Cancer Community
6.53k Members
Avatar universal

A $9,362 Scrotal Cyst. Does this make sense?

I don't want to discourage anyone from having a nodule removed or having a biopsy.  I'm releaved to know that the free-floating cyst in my scrotum is benign, but the cost of removeal seems extremely high.   My details........

Late in 2005 I noticed a small nodule within my scrotum, not within the skin or on the testes, apparently not attached to anything. Doctor at that time said lets watch. On followup Jan '08, a different doctor (another urologist) would not say what he thought it was indicating that he rarely sees a free-floating nodule with the scrotum. He recommended removing to be sure.

Two weeks ago I went in for outpatient surgery. It involved 3 nurses in a small operating room and my urologist, who performed the surgery. Surgery went well. Less than 20 minutes in the OR for the doctor. Maybe an hour total time for each nurse. My total time at the hospital was about 2.5 hours. I was able to walk out with no pain, having just a few stitches in my scrotum. The nodule appeared clear, and yesterday I got the lab report back confirming that it was a benign cyst, possibly an early hydrocele, although I thought a hydrocele was fluid "around" a testical not a nodule seperate and distinct from the testical.

I'm glad to know for sure that it was nothing. But here's the thing - The cost was $9362 (and I'm not sure if this is the entire cost). Insurance negotiated it to about $6,100. My share turns out to be about $2,400. Imagine if I was a low end wage slave with no insurance! I'd be billed the entire $9362 with no negotiation.

Let's apply a little reason here.

Hospital paperwork: 3 clerical hours at $100/h
Nursing support, including preop preps: 6 nursing hours at $100/h
Surgery: 2 doctor hours at $300/h to account for travel time and file review, although I'm sure he was scheduled for other work while there.  Actual time in surgery was no more than 20 minutes.  
Operating Room Rental: 1 hour at $500.  Wild gues but why would a small tiled room cost more than this.  
Operating Room Cleanup: 1 hour support staff at $50/h
Waste disposal: $200
Lab work to ID cyst: $500

I get $2,750 being liberal with the costs and times. So where does the additional $6,500 come from? Can anyone clarify?

I have no problem with the staff (the nurses and doctor were great), but the system is broken when a 20 minute cyst removal, involving local anesthesia can take a year's salary for someone on minimum wage.

And what happens to that low wage uninsured guy who has a serious problem like some of you on this forum and he fails to get it diagnosed (much less cured) because of cost.  My guess - he dies.
1 Responses
Avatar universal
This is probably gonna make you feel bad to hear, but I had a similar problem and when I found out the cost at a urologist and was aware that more seemed to appear every day. Decided to try and get rid of them myself. The doc said surgery was the only way, so I tried with relative success to remove them myself. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone because of the risk of infection and also of cutting something that's gonna bleed way too much. I was semi satisfied with the end result, but more came and I lost hope of having normal looking balls. But last year I cut soda out of my diet for a few weeks and noticed no new ones appeared during that time period, following a energy drink binge I had several huge and painful cysts appear and realized coke and monsters had to go if I wanted clear skin down there. It's taken close to a year but now my cysts which used to number around three dozen have nearly completely gone. I don't know what in soda causes them, but it's not caffeine; I know this cause coffee and pills don't cause any to show up. Best thing about this solution is it's free and quite permanent, you just have to be willing to give up your favorite drinks
Have an Answer?
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Popular Resources
Here are 15 ways to help prevent lung cancer.
New cervical cancer screening guidelines change when and how women should be tested for the disease.
They got it all wrong: Why the PSA test is imperative for saving lives from prostate cancer
Everything you wanted to know about colonoscopy but were afraid to ask
A quick primer on the different ways breast cancer can be treated.
Get the facts about this disease that affects more than 240,000 men each year.