Dr. Mary Margaret Gleason, a professor of pediatrics and child psychiatry at Tulane who treated Kyle from ages 3 to 5 as he was weaned off the heavy medications, said there was no valid medical reason to give antipsychotic drugs to the boy, or virtually any other 2-year-old. “It’s disturbing,” she said.
Dr. Gleason says Kyle’s current status proves he probably never had bipolar disorder, autism or psychosis. His doctors now say Kyle’s tantrums arose from family turmoil and language delays, not any of the diagnoses used to justify antipsychotics.
“I will never, ever let my children be put on these drugs again,” said Ms. Warren, 28, choking back tears. “I didn’t realize what I was doing.”
Dr. Edgardo R. Concepcion, the first child psychiatrist to treat Kyle, said he believed the drugs could help bipolar disorder in little children. “It’s not easy to do this and prescribe this heavy medication,” he said in an interview. “But when they come to me, I have no choice. I have to help this family, this mother. I have no choice.”
Ms. Warren conceded that she resorted to medicating Kyle because she was unprepared for parenthood at age 22, living in difficult circumstances, sometimes distracted. “It was complicated,” she said. “Very tense.”
Kyle was a healthy baby physically, but he was afraid of some things. He spent hours lining up toys. When upset, he screamed, threw objects, even hit his head on the wall or floor — not uncommon for toddlers, but frightening.
“I’d bring him to the doctor and the doctor would say, ‘You just need to discipline him,’ ” Ms. Warren said. “How can you discipline a 6-month-old?”
When Kyle’s behavior worsened after his brother was born, Ms. Warren turned to a pediatrician, Dr. Martin J. deGravelle.
“Within five minutes of sitting with him, he looked at me and said, ‘He has autism, there’s no doubt about it,’ ” Ms. Warren said.
Dr. deGravelle’s clinic notes say Kyle was hyperactive, prone to tantrums, spoke only three words and “does not interact well with strangers.”
He prescribed Risperdal. At the time, Risperdal was approved by the F.D.A. only for adults with schizophrenia or acute manic episodes. The following year it was approved for certain children, 5 and older, with autism and extremely aggressive behavior. It has never been approved by the F.D.A. for use in children younger than 5, although doctors may legally prescribe it as an off-label use.
“Kyle at the time was very aggressive and easily agitated, so you try to find medication that can make him more easily controlled, because you can’t reason with an 18-month-old,” Dr. deGravelle said in a telephone interview. But Kyle was not autistic — according to several later evaluations, including one that Dr. deGravelle arranged with a neurologist. Kyle did not have the autistic child’s core deficit of social interaction, Dr. Gleason said. Instead, he craved more positive attention from his mother.
Only on msnbc.com Updated 0 minutes ago Acai berry scam: You'll lose money, not weight
Copper heiress has signed a will, attorney says
Hidden buzz: 5 secret caffeine foods
Updated 54 minutes ago Low interest rates squeeze pension funds
Eco-author baffled by Discovery gunman
CEOs lay off thousands, rake in millions
Stephen Hawking says God's not needed. So?
..“He had trouble communicating,” Dr. Gleason said. “He didn’t have people to listen to him.”
After the neurologist review, the diagnosis changed to “oppositional defiant disorder” and the Risperdal continued.
“Yes, I did ask for it,” Ms. Warren said. “But I was at my wit’s end, and I didn’t know what else to do.”
Dr. deGravelle referred her to Dr. Concepcion, who in turn diagnosed Kyle’s condition as bipolar disorder.
“Some children, when they come to me, the parents are really so frustrated,” Dr. Concepcion said in a phone interview. “Especially the mothers are so scared or desperate in getting help. Their children are really acting psychotic.”
Dr. Concepcion also spoke with Dr. Charles H. Zeanah, a Tulane medical professor, who disagreed with both the diagnosis and the treatment. “I have never seen a preschool child with bipolar disorder in 30 years as a child psychiatrist specializing in early childhood mental health,” Dr. Zeanah said.
“It’s a controversial diagnosis, I agree with that,” said Dr. Concepcion. “But if you will commit yourself in giving these children these medicines, you have to have a diagnosis that supports your treatment plan. You can’t just give a nondiagnosis and give them the atypical antipsychotic.”
He also prescribed four more pills.
Kyle’s third birthday photo shows a pink-cheeked boy who had ballooned to 49 pounds. Obesity and diabetes are childhood risks of antipsychotics. Kyle smiles at the camera. He is sedated.
“His shell was there, but he wasn’t there,” Ms. Warren said. “And I didn’t like that.”
Dr. Concepcion referred Kyle to the early childhood support program, which has helped about 3,000 preschoolers from low-income families at risk for mental health problems since 2002.
His speech improved. He threw fewer tantrums. “They started working with us as a family,” said Ms. Warren, who also received parenting advice. “That helps.”
Kyle’s treatment was directed by Dr. Gleason, a Columbia medical graduate who had led a team that wrote 2007 practice guidelines for psychopharmacological treatment of very young children.
“Families sometimes feel the need for a quick fix,” Dr. Gleason said. “That’s often the prescription pad. But I’m concerned that when a child sees someone who prescribes but doesn’t do therapy, they’re closing the door that can make longer-lasting change.”
Off most drugs, Kyle started losing weight and his behavior improved. Ms. Warren’s life also improved. She met a man and they moved into their own house five miles out of Opalousas, a town of 25,000. They were married last Saturday.
At their home recently, Kyle and his brother, Jade, ran and played while their baby sister watched from a playpen. Their clothes were neatly folded in a shared bedroom. They often responded “Yes, ma’am” or “Yes, sir.”
