles, but equally important, referenced several leading hepatologist's in their opinions. Dr. D and Dr. C who post frequently in the net and anecdotal reports I've read at Janis regarding a very famous Miami doctor. You can reference some of it in this previous thread:
http://www.medhelp.org/forums/Hepatitis/messages/42065.html
You will probably find that the "100's" of articles you reference, either were derived from data that lumped heavy drinking with social drinking or are specific to heavy drinking.
I'd also like to clear up the misconception that I'm somehow "encouraging alcohol use". Providing information to balance out a discussion is not the same as encouraging alcohol use but simply to put out more information so people can make up their own minds.
You will note that in the "measley" study commentary I posted the following concluding statement: "Alcohol abstinence may be the safest course of action, but an occasional drink appears not to harm the liver in those infected with HCV." It says, alcohol abstience *may* be the safest course of action...." so it is not like I am somehow hiding or avoiding anything as has been suggested. If I was, I wouldn't have linked the article.
-- Jim
If you are concerned about your liver, stop drinking alcohol and drink tons of coffee. I am not kidding!!
I've been told by two respectable doctors in this field, evidenced by their writings on HCV and positions held in leading liver organzations, that alcohol should not be mixed with HCV. Granted, I'm a Stage 4 which presents an ever strong case for any consumption. But for people to say it's O.K. "socially" without knowing a person's definition of "social" and when several studies and doctors say no, especially without knowing their particular situation or the state of the liver, seems to be ill advisement.
Ask most alcoholics and they will probably tell you that their addiction was "social" (i.e. they believed that they could not "socially" function without it ;-)
----------------------------------------------------------------
If you re-read my post, you will see that "social drinking" is quite specficially defined per the Monto article. I post my comment again in context:
"Social drinking should not be a problem per "Monto" article (fifth down) but heavy drinking can damage your liver so make sure you're not deceiving yourself regarding how much you drink."I also told the poster to see a liver specialist (hepatologist) for medical advice.
You will also note (above) that I warn the poster about "not deceiving" himself in regard to how much he drinks. Further, I suggested he see a liver specialist for medical advice.
On this particular issue, I don't think it's so much a matter that myself and some others don't offer a balanced point of view, but in fact that we offer ANY point of view that differs from what you think.
It is obvious from what has been posted, that there appears to be a difference of opinion among doctors themselves on this issue. To brand a group of people "alchoholics" because they repeat offer one side the discussion, tells me more about those that are doing the labeling than those being labled.
-- Jim
What does drinking have to do with aquiring hepC? I know that drinking can increase liver damage with hepc, but what studies show it can cause it?
Bug
How's Janus and Janice?
Bug
-- Jim
Bug
Have you considered treating?
http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/arh25-4/245-254.htm
What a surprise as it puts the chicken before the egg. Thanks for the info.
Bug
Copyman: Thanks, it's become so difficult to decide what will hurt my tx and what will keep my sanity! Not trying to whine (just am!)
Bug
I suppose I've also heard to many testimonies of how diagnosis of HCV was delayed because elevated LFT's where thought to be due to the social drinks and only when total abstinence for a period had occurred did other tests get run to diagnose other possibilities for them.
The real sad fact, as I previously pointed out, is that those with a real social drinking problem will justify it by grabbing that one study, statement, etc. which re-affirms that their behavior is acceptable whilst ignoring the mountain of facts which tells them otherwise. Also seen many who continued or relapsed themselves right into a dirt nap.
I see that it's a bit more than:
"On this particular issue, I don't think it's so much a matter that myself and some others don't offer a balanced point of view, but in fact that we offer ANY point of view that differs from what you think."
but more a coming to realize that those struggling with addictions often times do not look at:
"Providing information to balance out a discussion is not the same as encouraging alcohol use but simply to put out more information so people can make up their own minds."
often times not weighing the balance to clearly rationalize which way the scales tip in their situation.
HCV, Gout, and alcohol in the opening post sounded rather fishy. Guess it left out pot, herbs, smoking, and faith to really set the barn ablaze.
Helping directly in a treatment center and alongside many others here in what seems to be the recovery capitol of the world, I encounter folks always looking for a nugget to grab that justifies their pattern. Nearly all claim to be social drinkers until they come to grip with the fact that they have a real problem.
