I'd retest again since the results for your tests have differed so much. I'd go with the herpes WB. Your doctor can find out what blood to draw and where to send it at http://depts.washington.edu/rspvirus/herpes.htm .
I just don't know about all these scores. My NP said either pos or neg never gave any numbers or anything. I never saw the actual test result. She gave me the results on the phone. thanks, EB