Nutrition Health Chat: Tuesday, Dec. 8th, 5-6 PM Eastern. Learn how vitamins, minerals, and phytonutrients affect your health. Free live Q&A. Join us!
Member Comments are provided by individuals and reflect their personal opinions only. Under NO circumstances should you act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum.  ALWAYS check with your personal physician before taking any action regarding your health! MedHelp International and our partners, sponsors and affiliates have no obligation to monitor any comments posted on this site, or the content and/or accuracy of such exchanges. MedHelp International does not endorse the views of any user.
 | 

A good idea gone bad - donating blood?

by Lulu54, Aug 02, 2009 09:36AM
On an impulse yesterday I donated blood as part of the Extreme Makeover home Edition going on in my neighborhood.  I felt fine until about 4 hours later.

Then it was all I could do to function.  We had gone to dinner at a friend's house and I had to get home.  When I came in I turned on the computer to check in here.  I managed to read the swirling controversy but before I could reply I either 1) fell asleep or 2) passed out.

I had no warning that I was going off into someplace else.  When I woke almost three hours later, I was holding my laptop computer.  Last night  and again today, it feels like I have been drinking heavily, with my internal body being rather shakey.  But i don't have a headache and I definitely had nothing to drink besides water all day.  



And yes, the blood bank folks had my complete med history and they rules have been revised so MS patients can donate as long as they are ambulatory.

I'm wondering if perhaps the blood donation set off some strange MS reaction - anyone out there with a clue?

be well,
Lulu


Member Comments (17)

by Deb61, Aug 02, 2009 09:54AM
To: Lulu54
After reading your post, I felt a need to immediately respond.  Yes, I had a really bad experience giving blood.  Many years ago I decided to give blood.  I was the correct weight, ate, and was young.  However, toward the end of the blood donation, I went into grand-mal seizures for several minutes.  During that period of time, I had no idea what was going--that period of time was completely black.  There was no vague memory of anyone talking to me or trying to get me out of it or dreams.  It was like that period of time was completely missing.  

Looking back, I wonder if I had MS back then.  I think there is a biological explanation (not sure how).  I think the nerves misfire when a trigger, like brain damage or MS, when something triggers it.  How scary!  As a result, I will never give blood again.  I was really bad off the next day.  It took a couple of days before I was back on my feet again.  

Take care of yourself and avoid the heat today.  You may want to call your doctor as well about this episode just to see if you're okay.

Deb

by luverofrogs, Aug 02, 2009 10:12AM
(((((((((((LuLu)))))))))))))))  I cannot donate blood because my veins are too small, so I don't have any experience with this.  It sounds very scary though.  Take it easy and be careful.

by Lulu54, Aug 02, 2009 10:31AM
thanks,
the only thing I can think of is my body was reacting to the trauma of losing blood - and I will be at the neuro's office tomorrow so i will run this by the nurses there.

It was very odd when I woke last night - usually if I'm going to nod off, I know it and do put the computer aside.  :-)

I'm taking it easy today,
L

by goofysmom1, Aug 02, 2009 11:57AM
To: Lulu
I am so sorry you had such a reaction!  I hope you are feeling better today.  Giving blood is such a wonderful gift - but only if we can do it without feeling sick afterwords.

I will be curious to hear what the nurses say about it and if your reaction was related to MS.

Hope you feel better!

Hugs,
Chrisy

by ShadowsSister, Aug 02, 2009 12:07PM
To: Lulu54
Hi it just me again, you said they told you the rules reguarding Those with MS was changed? I was told several years ago I couldn't donate blood because of the MS and my medications at that time?
I am so glad you are seeing your Nuro tomorrow. Please try to rest today and keep your feet up... I am so sorry this happened to you. I know how wise you are and that means you won't be running any races today or tomorrow.. Try to stay relaxed and cool
Love & Prayers are being sent & said..{{{~!~}}}

by Karen99, Aug 02, 2009 12:36PM
To: Lulu54
How bizarre was that?  Just when you think things couldn't get an weirder.  

Drink plenty of fluids today.  Take good care of yourself.

by Lulu54, Aug 02, 2009 12:41PM
hey Dj, they changed the American Red Cross rules two years ago about MS patients donating.I was surprised that even with the dmd's I could donate.

Karen, drinking lots of fluids sure complicates the ongoing bladder fun but I'm trying!!!  :-)

L

by sllowe, Aug 02, 2009 02:04PM
Lu - did you start that baclofen too?

If so, could have been a contributor. Even through titration, I was able to bonk off at anytime of the day.  

by Lulu54, Aug 02, 2009 03:52PM
yes, I started the baclofen and have been adding doses - I am now at 3 times a day with 1/2 a pill - 15mg total right now. maybe that's it - I would be more than happy to bonk off!

