I’m so curious to hear how it turned out being that this is 10 years later. My 8 year old is into the same things, and my husband isn’t that keen about it. I say let him be, but the pressure from my husband is ridiculous!
Thank you to everyone who answered me. I sent answers back to all of you but I guess I must have done it privately because none of my responses are posted here!
yes - shame on the adult- ALTHOUGH There is that way to look at it, but my son was similar- he loved the pink and purple mermaids, everything pink - and we all see where I am going with that idea- my son's friends were making fun of him at age 6 I think it was- and we did let him keep buying "soft pretty toys"- our other issue was that dad had just run away with a blonder cuter sweeter female- a "FRIEND" of the family's and my son still got to go visit them all- and pretend to be a sweet new little family- you can imagine the scandal in our town- we were already in the spotlight so to speak- and our nanny would even try to discourage the softy- girl like toys- I thought they were a comfort- I guess dad did too- he bought him anything he wanted (out of guilt I thought)-
WELL- In steps big brother- 18 my eldest son and told me the way real life ugly playground talk goes- not the pollyana stuff we want it to be- and my son would be labeled soon if he wasn't already- so our solution was to ask the boy if he was ready to give it all up- he spoke to him seriously and sincerely from already growing up in a little town and seeing the playground whispering from his earlier days- he actually understood and agreed- and we were in Christian counseling then, and they said to save back a few memories and we thought about it and chose not to- we set a date and marked it on the calendar- it was about a month away- the big brother went thru the closets and toychests- and left all the masculine toys- star wars- legos- nothing pink, purple or soft stayed- we donated them to the niece's girls. The replacement was something the boys decided together - a Super Nintendo console- that gave them a chance to bond and get the baby boy out from momma's softness- ??? just another view
What is normal? Some 8 year old's like superheroes, some don't. Some like board games and puzzles, some won't sit still long enough. My first grader still loves to watch Kipper, Max and Ruby, and Bob the Builder. He won't even consider anything with the slightest bit of violence or complicated relationships that might make him squirm. He plays mostly with the same trains, cars and tractors that he has since he was 2 despite our giving him newer and more "age appropriate" toys.
Peer pressure and teasing from the other kids will eventually shift your son's attention to other things besides stuffed animals. He doesn't need to be pressured by adults to give up his stuffed animals, which, by the way, are not just a game to him but comforting in their familiarity as well. If you don't want to encourage him, fine, try to direct his interest elsewhere, but don't discourage him or make him feel it's wrong. I say shame on that adult who made fun of him, that was very unkind.
OMG. Please do not listen to your mom. Let him be. He will get past it and you have to let it be without shaming him.