Although ammonia levels are usually elevated somewhat in classic hepatic encephalopathy, a normal ammonia does not completely rule it out. In fact, a recent study showed that the actual level of ammonia does not correspond with the degree of encephalopathy, although the increased ammonia is thought to play some kind of role in neurological dysfunction with liver disease. You are correct on your second point in that any kind of liver disease, if severe enough to compromise the liver's ability to metabolize things, can certainly lead to an encephalopathy. We see this quite frequently at the CLeveland CLinic in patients who have Wilson's disease (a genetic liver disease), alcholic cirrhosis, or hepatitis in addition to other diseases that affect the liver. Hope that helps.
My gastroenterologist recently entertained the idea that my severe neurological "spells" (epidsodes of increasing talkativeness, which progresses to uncharacteristic rage, inability to read/write, not knowing where I am, ending with fatigue and drowsiness) may be caused by hepatic encephalopathy. He felt that the chronic viral-like illness I'm experiencing, combined with the neurological "spells," might suggest liver dysfunction. However, recent testing to support his suspicion came back normal (except for a high creatinine level..... not sure if that was serum or urine concentration of creatine. Pretty sure it was urine.)
I was initially diagnosed with right temporal lobe epilepsy. However, while my EEGs have never been completely normal, they are not grossly abnormal and vary in where the abnormalities are located. First one had right temp. lobe spiking and slowing. Second EEG showed frontal slowing, both right and left, but no spiking. Third EEG showed distinct right temp. lobe slowing and occassional left temp. lobe slowing, but no spiking. A subsequent outpatient 5-day EEG showed variations of all of the above - however I did not experience a "spell" during the testing.
Attempts to medicate me have fed the severity of the episodes instead of easing them. My internist experimented with giving me trials of sedatives and anti-psychotics (Zyprexa) to see if they would take the edge off of the "spells." This caused a startling increase in symptoms. Which leads my gastroenterologist to believe that possibly my liver is not metabolizing correctly and is allowing toxins to "get to" my brain.
Sorry to be so long-winded. It's been a complicated journey through this illness. Still no clear answers.
Take care, doctor, and thank you for your service here.