L

by Sarahsmom46, Aug 02, 2009 04:21PM
To: Lu
How bizarre.  I'm so sorry that happened to you as your intentions were good.  You think your body would have cut you some slack.

I agree with whoever said it probably has a lot to do with starting the baclofen. Donating the blood probaly didn't help either.   Baclofen is a poten drug especially in the beginning.  What is the dose you are titrating up to?  

Let us know what the nurses advise. It will be helpful for us all to learn the do's and don'ts.  

Julie

by Charley123, Aug 03, 2009 05:30AM
To: Lulu54
I'm beginning to think that any procedure has the potential to set off MS attacks.  I have had a lot of blood drawn lately, but not as much as you, and have felt very weak and light headed for a few days afterwards.  I also had a bad spell after the conlonoscopy I had in April.  It was right after the colonoscopy that my sed rate went up to 129 and I now have polymyalgia rheumatica, giant cell arteritis and possible fibromyalgia-on top of MS.  I've been on prednisone for 4 weeks and while some of the inflammation seems to be getting better, the MS symptoms (heat related, balance etc.) are worse than they were during hottest days last summer.  The timing may be coincidental.  
I don't really know. But, I do like your question as I've had the same one for a number of years. Charley

by Lulu54, Aug 03, 2009 05:32PM
To: All
I really must make sure that I have the official record here - there is absolutely no connection between my exhaustion Saturday night and the fact I donated blood earlier in the day to the blood drive.

I asked that question on the MS nurse at my neuro's office and she emphatically said it was not a problem.

Then a short bit later I asked my neuro himself the same question and got the same answer.  He said that there was no way that donating blood affects the course of MS.

So there we have it folks - next time you want to do so, you are cleared to donate.  The Red Cross will take our blood and the doctor says its ok!

My best,
Lulu

by goofysmom1, Aug 03, 2009 05:51PM
To: Lulu
Well that is good to know.  Did either the nurse or neuro have any thoughts on what may have caused such a strong reaction?

Hugs,
Chrisy

by Lulu54, Aug 03, 2009 06:14PM
Chrisy,
It may have been the baclofen that I just started this week and/or good old fashioned tiredness.  

my best,
L

by goofysmom1, Aug 03, 2009 06:32PM
To: Lulu
Amazing how our bodies (don't) cope with things huh!  :)

Hope you are feeling better now.

Hugs,
Chrisy

by Weakandfalling, Aug 05, 2009 09:27AM
To: Lulu54
You were so kind to want to donate even with your MS symptoms.  I am sorry you had a bad reaction afterward!  

I had signed up to give blood a couple of years ago, but then had to cancel the pledge because I felt so weak that I knew that I would need every drop of blood I currently had just to maintain my current state of weakness and not become even weaker.

Please listen to your own body and experience and don't give any more blood despite what the medical "authorities" might say!  I have come to learn (the hard way) that today's medical authorities often aren't authorities at all!  One day they say something is fine and the next they retract the statement and take an opposing position. Just consider their previous position on postmenopausal woman and estrogen supplementation.  They really just don't know all that we (and they) think they do.  

I think Charlie123 has a point:  It may be that any intervention might trigger a relapse or bad symptoms in a person with MS. That has been his experience as a person diagnosed wtih MS. That is also true of people with ALS as well as bipolars:  Any surgery etc. can cause a bad reaction or worsening of condition.

So, please, be careful.  Donate money or time, not blood!!

WAF

by Mand125, Aug 05, 2009 10:41AM
To: Lulu54
Some years ago my daughter was donating blood, it was before her MS diagnosis but soon after I was dx, I asked her to check for me whether I would still be able to donate - I had done so regularly for about 25 years before that.

The lady (nurse I think?) she spoke to said that while I would be allowed to donate she certainly wouldn't recommend it as she thought it "wouldn't do me any good at all".

I haven't donated since I was dx because of that.

Mand
Related discussions
Post Comment
To
Comment
Post Comment
Recent Activity
saveone commented on To Stanford and Back ...
10 mins ago
Zacksmomi needs to get off this computer if I want to see at all t...
Zacksmomi commented on photo
2 hrs ago
Zacksmomi uploaded new photos
2 hrs ago
docflick commented on Functional
2 hrs ago
mrspianoman added the Multiple Sclerosis Tracker
3 hrs ago
shoshin commented on To Stanford and Back ...
3 hrs ago
sllowe commented on To Stanford and Back ...
3 hrs ago
RSS Expert Activity
7 Ways to Reduce Stress During the ...
12 hrs ago by Steven Y Park, MD
What You Can Learn From Tiger Woods...
Dec 04 by Steven Y Park, MD
When the Mexican Drug Trade Hits th...
Dec 03 by Arnold L Goldman, D.V.M.
Community Members