Hepatitis Social Community
forum experiment
About This Community:

This forum is for hepatitis patients, family members, loved ones, friends or anyone with an interest in hepatitis, to have open social conversations about any topic they choose, with the exception of religion and politics. Please note that our standard “Rules for Posting in Public Areas”, which are found in our Terms of Use , also apply in this community. If you are newly diagnosed with Hepatitis or you have questions or information to share about current treatments, research studies, clinical trials, or other medical issues pertaining to Hepatitis, please post it in one of our Hepatitis Communities ( Hep A , Hep B , Hep C or Hep-autoimmune ).

Font Size:
A
A
A
Background:
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank Blank

forum experiment

How about an experiment?
No moderation for say 24 hours and remove stars and best answers too
the objective to see how the forum works, would it get out of hand ?
would we notice a difference?
are the Mods up for it?
are you up for it?

exact details to be finalised but i have some ideas
basically for 24 hours the mods watch but never react, the 24 hours would start without us knowing  within a one week period, so say its monday to friday within that the time the mods pick a 24 hr window and then start the clock without telling us..the report button remains active and this is how the experiment is scored , number of reports the only difference is after a post is reported nothing behind the scenes happen except a count of abuse
also after the 24hr period we are informed and we can gauge if the forum seemed different
i admit there is a lot to work out but could be interesting
would the powers that be , be up for it?
Related Discussions
25 Comments Post a Comment
Blank
179856_tn?1333550962
Oh my James you are always the eternal optimist and truth speaker there is no hidden agenda in your words and this is why I think you are marvelous!   :)

I still say kill the report button it is for children!   ;-P

x
Blank
1117750_tn?1307390169
the peasants are revoulting ha ha ;-)
Blank
9648_tn?1290094807
as long as the pheasants aren't revolting . . .
Blank
1117750_tn?1307390169
i would never say that about any bird    ;-)
Blank
206807_tn?1331939784
I think we need a Moderator that has been through tx, preferably one that had a rough sx. You can’t fully understand something you haven’t been through.
I compare it to me being a Moderator in the Breast Feeding Forum.
While I am at it, I had a post deleted and a Star removed. Get real we are not children.
Blank
1117750_tn?1307390169
yield to our request  Mods
ha ha
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
Get lost !!!!!!
medhelp.....trolling season !!!
Blank
Avatar_m_tn
I think that the new member who has posted a string of obnoxious posts isn't *just* a flip response, but serve as a sort of model for why moderation is needed.

There is a need for moderation on the board, and  failing one universal accepted model that pleases everyone MH has adapted one that they feel provides the greatest good for the greatest number of members.  Yes, at times I feel that is too "PG-13" or too proactive.

But.....it is good to have moderators to remove posts of people who are unable to communicate without being offensive.  This latest member seems to post with the clear intent of offense.

So....no......I'm not personally in favor of NO moderation, since there are many people who are unable to regulate themselves, much less their posts.  On any random day any of us can fall victim to our own impulsive or unfiltered posts.

Can you imagine reading the latest musings of raspberywhackjob day after day?

Board rules and moderation serve a purpose and need, IMHO.

Willy
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
Willy,

This type of abuse is quite different on so many levels.
And BTW: only targeted certain people....I find that odd.

The mods must be on holiday or I would have lost all my stars
by now :(.

I truly believe it is someone who has a personal vendetta.

Take care all
Elaine
Blank
9648_tn?1290094807
The poster you are referring to is totally a troll. I don't think anyone has argued that it's okay for the forum to be riddled trolls. The problems that many of us are responding to is having long-standing members posts removed during disagreements and the interpretation of what makes a personal attack.
Blank
1117750_tn?1307390169
whos a troll?
this thread is not about trolls , strawberry whoever has not posted here  , confused???
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
"And BTW: only targeted certain people....I find that odd. "

I thought so too at first that the target was specific people but then as I went through the threads he posted in, didn't seem too discriminate either.  School's out for summer, dontcha know.  These kinds of things happen on a number of forums when that happens and I really don't think this is someone with a personal vendetta but rather an immature idiot with a keyboard, an internet connection and nothing better to do.
Blank
220090_tn?1379170787
Hello all,  I am glad to see that not much has changed since I last signed on.  I think the poster you are referring to has been deleted from the forum.  I tried to read some of his/her posts and there are none.

Hello to all.  I hope you are all well.

Eric
Blank
1117750_tn?1307390169
ok just been told a load of posts were made and deleted, and iam a *****  , ha ha thats ok been called worse
Blank
475300_tn?1312426726
I got a warning for the "s**ools out" saying  last year    LOL
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
So....since my post is still standing, things are improving?  ;->
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
"The problems that many of us are responding to is having long-standing members posts removed during disagreements and the interpretation of what makes a personal attack."

