I've just been diagnosed with infiltrating ductal cancer in the left breast, with four tumors found in an MRI, of 8 mm, 4mm, and two "satellites" of 3 mm each. Core biopsy of the 8mm and 4mm tumors found Her2new-pos, estrogen negative cancer. I have a strong family history of breast cancer (no ovarian), and will get results of genetic testing around Jan 20. The first surgeon I talked to recommnded mastectomy in the left breast -- and even raised question of prophylatic mastectomy of right-- almost immediately. I am having a different surgeon do the surgery (for other reasons, not b/c I objected to the recommended course), but I more or less assumed mastectomy from the beginning, and now just wnt to be sure that it is a good call. One thing I worry about is that I am opting for mastectomy for emotional reasons -- to feel I am taking more drastic action more likely to prevent recurrency-- when in fact the studies show that, all other things being equal, lumpectomy with radiation yields similar survival rates to mastectomy. Bottom line: I don't mind losing all of my left breast rather than part of it if its for good reasons, but don't want to do it for nonrational reasons!!! So, my question: given my situation (multiple although small tumors, Her2new pos, estr/prog-neg, and strong family history, B-cup size), are there good survival-related reasons for going for the mastectomy? Thanks so much!