1) surgery does not gaurantee releif of symptoms. It depends on where the nerve has been injured and the ulnar nerve is notoriously difficult to localize an injury based on electrodiagnostic studies. Based on your history of a possible stretch injury it is more probable to be the site of injury, although with only sensory involvment clinically or by EMG this is less certain as anywhere form the distal sensory brancy in the forearm and higher may have been affected.
Surgey will not help a fixed nerve injury that has occurred already but may help in terms of ongoing repeated truama or compression. Evidence of this comes in the form of episodic worsening of symptoms after compression or EMG evidence of ongoing active denervation by the presence of fibrillation potentials. This may help in the risk/benefit decision to try a surgery. If you have not had a detailed EMG examination of that limb - at least 5-6 ulnar muscles, this may help in the decision.
Tingling after tapping your wrist is not a specific sign for damage at that site, it still could be from damage anywhere along the course of the nerve.
A consultation with a neuromuscular specialist may help interpret your clinical history and electrodiagnostic studies to come to a comclusion whether further injury to the nerve is possible. In the meantime you should avoid positions of ulnar nerve compression like leaning on your elbows etc
Good luck
thanx kc-- i get massageed every week. no help.
One thing that might be interesting to know is whether you test positive on the gene test for HNPP--hereditary neuropathy with liability to pressure palsies. Basically, everyone's little finger can briefly fall asleep in response to the wrong pose, but people with HNPP are particularly prone to compression neuropathies. Diabetics (and pre-diabetics) are, as well, so that may be something to watch.
Hope you get an answer to your surgery question.
I have had ulnar problems for several years following a bad experience with chiropractic treatment for carpal tunnel type symptoms.
The very best relief I have received upper body therapeutic massage by a licensed therapist. This was just recently, and the results are excellent, very little remaining symptoms after just a few massages.
mike, do you rest your elbow alot in a certain position on a table or similar? I used to prop my head up alot against my hand with my elbow on my computer desk and it caused ulnar nerve parastesia which was present 100% of the time, but it went away after I realized the cause and stopped leaning up against my elbow. Just something to think about
beeen there, donethat.. it's always there.