Aside from most recommendations saying no alcohol if you have HCV, providing them these nuggets in order to be fair and balanced does not make much sense to me. Particularily when the definition of addiction is "persistent compulsive use of a substance known by the user to be harmful".
Oh well, if some folks think it's OK to encourage it I guess that's their perogative.
Hope things are working out for you and some options of clearing become available.
Even after that, as if either it didn't register or didn't matter, people were adding two cents. I don't get it.
-----------------------------------------------------
I didn't want to keep going with a battle of the studies but since you've made this point several times I think best to address rather for you to somehow feel I'm avoiding your question. Here is a more recent study that contradicts the above entitled "Alcohol has no effect on hepatitis C virus replication: a meta-analysis" It was one of the studies I referenced in my post "C16" above per an earlier thread. Abstract here: http://tinyurl.com/nkqty
I'm not saying that one study is better than another but I assume the doctors I've consulted are aware of both. I also believe your study emphasized *heavy* drinking but not sure.
GO: I understand what you say. In a similar/dissimilar fashion, many of us here have struggled with for example reporting negative treatment experiences which may in some way may discourage some from either treating or lessen their resolve once in treatment. I think where we came out is that it's best to lay out the situation as we best know it and let people make up their own minds. I do understand that some here may have had previous drinking problems or may have current problems and not recognize them. I still see that as a separate issue from what was originally asked and discussed. If someone here, or a doctor, says it's OK for patient "X" to have a couple of beers a week, then I don't think it's the doctors fault if patient "X" takes that as a green light to go out and binge drink. Just my thoughts.
Have no wish to take this any further but wish you and Rev well.
-- Jim
I just don't see how anyone (including a doc, no matter how renown, I've had problems with other advice I have seen from "renown" docs) can say that it is okay to drink, say, 3 drinks a week while you have this disease....how can this information be quantifiable? We've all seen the studies that say "women" metabolize alcohol differently then men, prob because we carry more "body fat" and when you have more "body fat" the alcohol will tend to stay in the system longer in the fatty tissues...or something to this effect...conflicting studies mean that they just don't really understand this type of stuff - to a high degree....to me anyway....
So alcohol might effect me differently then it will effect someone else...who knows for sure? The only constant we have in this equasion is that we have liver disease, and that alcohol is a known toxin to the liver...there is "no way" of telling how much one person can get away with, as opposed to another, while having this disease....
So they ( a few experts) take an educated guess that a few drinks a week won't hurt, how can they possibly know for sure? "Maybe" it might not effect John, but it will effect Bill? How can something with sooooo many variables be quantified, with any degree of accuracy, from person to person?
Moreover, do we all know exactly our liver disease is progressing? We've had threads before discussing how it's darn hard to get a completely accurate overview on our individual liver disease, so we need to throw in a "wild card" like alcohol consumption into the equasion? Why not wait till after your SVR to drink your few drinks per week, is the irritation of 'going without' while your ill with this really worth the risk?
So, with the few elements that we do know something about with a lot more accuracy, that we have liver disease, and that alcohol is a known toxin to the liver....isn't it only fitting that we err on the side of caution? I mean, we do have a potentially deadly disease, and who knowns who is going to clear with the present SOC, is it really worth it to anyone to try your luck with some fixed number of drinks per week? I guess it is to some, that's pretty apparent, all I mean to say is that I just don't understand that way of thinking...and I don't think erring on the side of caution with a potentially deadly liver disease makes me an alarmist...in this regard anyhow...
We have Hepatitis, (those of us who are not SVR) the game is completely different for us then a person without liver disease, sad but true...if a doctor has a problem with that, it's not his/her liver that he/she is playing with, it's ours...most docs don't have this disease so I don't see where they have much on the line here, except to give out opinions, in this regard anyway...
it's our individual health on the line here, not theirs...
Stacy
That's one problem.
I got hep c in 1967 from a transfusions and can see how it affected my life and relationships.
Drinking and hep c and gout are 3 problems.
you can get rid of the hep c, quit drinking for years-7+=and still have gout.
