Aa
A
A
Close
Avatar universal
Why do so many choose the amnio over the CVS??
just wondering.
Cancel
6 Answers
Page 1 of 1
189192 tn?1261345228
CVS is a much new procedure and not as widely available.  

One of the benefits to CVS is that it can be done sooner than amnio.  
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Comment
Post Comment
99627 tn?1301274552
CVS also has higher risk of misscarige than amnio. I believe 1 in 100
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Comment
Post Comment
Avatar universal
Are you testing because of a positive risk factor? I guess so much about which test is best for an individual hinges on what you will do with the results. If you will keep your baby no matter what the outcome, I would skip the tests. If you might consider termination if an abnormality is found I'd take the higher risk CVS (1:100 m/c); it will offer you results weeks earlier than an amnio (1:200 m/c). From everything I've ever read, a late second trimester abortion is really a human tragedy.

I realize many centers that perform amnios regularly quote lower m/c stats.  But I'd always go into the test with a conservative number in my mind, because it could be your reality. While you read of most invasive tests going just fine there is a risk factor placed on it for a reason and it should be seriously considered. I've read at least one post on this forum where sadly one of the moms was the "1" in 100 that m/c due to CVS.

Best of luck on a healthy and worry-free pregnancy :0)
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Comment
Post Comment
161782 tn?1201221532
I had a mc after a CVS, so I've since gone with an amnio (had one with DD and with this preg)

My doctors claim a 1 in 1600 risk for either proceedure, but I still think an amnio is safer and as tanker points out, the test has been available longer than CVS.

The thing that stinks about the amnio is you have to wait until at least 16 weeks, and the results can take another 2 weeks unless a 2-day FISH test, which gives prelim results is available.

It really is a personal choice.  If you would never terminate, then there's really no point risking it.  There are also some good screening tests at 12 weeks, but they are not definintive and often give you false positives.

Good luck to you whatever you choose.

P.S.  For the record, neither the CVS or amnio were painful.

Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Comment
Post Comment
Avatar universal
Thanks for the comments. I called to make an appointment for a NT scan on March 7th she asked if something came back not normal if I would want the CVS. I said I would but hopfully the NT scan is good. So I won;t have to struggle with the chose.,,(sigh) The other thing is, it looks like I'll be without insurance for weeks 15-28.
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Comment
Post Comment
Avatar universal
I hope you get great numbers back from your scan!
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Comment
Post Comment
Your Answer
Avatar universal
Answer
Do you know how to answer? Tap here to leave your answer...
Answer
Answer
Post Answer
A
A
Top Pregnancy Answerers
Avatar f tn
Blank
maw4389
Avatar n tn
Blank
hkjen
2080231 tn?1444937185
Blank
dianaexoh
Royal Oak, MI
Avatar f tn
Blank
2gs_2bs_andcounting
Avatar f tn
Blank
Rosieray27
Avatar f tn
Blank
sgulia1987
Blank
Pregnancy Tracker
Track your pregnancy
Start Tracking Now
Recent Activity
4548024 tn?1474842725
Blank
renae176 commented on renae176's status
18 hrs ago
18981035 tn?1474954407
Blank
sweetbee3 added the Weight Tracker
Sep 27
4769306 tn?1451008167
Blank
KeeLolo Well O day was Sept 21st. I... Comment
Sep 26
Pregnancy: Age 35+ Community Resources
Top Pregnancy Answerers
Avatar f tn
Blank
maw4389
Avatar n tn
Blank
hkjen
2080231 tn?1444937185
Blank
dianaexoh
Royal Oak, MI
Avatar f tn
Blank
2gs_2bs_andcounting
Avatar f tn
Blank
Rosieray27
Avatar f tn
Blank
sgulia1987