Guy B.
1. You had a normal period after sleeping with guy A.
2. You had an early ultrasound that said you conceived in early October, probably sometime around the 8th. That ties back to your period beginning September 23, as it did.
3. Due dates are not reliable if the baby is measured later in pregnancy because babies grow at different rates.
4. Even if you did conceive around September 28, (which you didn't by your first two or three ultrasounds and those are the only ones reliable for dating), it was after the period you had after sleeping with guy A.