17567 tn?1276205629
Up and Down
Just curious.... I noticed that my weight varies by around 3-4 pounds during the day... does anyone experience/notice this for themselves too?
Cancel
6 Answers
Page 1 of 1
Avatar universal
YES, it is crazy.. I will be 131 in the morning and 135 in the afternoon. I am trying to lose some weight but its hard to know how much I have actually lost with that much variance!
Comment
Cancel
Avatar universal
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
172023 tn?1334675884
Its very common.  That's why you should not weigh yourself often.  Look for the trend week to week, rather than day to day.

Comment
Cancel
172023 tn?1334675884
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
579258 tn?1250652943
Yes, it is quite normal to have that variance throughout the day.  May I respectfully suggest that you pick a specific time to weigh each day and to weigh in the same clothes as it will provide you with a fairly accurate portrayal of your weight.  

While it is a personal choice, and many people struggle as to how often to weigh themselves, there is some information that supports weighing daily.  Here is the information:  

A number of studies have suggested that people lose weight more successfully when they use self-monitoring. The study suggested that patients keep a food diary, but emphasized that it must be truthful, with the recognition that there will be setbacks. Although there has been some controversy over whether people trying to lose weight should weigh themselves every day and there is not a lot of research on the subject, one review looked at more than 3,000 subjects enrolled in two diet studies and found that frequent weighing was associated with more weight loss (Ann. Behav. Med. 2005;30:210-6).

Over the past two years, I chose to weigh daily as it quickly reflected the times I stumbled.  This allowed me to be responsible and react quickly to get back on track.  We all stumble, it is part of the process of learning better practices.  The trick is to not beat yourself up over it, learn how to cope better, make a plan of action to help thwart the same downfall the next time, and get back on track asap.  

Water weight fluctuations happen even when weighing at the same time.  So, you should not get too upset if you see up to a 2 lb this fluctuation, even when weighing at the same time of day.  It is normal and each person knows if they've made a choice to validate the weight gain or not.  If the weight gain is validated, address it quickly so you don't back-slide.  If the weight gain is not validated, then dismiss it as water fluctuation or building muscle mass and watch the next few days for your weight to level out.

If you are one that is not able to adopt that way of thinking or the scale becomes an obsession, then perhaps weighing once a week is more appropriate.  In the end, it is what works best for you in your weight loss journey and transition to a healthier lifestyle.

Hope this helps ...

Supportive hugs to all ...
Ranae
Comment
Cancel
579258 tn?1250652943
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
17567 tn?1276205629
Actually, seeing this I decided to weigh myself at the same time (first thing in the morning) with the same clothes (next to none).  It appears that the variance is much less.

Regards,
Phil
Comment
Cancel
17567 tn?1276205629
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
172023 tn?1334675884
What happened to me when I was weighing daily is that if I lost, I figured I had a little "wiggle room" to eat more.  If I gained, I was unhappy and started thinking "I've already blown it, may as well have that extra bite here, or that cookie".

It wasn't until I started weighing once a week that I understood that weight loss is a long term, life long journey, and daily weighing was hindering my progress.  It is certainly not the same for everyone.  For the most part, I weigh once a week.  If I do see several pounds creeping up, I tighten up what I'm doing, because there is always a reason (laziness, complancency now that I've reached my goal weight, etc).  

I personally don't like to foster a scale obsession, always letting the number I see dictate my day. I follow the same plan, all the time.  I may loosen up some weeks, and if I see an upward trend, I deal with it.  If I don't great!

Whatever you do,  just don't stop weighing periodically, whether you choose daily or weekly weigh ins.  Be sure you don't let small gains become big gains.   Keep track.  You'll get there.
Comment
Cancel
172023 tn?1334675884
Comment
Comment
Submit Comment
Your Answer
17567 tn?1276205629
Answer
Know how to answer? Tap here to leave your answer...
Answer
Submit Answer
A
A
Recent Activity
1099201 tn?1338184518
Blank
shennigan just a good tired. Comment
10 hrs ago
649848 tn?1424570775
Blank
Barb135 commented on MH Community Mgr's status
16 hrs ago
707563 tn?1455827280
Blank
Emily_MHModerator uploaded a new photo
18 hrs ago
Blank
Weight Tracker
Track your weight over time
Start Tracking Now
Top Healthy Living Answerers
Weight Loss & Dieting Community Resources