I haven't seen that long-standing members are immune to behaving badly any more than new members.  In fact, in some cases, it seems that some members think they should be given more leeway because they have been here awhile.  If someone is going to be nasty and insulting, I don't care how long they've been here, how much they know or how much they think they know, they should be dealt with.  I don't think there should be one set of rules for one member over another based on how long they've been here  - do you?   Same rules should apply to all.  

The only leeway perhaps is that, amongst ourselves at least, we try to be more understanding of those who are on treatment - but even at that there's a limit to what is acceptable and postable on a public forum.   Being on treatment doesn't exactly give us carte blanche to say and do whatever we want either.   There has to be some kind of balance.

Blank
Avatar_f_tn
I have never been on any kind of public internet forum that wasn't moderated, even if it was a very informal kind of thing moderated by the person who paid for and created the forum.  They get moderated as to who is allowed on and what kind of posts they can put up.  I'm on an EX500 forum for my Kawasakin Ninja and THAT is moderated.  There's a reason for that.  Most people conduct themselves pretty well and as usual it's the minority that don't  OR the minority of times people who usually behave well step out of line.  
Blank
475300_tn?1312426726
I have to agree with you 100%!!
Blank
9648_tn?1290094807
" I don't think there should be one set of rules for one member over another based on how long they've been here  - do you?"

Not at all.

My point was that the longstanding members weren't trolls who suddenly appeared out of nowhere posting incendiary comments only to disappear again.

I fail to understand why you keep challenging me. We can have a different opinion, and apparently do. That's fine with me.

Pax
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
I"m not sure why you take it as challenging you.  I haven't been rude, I haven't been insulting, I'm not specifically targetting you either. I'm simply presenting an alternate point of view to the points you're making, it happens on this forum all the time.  Many points of view have shades of grey and people post their viewpoint.  I don't understand why you're taking offense to that.   If you think my goal is to specifically attack you or anyone, it's not.  I don't quite see it the way you do and I want to present an alternative thought.  That's it, that's all.  You considered your viewpoint worth posting and I felt the same about mine.  

As for your latest point about longstanding members, I maintain my own point.  I don't care how long they've been here.  It doesn't give them any more right to be nasty or insulting.  If anything, I would expect more of them because they know what's at stake here and engaging in personal attacks doesn't help any of us to maintain a forum where we can debate an issue with freedom from moderation.  I don't care how long they've been here, if they're going to be debating people instead of debating the topic then it needs to be addressed.  
Blank
9648_tn?1290094807
Actually, I'm not saying you've been rude or insulting. I'm also not taking offense. But you keep addressing me specifically and asking me questions as if to put me on the spot. Hence I see you challenging me.

You don't admit that you're doing it, but you are.

Some people might think that is a personal attack. Just sayin'.
Blank
Avatar_f_tn
Of course I'm addressing you specifically.  You're the one making the comments I want to respond to.  How is that a challenge??  Do you take that the same way every time someone responds to your posts??   Of course I don't admit it.  I'm not even close to approaching this as a challenge.  This isn't a competition here although I see some people approach posting on this forum that way.  I'm not one of them.  I simply like a good discussion between reasonable people and it's one of the reasons I go on various discussion forums.  I love exchanging ideas and do it often with reasonable people.  I see some shades of grey to your comments and like I've already said, I'm simply presenting an alternative point of view.  How on earth is that a challenge when that's what's happening on this thread and every other thread on this forum?

Frankly, it's me who's starting to feel attacked as I'm the only one getting accused of challenging people when I post an opinion and nobody else is.  Perhaps you have preconceived notions about me that are inaccurate and perhaps you want to consider that.  
Blank
1225178_tn?1318984204
I just wanted to say that I enjoy reading the posts between you two. It is 2 points of view, yes... but it doesn't appear mean spirited, and I think that is great!
Blank
233616_tn?1312790796
ten forum quality threads in as many days...something is afoot Watson!!!!!!!!!.

medhelp, I hope you are getting this !!
Blank
Post a Comment
To
Blank
Weight Tracker
Weight Tracker
Start Tracking Now
Hepatitis Social Community Resources
RSS Expert Activity
242532_tn?1269553979
Blank
How to Silence Your Inner Critic an...
Apr 16 by Roger Gould, M.D.Blank
242532_tn?1269553979
Blank
Emotional Eaters: How to Silence Yo...
Mar 26 by Roger Gould, M.D.Blank
1344197_tn?1392822771
Blank
Vaginal vs. Laparoscopic Hysterecto...
Feb 19 by J. Kyle Mathews, MD, DVMBlank
Top Hepatitis Answerers
1747881_tn?1358189534
Blank
hrsepwrguy
Greeley, CO
317787_tn?1373214989
Blank
Dee1956
DC
96938_tn?1189803458
Blank
FlGuy
South, FL
Avatar_m_tn
Blank
willbb
446474_tn?1385271190
Blank
HectorSF
CA
Avatar_m_tn
Blank
can-do-man
IN