After a few weeks of research I think I have come upon something and
I have a few questions.
I have posted here before and have got wonderful suggestions. I have been
seeing a Physiatrist for about 5 months for a horrible lower right back pain,
with referred pain into the groin and leg. The back pain is the primary pain.
They have treated me right by the book but all tests are negative.
(MRI, bone scan, CT abdomen, EMG) I found the following information
on the internet:
- lesion labeled annuular tear or internal disruption is based on
concept of leaking disc, one which permits the irritating liquid
material normally restricted to the center of the disc to come into
contact with the innervated tissue;
- annular tissue that permits egress of this liquid has a poor capacity
- at most, a thin layer of scar tissue at the periphery of the tear may
seal the leak but leave the disc highly susceptible to retearing;
- where as herniated disc has a significant capacity to be resolved w/
time, annular tear continues to produce symptoms indefinitely;
- clinical picture is based on pain related to increased intradiscal
pressure and irritability of neural structures;
- annular tear is usually produced by injury that increases intradiscal
- predominant element in the history is back pain, either alone or in
exess of leg pain;
- leg pain may be either unilateral or bilateral;
- increases in intradiscal pressure exacerbate the pain;
- pain is often worse when sitting than when standing;
- coughing & sneezing worsen the pain as do forward bending and lifting;
- on PE no nerve compression is evident;
- key finding is positive sciatic stretch test that produces back pain
or back pain greater than leg pain;
- positive test is presummably produced by tension on irritated dural
tissue or possibly by increased intradiscal pressure;
- myelogram, MRI, & CT, tests show no compression of neural structures;
- key test is discography with CT discography;
- positive examination will show dye extending into the epidural space
or extending to the periphery of the disc where it can contact
innervated portion of the annulus fibrosus;
- posiitve test also requires a reproduction of pain accompanying
injection of dye;
- back pain alone or back pain greater than leg pain;
- increased back pain with increased intradiscal pressure;
- reproduction of back pain to greater degree than leg pain by sciatic
- no neurologic deficit;
- reproduction of pain by discography and discographic dye extending to
or beyond the periphery of the annulus fibrosis;
I FIT THIS PROFILE ALMOST 100%- I just found this yesterday and have not
mentioned it to my Doctor. I have not had a Discogram but my questions
are as follows:
1. Is it necessary to have a Discogram to find this, because if the
treatment does not change, why go thru the pain?
2. What is the treatment for an annular tear if indeed this is what I have?
Is is always non-surgical, surgical?
3. Can a person recover fully from an annular tear, or will I have to
rely on pain management the rest of my life??
4. Are there any publications which may discuss annular tears in greater
detail. I live in a small Indiana city where there is no major
medical school, so I have limited access to a medical library.
My mother lives in Cleveland, if indeed this is what I have does
it make sense to visit you folks at the Cleveland clinic?
Thank you so much,
Your questions address very contoversial areas in the managemant of back and leg pain, and answers will differ depending upon speciality, region of the world, experience and expertise, etc.
The very existence of "discogenic" pain and pain from annular tears, while plausible, is controversial. The "test" is the reproduction of pain with injection into one particulat disc (and not others) during discography. This is obviously a rather subjective test open to inerpretation.
The prognosis following anterior interbody fusion (frequently offered operative treatment for this situation) may be no better that the prognosis with just conservative treatment. No randomised controlled trial to address this has been done, however.
Modern day MRI (with/without contrast) is probably almost as sensitive for annular tears as a discogram is. The problem lies not in finding abnormalities on spine imaging studies (they are abundant even in asymptomatic individuals); the problem lies in knowing what to do with these abnormalities. Regrettably there is little scientific evidence to support several common surgical practices.
The following are some publications that may be of interest.
Magnetic resonance imaging of the lumbar spine in people without back pain N Engl J Med (United States), Jul 14 1994, 331(2) p69-73
AUTHOR(S): Jensen MC; Brant-Zawadzki MN; Obuchowski N; Modic MT; Malkasian D; Ross JS
Spine (United States), Feb 1 1996, 21(3) p402-4
AUTHOR(S): Bogduk N; Modic MT
Contrast-enhanced MR imaging in acute lumbar radiculopathy: a pilot study of the natural history
Radiology (United States), May 1995, 195(2) p429-35
AUTHOR(S): Modic MT; Ross JS; Obuchowski NA; Browning KH; Cianflocco AJ; Mazanec DJ
N.B. Dr Modic is the chairman of the department of radiology at the Cleveland Clinic, and an internationally renowned expert on spine imaging.
It does make sense to see us at the Cleveland Clinic! Please call (216(444-5559, or (800)223-2273 for appointments. You may benefit the most by seeing a neuromuscular specialist first (any of Drs. Mitsumoto, Shields, Levin, or Pioro).
The Content on this Site is presented in a summary fashion, and is intended to be used for educational and entertainment purposes only. It is not intended to be and should not be interpreted as medical advice or a diagnosis of any health or fitness problem, condition or disease; or a recommendation for a specific test, doctor, care provider, procedure, treatment plan, product, or course of action. MedHelp is not a medical or healthcare provider and your use of this Site does not create a doctor / patient relationship. We disclaim all responsibility for the professional qualifications and licensing of, and services provided by, any physician or other health providers posting on or otherwise referred to on this Site and/or any Third Party Site. Never disregard the medical advice of your physician or health professional, or delay in seeking such advice, because of something you read on this Site. We offer this Site AS IS and without any warranties. By using this Site you agree to the following Terms and Conditions. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your physician or 911 immediately.