You can clear hep c-I did in 5-2002 on interferon-3x wk shoots-and riba- and you can quit drinking...
or you can tackel one or two of the health problemsb/gout will stick w/you even if you are virus free and alcohol free....
b/if younliver hurts after drinking or sugar binging-all the same to the liver-that's whhen to quit and if your feet are hurting, that's a whole nother problem w/a whole nother diet!
Treatment is tough... it's hard and you feel old before your time - I'm 5 mnths post TX - and I'm just starting to feel better.
And you have a better than 1% chance. -- 3 years have passed you by... Great--- you took a mini vacation.
Now when you feel better get off yer duff and do some fun things! Find life all over again.
Who knows how long you'll live --- depends on your level of damage --- however... you could be walking down the road and Godzilla could step on you tonight. So it doesn't really matter.
Most people with HCV live normal lives until their liver starts to take damage. After Treatment - most are SVR (those of Geno 1a sometimes have a rougher road and a longer one...) and it takes about 6 months to a year to clear most side effects...
And those side effects are doosies... let me tell you - don't think this is how you're going to feel - cause you won't... I didn't.
I still feel aches and pains... But nothing like the OVERWHELMING EYEORE DROOPY CLOUDED THINKING HORRIBLE ACHES AND FATIGUE times like I had during TX.
And if I --- the biggest weenie ever roasted.... If I can do it --- then you -- someone who has recovered from drugs (what a fantastic achievement!!!! That's more amazing than I've ever done...I can't even say that I know I could do that... I've never done drugs --- but I've seen what strength it takes for people to clean themselves up!) If I can do it --- then you most certainly can.
Don't be sitting there worried - enjoy what you have --- and while you have it!
In fact --- pull your head out of those murky clouds --- and quit worrying --- if you're doing what you can to remain healthy - not drinking alcohol - and maybe starting some exercise --- you should be doing fine.
I can't promise a long life --- but most people who have cured or gone SVR live normal healthy lives... And even some people who have HCV but never cleared - and maintained little damage --- those folks live fairly normal.
So keep your head up!
Meki
Someone jump in here if I'm wrong. Certainly don't want to be providing inaccurate info....
The article says "HCV-related cirrhosis (with its associated complications, such as liver cancer) is a major cause of death, although it develops slowly and occurs only in approximately one-third of HCV-infected patients. Alcohol can exacerbate HCV infection and the associated liver damage by causing oxidative stress and promoting fibrosis, thereby accelerating disease progression to cirrhosis. Furthermore, alcohol may exacerbate the side-effects associated with current antiviral treatment of HCV infection and impair ...."
Alcohol can exacerbate HCV - exacerbate means to make worse an already underlying condition. Alcohol DOES NOT CAUSE Hepatitius C (or A or B for that matter).
The next paragraph "Hepatitis is an inflammation of the liver that is characterized by jaundice, liver enlargement, abdominal and gastric discomfort, abnormal liver function, and other symptoms. Although in many patients the diseased liver is able to regenerate its tissue and retain its function, severe hepatitis may progress to scarring of the liver tissue (i.e., fibrosis), cirrhosis, liver cancer (i.e., hepatocellular carcinoma), and chronic liver dysfunction. Hepatitis can have numerous causes, such as excessive alcohol consumption or infection by certain bacteria or viruses. One common cause of hepatitis is infection with one of several types of viruses (e.g., hepatitis A, B, or C viruses). With the development of ...."
The key phrase here is "Hepatitis can have numerous causes, such as excessive alchohol consumption..."
Don't get the word/condition hepatitis confused with the disease Hepatitis C. They are not the same thing....they only refer to the same body part; i.e. the liver. Hep researchers were not the most creative in naming new viruses, so we didn't get any of the cool names like Ebola or Shermack's disease or whatever.
Forgive me if I'm out of line here .... cause what I thought I was reading from your posts was that drinking alcohol causes Hep C and it doesn't. It does cause the condition hepatitis in your liver.
Does anyone know if Stage 2 of the 4 stages of Liver Scor. is very far along, halfway... what??
