No, a placebo response is not a gauge of the cause of a symptom. It is true that the question of nocturnal erections is used to try and separate the emotional from the physical causes of impotence, but it is not an absolute means of distinguishing between the two. There is no one symptom that makes the diagnosis.
When you search for a counselor, consider a sex therapist.
S.A.Liroff, M.D.
Thank you once again for reviewing my symptoms....I apologize if I've become an annoyance. I am going to seek counseling asap. My mind was convinced I had prostatitis, therefore should I have not felt a placebo effect of some kind? Also, since one of the tests for psychologically caused erectile dysfunction is whether or not nighttime erections still occur, shouldn't I still be experiencing these?
Your symptoms are not those of prostatitis and going back over your history, I am further convinced that there is an emotional cause for what you are experiencing. You are not imagining what is happening, your symptoms are very real, but the cause is not physical. Treating the physical (antibiotics, etc.) is not getting at the true issue. The longer you let the symptoms persist, the more difficult it is to resolve them. You need to seek emotional counseling for this.
S.A.Liroff, M.D.