Age is an important point to add in any discussion relating to PSA levels. Given what you relate about the findings on your digital rectal exam, and I assume that you do not have a urine infection, a decision would be based solely on your PSA. I would be hesitant to make a decision on the basis of a single determination and I would recommend a repeat PSA after not having had a digital rectal exam nor an orgasm for at least 3 days. If the repeat value is greater than 4, I would recommend a biopsy. If less than 4, I think that it should be repeated in 3 months and if still in the normal range, I'd repeat it in a year along with a digital rectal exam.
As to how to interpret the biopsy, I trust that the pathologist would know how to do that.
S.A.Liroff, M.D.
I forget to mention I am 63 years old