First of all, keep in mind that I am unable to diagnose you because I am unable to examine you, this forum is for educational purposes.
The symptoms that you describe are non-specific, but I can give you a range of possible causes and suggest some more testing. The feet are the site of the longest nerves in the body(they
travelTravel sickness from the brain, down the spine, down your leg, and into you feet). Thus if any process affects all of your nerves (the feet are the first to show signs of the damage). Common processes that damage nerves are diabetes, alcohol, vitamin deficiencies, thyroid problems, some cancers, and genetic conditions,etc. In addition to processes that affect all the nerves, some causes specifically affect the region of the feet. The lumbar spine (lower back) can degenerate causing discs to protrude onto the nerves traveling to the feet. I would suggest that you have some additional blood work including glucose tolerance test (3 hour GTT), B12, TSH, Monoclonal protein analysis, Hu protein and paraneoplastic panel, ESR, CRP, ANA, RPR, vitamin E level, and copper level. I would also have an EMG (nerve muscle test) to evaluate the health of the nerves going to you feet. I would also suggest an MRI of your lumbar spine to evaluate for any structural lesion (disc, tumor, spinal stenosis etc.) If the above are negative, I would suggest a lumbar puncture to evaluate the spinal fluid for any signs of inflammation or cancer cells. I do not think the symptoms that you describe are consistent with MS.
I hope this has been helpful.
I have that numbness in my feet behind my toes.... it used to drive me crazy... couldn't sit.... couldn't sleep..... my neurologist put me on Topomax (topamax).... I still have the numbness.... but it doesn't drive me crazy like it did..... if you come up with something better let me know...