“They’re respectful, but they’re hyper kids,” Ms. Warren said. “Once he came off the medication, he’s Kyle. He’s an intelligent person. He’s loud. He’s funny. He’s smart. He’s bouncy. I mean, there’s never a dull moment. He has a few little behavior issues. But he’s like any other normal 6-year-old.”
Kyle paused to show a reading report card from the end of his kindergarten year, with an A grade.
“Awesome job, Kyle!” his kindergarten teacher wrote.
This story, " Child’s Ordeal Shows Risks of Psychosis Drugs for Young," originally appeared in The New York Times.
Copyright © 2010 The New York Times
This is sickening and just plain scary. 18 months?! Who drugs up an 18 month old baby with pyschotic drugs?! You're not even supposed to be able to diagnose some of these disorders till they're much older because it's just too hard to tell this young.
And it was as simple as him having a speech delay and reacting to a change in his environment. Crazy. I see this stuff all the time. Professionals coming up with all these diagnoses for kids, all these complicated things, when it's usually simply a matter of the child being immature, reacting to a change in their environment, speech delay, etc.
I think children are being overdosed way too much for ADHD too. I talked to an Audiologist about this. We found out, quite by accident, that my daughter had Auditory Processing Disorder when she was around 10. We knew she had some sort of learning disorder that seemed similar to ADD but I didn't want to put her on medication. She would pass a normal hearing test. One day I brought my son to the Audiologist because he had ringing in his ears. As I was standing there talking to the Audiologist about my daughter's difficulties in school and was trying to understand what was going on, he said it sounded like she had APD and that he'd test her when he was done with my son. He tested her (took 3 hours) and she scored very poorly on the test. She had all the signs of APD, NOT ADD. The Audiologist said many children have APD but the parents never know or test them for that. They just assume it's ADD (because the symptoms are so similar) and they put them on Ritalin when they don't NEED Ritalin! He said way too many kids are put on ADD medication who don't have ADD.
That's scary to me. We are overdosing our kids who don't even need these medications to begin with!
There should be greater supervision from the FDA as regards this rather than less. Autism for example is a developmental disability so it doesn't really respond to medication. There are better ways to control the symptoms such as cognitive behavioral therapy (I have seen this in person because I volunteered for a while at a center for children with autism, constructive behavioral therapy was how they were helped). Adhd can be over diagnosed and although I do know some adults with adhd who have benefited from medication given the severe side effects of some current treatment it should be used with caution in young people. Adhd also responds to cognitive behavioral therapy as well. A diagnosis must be very clinical and specific and not just based on behavior and medication should be given only when needed such as with childhood schizophrenia which is clinically rare.
It seems so many these days, parents and Dr.s look for a quick fix in the form of a pill. We as parents need to slow down, spend more time with our children and in my opinion many issues can be dealt with without a prescription. I know there are legitimate cases where medication is necessary, but I also personally believe many issues are not issues at all. For example..hyperactivity. Could it be that children are just not spending enough time running around outside playing, and too much time in front of the TV or Computer? I also think that Attention Deficit is normal to a certain degree in most kids...of course they have trouble concentrating on one thing for too long...they are children! While I am glad advances have been made in medicine to help kids who truly need the help, I have long thought overdiagnoses was a problem. I understand people are busier these days, and many have parents who both need to work...but we need to spend more time with our children, let them play, run off that energy, and take the time to work with them. A pill is not always the answer.
My son at age 5 was given clonidine for Tourette Syndrome and Asperger,by 8 it was changed to haloperidol,and at 12 they wanted to put him on risperidone which I think is the same as your risperdol,I took one look at the possible side effects of this drug and decided I wouldn't give it to him,he could not function in school without medication so I took him out of school and taught him at home,the best thing I ever did was get him off all drugs,he is now 25 had a job since he was 16 got into uni on his own academic merit and is a great young adult who can still struggle with his anger but is trying to learn control without medication turning him into a zombie that just goes through the motions of life.
I'd have to say its related to age as well as what its being treated. The use of psychiatric medications in children can be of concern. I do however know people who are adults who have Tourette's and ADHD and take Risperdal (which I took in the past) and Clonidine (which I take now). With a child (as with an elderly person, there are warnings on the labels of antipsychotics for the use in people who are elderly with dementia) the risk of certain side effects is greater. Some people (such as myself) literally need these medications and for some people they are not needed and for some they can be a detriment. Greater research should be done as to the risk/benefit analysis and further development into newer and safer treatments. Parents who of course are guardians should have further decision making capacity into what are the best options for their children, as regards medication, psychotherapy or cognitive behavioral therapy.
I totally agree,but until they fully understand what these drugs can do to children then in my opinion they shouldn't be prescribed.
I think some of these drugs are sooo dangerous....I had an allergic dystonic reaction to a combination of buspar for anxiety and compazine for nausea....and it was one of the scariest things that has ever happened to me. It made me realize just how much these things screw with your mind chemistry.
even for the people who need them...they're soo dangerous. I understand taking them because you need them, but I always cringe just because they're so toxic.
I have a grandson who has aspergers. He is 8 and can be very violent. None of the programs have worked for his behavior issues. So just recently the doc put him on a high blood pressue med to calm the aggression and hopefully by doing that will allow a period of intervention, so he can be reasoned with. This is the plan and he has only been on the meds for a couple of weeks. The therapist has told us to not respond to any verbal outburst whatsoever, and said to call the police if his physical aggression put anyone in danger. He is 8. Do ya think this is gonna work? I am old school and not into all this new fangled drug scene, and I do no what would happen if he dug his nails into my arms and drew blood down both arms because I dared ignore him! So, I guess that would make ma a monster by todays standards?