Question: Have you had sex with him again? If you haven't/don't plan to.. What exactly do you guys talk about? Bc if you guys talk about that night a lot, esp. his talking and urging for it to happen again, then maybe he's looking for a FWB..? If it's just really interesting/get to know one another chitchat with the occasional mention of that night.. then, personally.. I would feel good about the situation.
Thank you so much for your advice. I feel so much better. I will definitely let this one run its course. Time will tell if this works out or not. I'm going to try to not have bad feelings about all this.
Perhaps now it is time to take it slow.... you got the sex part out of the way - just sit back and relax and hang out with him for a while - there is no pressure now. If he likes you and wants a relationship with you he will keep coming back and hanging out with you. Perhaps you did act too soon - but it takes two to tango - don't put all the blame on yourself for what happened... there was and sounds like there still is a connection between the two of you - so now you need to figure out where he is at. It sounds like he is still interested in you (since you have been talking everyday) - now it is time to start over. The sex may not come for a few weeks again, but that might not be a bad thing - he may be just as nervous as you are.
So what if your friends know - lots of good friends end up hooking up at one time or another. They might think it is odd at first, but you can't control your heart. They'll get over it. Good luck!!
I went through the same thing, and now My best friend and I have been married for 5 yrs. If you both want it to work out, then just talk about it. I'm sure that if you guys decide not to date, it will be akward, but in time, it will get better.