It was blood. His fingers scratched your vaginal walls and you bled.
On april 12 my boyfriend fingered me. A bunch of brown stuff came out. We thought I started my period but i didn't. What was it?
Yes, sperm that shoots out of male fingers gets you pregnant 100% of the time and always with tripletes. Obviously you are not over reacting and feeling vaginal tears from the fingering and stomach pain from the stress.
Unless you had full penetration with his penis inside you and he *** then your not pregnant and I would try not to stress as that will make your period late good luck