87651 tn?1259606003
Soy?
Hi All,

Quick question... I will drink a SlimFast every so often. After reading the contents, its says sweetened with milk and soy. I am on Armour, 45 mgs. Any thoughts? Or can we have soy, but within a certain timeframe of taking meds?

MK
Cancel
9 Answers
Page 1 of 1
499534 tn?1328707778
Hi there,  I have read a lot of negative information on consuming soy when you are a thyroid patient. The slimfast sounds like it is probably very small amounts though. Just stay away from Soy foods and consuming a lot of products with soy in it.  How do you like being on Armour? I am going to get switched here shortly.
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
168348 tn?1379360675
Hello .. I'm not sure .... but whatever you do keep it consistent so that the tests reveal it the same from day to day .. week to week .. month to month kind of thing with no changing variables .. ie., I take my synthroid with coffee and milk and it isn't the best way to take it .. I don't eat for 1/2 hr .. which is good .. so as long as I am consistent I am ok .. with Armour, though, I am clueless.

C~
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
87651 tn?1259606003
Thanks C! I was just going to have one this afternoon.  I dont drink them really. My hubby does.
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
Avatar universal
Take this with a grain of salt but…

I thought I once read that the issue of soy is irrelevant after you’ve had your thyroid completely removed and there is no more thyroid tissue to be effected.  The same goes for the lists of foods that are discouraged for someone who has a thyroid problem - they can’t effect what’s not there.

The only food I read to avoid, eat sparingly or separate by many hours from the med are walnuts.  I read they can neutralize thyroid medication and cause it to not work.
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
461147 tn?1214593029
u got me thinkin on this one! i just googled some stuff (not sure the reliability) and from what i found, if you do not have a thyroid and rely completely on meds for tsh, then soy shouldn't have any effect.  i'm going to my dr. next week though and i am going to ask, because i am a soy queen lol
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
219241 tn?1413541365
Funny how we all get different information! I did my research and found that soy is a no-no if eaten/drunk on a daily basis for ANY thyroid patient. If you have it once every couple of weeks then its fine but not on a daily basis. I'll find the medical research link and post it later today...(hopefully if I don't forget!)
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
219241 tn?1413541365
Hmmm can't find the link I was on about. But all the research I did read today basically says it's ok to have soy, but just NOT at the same time or within an hour or so of taking your medication. Makes sense to me! We shouldn't take ANYTHING else except our tablet in the morning. Sensitive little pill!
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
393685 tn?1425816122
Hello M!!

OK here is what I know - Soy is filled with isoflavones (sp) - these are components that bind in our system. Ingested in small amounts they are harmless - but for hypoT patients IF still not regulated - even the smallest amounts of soy bind together and cause problems.

The thyroid is not the only hormones effected - sex glands - pitutary- adrenals- the whole circle of our bodies hormones will not work together if there is interruption. Since you have no thyroid and your meds are creating the TH needed to stablize - then soy may interfer with the absorption of Armour.

As you become balanced and all hormones are working together with your meds - you should limit soy comsumption. I love soy milk - I hate milk. But I limit my soy alot. I drink it in my coffee and that's about it.

I would definately not do the slim fast thing. Way too many chemicals in there and could cause problems. Very commonly GI issues creep up drinking this for thyroid patients as well as others.

If you are looking for a drink - your hubby too- go to GNC and get a good natural protein drink with no fillers or sugar. They are packed with the good things we thyroid patients need and won't bother the system. The cost is less and they are much better in the long haul.

Good Luck

N
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
Avatar universal
I just wanted to add that I, too, have heard and read that if you have a thyroid problem to stay away from soy.  
-Karly
Comment
Cancel
Comment
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
Your Answer
Avatar universal
Answer
Know how to answer? Tap here to leave your answer...
Answer
Submit Answer
A
A
Blank
Weight Tracker
Weight Tracker
Start Tracking Now
Thyroid Disorders Community Resources