Jul 11, 2009 12:10PM
-
comments
Tags: , , , ,
Tom Dock wrote a blog about declaws in cats. I thought I would paste my comments to his blog here, in case you missed it.
"I (a board-certified surgeon) just would like to comment on one specific point: the pain cats endure after a declaw.
Comparing declaw to amputating fingers in people is simply ridiculous. It's an old, classic, overused scare-tactic.
Would you compare abdominal surgey in a cat or dog and a human? Of course not. Dogs often jump in the car a fwe hours after they've had abdominal surgery. People are probably in pain in a bed for several days, and can barely walk.
Would you compare knee or hip surgey in a cat or dog and a human? Of course not. Pets often start to use the leg hours to days after surgery. People are probably in pain in a bed for several days, and can barely walk.
Similarly, we don't cut babies hands off (see comment above) and we don't cut people fingers off (see comment above), if anything because kids don't end up abandoned if they steal a cookie. And last time I checked, cats don't use a cell phone all that often, and they don't spend they days typing in chat rooms. They can live a perfectly happy, comfortable, indoor life after a declaw.
We perform surgeries that should be far more traumatic and painful that a declaw.
So again, I just would like to comment on one specific point: the pain cats endure after a declaw.
I don't think that declawing a cat is inhumane in some very specific, well chosen cases.
However, I firmly believe that improper pain management is inhumane. After all, we manage far worst cases successfully (fractures, leg amputations, spinal surgery...) from a pain management standpoint, so one would believe that pain management wouldn't be any more difficult for a declaw procedure.
A reasonable protocol could include:
1. application of a "pain patch" the night before
2. before surgery, local anesthesia around the foot (similar to the local injection you get at the dentist)
3. before surgery, an injectable anti-inflammatory drug
4. before surgery, injectable "kitty morphine"
5. after surgery, the injectable anti-inflammatory drug and the "kitty morphine" are continued every 6-8 hours.
6. To go home, the anti-inflammatory drug and "kitty morphine" are continued by mouth for 7-10 days.
We have made immense progress in pain management. There are profesionnal journals, seminars, associations dedicated to that sole purpose. Well, let's use these drugs and techniques!
If such a protocol is not offered (which I would suspect it is not commonly), or if the client can't afford the added cost, then we are dealing with a different issue, -not whether declawing is humane or not. I have witnessed many cats managed this way, including my own, and they seemed pretty content and had a good appetite. If anything, they were "high" on morphine...
I recently read an article written by a general vet about this topic. It was so well written, that I thought I would quote a few sentences:
* "(...) More than 30 years later, I have declawed thousands of cats and I am still waiting for a pet owner to tell me that he or she regretted having it done."
* Some say that "declawing is unnecessary and if the cat had a choice, it would not want its nails removed. (...) I'm sure that if cats had a choice, they wouldn't want their sex organs removed either."
* "I also suspect that they would rather be outdoors hunting than confined in a small apartment or home all day."
* "When done correctly, declawing results in few complications and minor, very temporary discomfort and is much less painful than many other common procedures."
Ditto.
Signed: Phil Zeltzman, DVM, DACVS
A board-certified surgeon who does NOT perform declaws.
www.DrPhilZeltzman.com "