Update: Your responses prompted me to seek a second opinion. I took her to the cleveland clinic and after reviewing her previous records and our descriptions of her episodes the dr. felt they were most likely right temporal lobe seizures. She will have an mri and proably another veeg soon. Thank you for your comments.
Its sometimes difficult to distinguish between a parasomnia and a nocturnal seizure. Parasomnias such as night terrors or nightmares can occur at this age group. Seizures coming from the frontal lobe can also occur with similar symptoms to what you describe. The only sure way to diagnose which is to record them on video-EEG, one cannot 100% exclude one or the other without this.
TS has a set of criteria which allow the diagnose of defininte, probable or possible TS with major and minor criteria. 2 major or 1 major and 2 minor criteria must be met for a diagnosis. Major criteria include
Facial angiofibromas or forehead plaque
Non-traumatic ungual or periungual fibroma
Hypomelanotic macules (more than three)
Shagreen patch (connective tissue nevus)
Multiple retinal nodular hamartomas
Cortical tubera
Subependymal nodule
Subependymal giant cell astrocytoma
Cardiac rhabdomyoma, single or multiple
Lymphangiomyomatosis
Renal angiomyolipoma
Minor criteria include
Multiple randomly distributed pits in dental enamel
Hamartomatous rectal polypsc
Bone cysts
Cerebral white matter migration lines
Gingival fibromas
Non-renal hamartoma
Retinal achromic patch
"Confetti" skin lesions
Multiple renal cysts
If she truly has >3 hypopigmented spots on evaluation of her entire skin by a doctor under a Woods lamp, and dental pits as above she would meet the crtieria for 'probable' but not definite TS (one major and one minor criteria). This email is for educational purposes only and cannot substitiute for a formal medical opinion. More testing like a retinal examination, heart and kidney ultrasound scans might be warranted to look for signs of TS. Sometimes an examination of the parents can be useful to look for subtle signs of TS can be helpful as a percentage of cases are inherited from parents. Most cases are sporadic mutations (not inherited).
I am a registered nurse. I happen to have an 8 yr. old niece who has T.S., dx'd at age 2yr. I really feel you should get a second opinion from a different neuro, a pediatric neuro. For 3 main reasons: 1. Your new pediatrician recommended to return to the neuro, 2. She is continuing to have these episodes that remain unchanged after 2 years (her body is trying to say something), and 3. Her mommy and daddy seem to have a gut feeling that something is not right! #3 is vital to me as a former pediatric nurse! I am a mother of 4 myself. We always know before the docs do if something is wrong with our child. If someone isn't listening or being thorough enough with persistent symptoms, go elsewhere. Do not allow them to make you second guess your own good parental instincts. I have tremendous faith in the field of medicine. MOST docs are truly gifted, however, as with any field, there are some that should not be practicing. Just go with your gut!
T.S. can be tricky. Sometimes difficult to dx, espec. if you are in a smaller town. This is not a common illness, therefore sometimes signs and symptoms can be overlooked. Obviously, the more a doc sees this disease, the easier it is to detect and dx which may be more likely in a larger hospital or town.
Has your daughter been dx'd with "ash-leaf" spots or lesions, (the hypopigmented areas often shaped like an ashleaf or long and narrow).I believe you mentioned she has one? Or, "cafe au lait" spots which are areas of hyperpigmentation? Any unusual growths, changes in vision, possible seizure activity (falling down, briefly "zoning out" or staring, mild twitches)? These night time episodes sound suspicious since they are so chronic and seem to follow the same pattern every time. Since you have read up on TS you are aware any area of the body can be affected since these lesions can present anywhere.
I wish you luck with your daughter. Cont. to find answers. These night episodes should be evaluated further.
Sorry if I wasn't clear in intial post. My daughter is now 8. We live in the Cleveland area and her previous testing was done at Rainbow Babies.