Are you getting the labs done at the same time of day? TSH can fluctuate as much as 75% over the course of a day, typically, being higher in the morning.
Wherever you're getting your thyroid panel done, may let your get the antibody tests, as well, otherwise, we can provide you with websites from which you can purchase them, then go to a lab, specified by the site for collection. That may be what you're doing?
I'm sure you'll need a doctor's order to get the ultrasound and/or other imaging tests, which would tell whether you have nodules and if they're toxic.
Remember that not all specialists (endocrinologists) are good thyroid doctors.
Be careful of the xanax, though as I've seen people have a hard time get off them. What happens when we have a thyroid issue is that the adrenals, often, come into play to help the thyroid (both part of the endocrine system), so you could have an abundance of cortisol, along with your high Free T3.
You might try researching a more natural approach for sleep, with melatonin or adaptogens, magnesium, B vitamins, etc - all of which can be calming. Just a thought.
Please post your new results with ranges, when you get them.
Free T4 isn't used, directly; it's a storage hormone and has to be converted to Free T3, which is used by individual cells in the body. It's not unusual for Free T3 to remain higher, through conversion, once thyroid production actually declines. Your Free T4 is only at 25% of the range; it should be about mid range, while your Free T3 is at 84% of its range; it should be in the upper half to upper third, depending on where the patient feels best.
Have you had antibody tests to determine if you have Hashimoto's? The tests you need are Thyroid Peroxidase Antibodies (TPOab) and Thyroglobulin Antibodies (TgAb). You need them both, since some of us have one or the other and some have them both. You should also get the Thyroid Stimulating Immunoglobulin (TSI) test to rule out Graves, since some people do get them both.
It's also common, with Hashimoto's to swing from periods of hyper alternating with periods of hypo and normal before settling into permanent hypo. A hyper phase of Hashimoto's is also considered hashitoxicosis.
With your Free T4 as low as it is, it's apparent that your thyroid is not producing much thyroid hormones, since T4 is the main hormone produced. There are a couple of possibilities as to what's happening since your Free T3 is so high - 1 is that most of the Free T4 being converted to Free T3, as has already been mentioned.
The other possibility is that you could have nodules that are producing hormones independently of your thyroid. This is called toxic nodules. You would need a thyroid ultrasound to help determine this. An ultrasound will determine if you have nodules and if they are hot or cold. Further testing may be needed to determine if the nodules (if present) are producing hormones on their own.
"High levels of free T3 is evident early on in cases of hyperthyroidism (overactive thyroid). While the concentration may be normal for a long time in cases of hypothyroidism (underactive thyroid) however, concentration of T3 may be normal for a long time due to the increase in conversion from T4."
- Werlabs - Free T3 (triiodothyronine)
***
"It should be pointed out that, especially in the US literature, the term ‘hashitoxicosis’ is sometimes used to describe an autoimmune thyroid disease overlap syndrome of Graves’ and Hashimoto’s disease.2 In this article the term is strictly limited to the ‘leakage’ symptoms of active Hashimoto’s disease.
Hashitoxicosis is most likely to present in the early stages of autoimmune hypothyroidism."
Touch Endocrinology -
Hashitoxicosis – Three Cases and a Review of the Literature
Hi and welcome...
What's the dosage of your NatureThroid and how long have you been on it? It's not unusual for those on desiccated hormones to have higher Free T3 and lower Free T4 levels, because of all the T3 in the desiccated hormones. The fact that your TSH is as high as it is, indicates that your dosage might need to be increased.
Were you on another medication prior to starting the NatureThroid? What medication and what dosage, for how long?
Can you tell us, exactly, what symptoms you have? There are some symptoms that "cross over" (apply to either/both hyper and hypo)...