The current test does have a free T4 of 1.2 with with a reference range of .8 - 1.8. The original had a free T4 of 1.03 with the same ref range. Also, the original had T3 total of 117, ref range, 60 - 181, T3 uptake 30.4, ref range 22.5 - 37 while T4 is 9.3 ref range 4.5 - 10.9. Don't have these values for current since test was submitted by a different doc with a different lab. But both tests don't have free T3 as per current doc's dismissal of any value for diagnosis.
Did your MD do a Free T3 and Free T4, it would be nice to see these levels since this is what to medicate by, if your MD did not do these labs then he has no business prescribing medication based on TSH only, if you have these labs please post them with the ranges provided/ FTB4