Thank You. LipStick
As far as the stages there is no way anyone, doctor or not, can predict how you will respond to liver damage. It could easily take 10 years to go from stage 2 to 3 or as little as 18 months. While it would be nice to have a progression date it just isn't possible for anyone to predict how one will respond to damage. I know people in their 60's and 70's living with Hepatitis C and they've had it since their 20's and 30's. I've known of a couple other people that died in their 40's.
Susan
I don't understand why you say that you have only a 1% chance of clearing. If they're keeping you on treatment, they have a reason why. Generally people with a 1% chance are pulled off treatment fairly early in the game. Even if you don't get SVR, moreover, the interferon/ribavirin can cause your liver to get better. Don't lose hope. You're sick from the medicine right now and not in a position to think logically. The meds are verry depressing - are you taking any anti-depressants? if not, ask your doctor for a prescription. Time heals all ills, and you will feel better, I promise.
The only way to know for sure what kind of damage you have today is to do another liver biopsy. After 5 years I'm somewhat surprised your doc hasn't suggested one.
I know there is talk about the fibrosure/fibroscan but it's not widely available at this point. Right now it's still the biopsy that gives the best info for the widest amount of people.
Now here is the issue I am intrigued by, and here is an excerpt from the above linked article on HCV and Alcoholism:
"In addition to the high incidence of HCV infection in heavy drinkers even in the absence of classic risk factors, other observations suggest that heavy alcohol consumption enhances the ability of the virus to enter and persist in the body. For example, several studies demonstrated a correlation between the presence of virus in the blood (i.e., viremia) and the amount of alcohol patients reported they consumed (i.e., self-reported alcohol consumption, or SRAC) (see figure 2). Furthermore, moderation of alcohol consumption was shown to result in a decrease in the number of virus particles in the blood (i.e., the viral titer) (Cromie et al. 1996). Researchers do not yet fully understand the mechanism through which alcohol affects the viral titer. It is well known, however, that alcohol impairs the function of certain components of the body's immune system (Ince and Wands 1999). An impaired immune function, in turn, may influence the ability of the virus to persist in the body rather than be eliminated by immune cells. "
More than a few references in this long article were made to people 'acquiring' HCV because of alcoholism, in the ABSENCE of normal risk factors...like IVDU, transfusion, etc.
I have read several research studies in the past saying the same thing, and have several times noted that on the forum! Here is what I think may happen:
Be warned, the following is my theoretical speculation, and is not intended to be interpreted as fact!!!
OK, I think, as I have said in the past, that some or many people may harbor an 'inactive', or 'dormant' version of HCV that is either passed on from birth, or acquired casually, sexually, etc. and does not cause an active, detectable blood liver infection. Thus, no antibodies on testing, no elevated enzymes, no sign of HCV. In this subset of the population, those that become alcoholics may allow the virus to move from a 'latent, dormant' phase, into an active infection....the mechanism might be immune system suppression, alcohol's effect on multiplying the virus, or any number of other unknown mechanisms. The point is that most of these alcoholism studies indicate that alcoholics become (acquire) HCV positive at a much higher rate than the normal population. And, they are alcoholics who have been weeded out for other risk factors.
All of this fits my theory that HCV can transmit and be harbored by individuals in other ways than the typical active/ chronic/ acute blood liver infection.
For all we know, a major portion of the population could have a dormant HCV virus that would remain unknown, and virtually harmless for life, unless triggered, or activated by something (like heavy alcohol abuse).
I find this subject to be extremely thought provoking, and if you read the research article posted way above in this thread, you will also sense the surprise and curiosity of the researchers who are seeing this data in alcoholics, and trying to figure out why they 'acquire' HCV at such a high rate. Maybe they already had it, but it was invisible!!!
So, this is my off the wall thought for the week, and I look forward to the comments it generates.
By the way, if I haven't said it before, I really do believe there is much more about the behavior of this virus that we do not yet understand, than what we do currently understand. Look at the studies every week implicating a new disease, or manifestation to HCV. This week, the articles on Diabetes, and the continuing evidence of a link to HCV.
Have a nice day all of you!!!
DoubleDose
I've been told that sugar feeds a virus. If this is correct and alcohol turns to sugar in the body is this feeding the virus at a faster rate than say a twinkie would?
Any ideas?
I'm going to write a letter to my Doctor, try to sugar coat what I did, & pray the new results will show a significant improvement. Otherwise, I will be back to square one, but with more Hope than I've ever had before. Thank You. As for DoubleDose...It could be! I drank 7 days a week for 6 years on the national womens pool league circuit. I was very good with the Crown Bottle & the cue... ;) Prior to that I drank often. Then fell "sick & tired with pain" searching for 4 years before the diagnosed me withHepC. I no longer can sip a drop due to the BURNING in my stomach... Wish it id the same to me with the cocaine.. I'd be "Home Free" Tho I pray I'll never touch either ever again, I sadly report I've heard my own self too many times. My son is the only one I admit this too, and he reams me almost to the point of doing it again, my daughter..I am too ashamed to tell. Re-reading this I feel like a loser, but today, I am a loser with HOPE... I've never travelled that Path. NA says I will always b "recovering" I say "No.. I will be free from this Demon, I know I will" Have only been trying since Igot the news, and I have done great on my own. I moved from all my old friends, changed my number, lost theirs. And as I said, my kids hover over me in a good way. If I'd stay out of Walmarts I'd never be found from "Bad habit Buddies" ..but that ain't gonna happen.. Hopefully I have gotten a second chance and will make it. Thank you all. LipStick
May God bless you with wisdom and discernment.
triggertime
keepdafaith&don4get2giggle
Could you pass the Twinkies please. (grin)
Hope is a good thing.
Don't be ASHAMED --- Ever. It's a learning experience. We ALL have something we keep in the closet. Or in our Past. For each of us it is a different thing. For each of us - we guilt ourselves for what we think is something awful.
For example --- when I was a little kid... there was this other kid that had built a sandcastle on the beach.
I distinctly remember being so jealous (as a 3 year old - that was REALLY jealous) that this other kid could build this castle and I couldn't.
Now - being a billion years older ---- LOL - I realize that that lumpy bunch of dirt clumps and broken sticks was nothing but a pile of sand... But to my little kid... that castle was the greatest thing on earth... And I didn't build it.
So --- I went on a rampage and stomped on it --- and made that other little kid cry.
And I felt happy about it.
Until I got older and that memory surfaced --- and I felt like a schmuck.
So --- I guess I learned from that experience. I was ashamed that I could have done something like that - ever.
But I learned never to do it again.
I can't really compare drugs or addiction to my sand castle stomping experience. But I wanted you to know that sometimes it's not WHAT you have done that is bad... But sometimes it really is only how YOU --- view it.
So - try viewing it a different way. Instead of saying... Look how awful I am... Say.. Look - I'm really trying - check me out!
And Hope is awesome!
Hugs,
Meki
Whatever you do, whether you do the daily shots (Infergen?) or wait for some of the newer meds, I'd recommend doing everything possible to build up your strength. You know the drill: eat right and exercise, both of which will make you feel infinitely better. If you're debilitated from your last tx, maybe you need to take a few months off, at least, before doing the shots.
You're only stage 2, so you have time to regroup if you want to. There are so many new and improved therapies for this disease. If it were me, I'd wait, get healthy, and then go for Vertex or something like that when they're available.
You're a tough chick. I really admire you for staying off the drugs.
Best of luck,
Love,
pigeon
Ralph aka: ***@****
Sincerly Yours; Semper Fi: Latin for (Always Faithful to God and yourself). I love those who have the courage to hold on, and pray for those don't.
My advice is go to a hepatologist (Gastroenterologist specialized in the liver) and get the initial work-up: Bloodwork to look for indicators of cancer or cirrhosis, PCR to get viral count; genotype test, liver biopsy if he recommends it. Be sure and tell him about the gout.
If you are genotype 2 or 3, treatment is shorter and more successful and you may as well do it (most americans are genotype 1). If you have a low viral load you are much more likely to cure. Do the tests and let your doctor lay it all out and help you make a decision.
thats enough for me. It wasn't enough when I had hep in 1971, STUPID, but now that I'm OLD, I know bad things can happen and just the knowledge of the possibility of drinking escalating, or doing more damage is enough for me to not drink.
I guess we all pick our poisons.