I read both the article by Joann Ahern, RN and the response from Yale and I still think that I'd prefer to err on the side of caution. This is MY BABY we're talkin' about!! So my husband and I lose a little sleep - at least we know we will see our son's smiling face in the morning!
It would be really helpful if you could place hyperlinks to the article in this forum.
That said, I agree 100% with what Carol posted above! My wife and I test our daughter twice each night, unless she has had a lot of physical exercise that day. In that case, we test 3 or 4 times each night. We would not THINK of taking a chance with her health and well being!
First of all, it was difficult for me to even consider responding to this question and the parent comments. I became Diabetic at the age of 13 and was able to communicate my needs and learn how to manage my diabetes, in so far as it could be managed at that time, 39 years ago. Even so, my parents were a wreck all the time, constantly worried about me and my disease. So my heart goes out to parents of very small children who must manage a very difficult disease with all the technological tools that are now available, but still no perfect formula and no promised outcome. I do hate this disease and hate what all of us have to go through on a daily basis to survive.
And it is because of this that I must speak for the voice of moderation, even on night testing. The challenge of living with Diabetes is not only about managing our disease, but it is also about learning to live a full and meaningful life with a chronic disease. What you teach your kids about LIVING with Diabetes starts early. Your anxieties,your concerns, your limitations and fears will become theirs. Every child is different and it is important to know your child's nature and to deal with their diabetes in a way that is consistent with how they are most likely to approach it as they get older. It is so impoprtant to pay attention to all aspects of your child's response to this disease, including their emotional response.
Please understand that I am not saying not to test at night and I am certainly not advocating poor control or sloppy treatment of Diabetes. What I am suggesting, and what I think the article is suggesting, is to use blood testing as a tool to monitor, to learn about your patterns and to change behaviors to improve control. If you know your child has hypoglycemic night tendencies, test before they go to bed, provide a snack and test once or twice for a few nights to see if it works. If it does, keep up the pattern of before bed testing and snacks. If your child needs to go to bed with 150 blood sugar in order to avoid a hypoglycemic attack, then either give him/her a larger snack or lower their night insulin. If exercise causes hypoglycemia, then add a snack. There are going to be days when you break from your normal routine and may want to test a little more than usual. But it can be very hard and depressing to keep up a rigid schedule of blood testing all day long and nighttime too.
Obviously all this needs to be checked out with your physician, as I am certainly not qualified to give medical advice. What I do know is that the ability to test blood sugar has led some of us to believe that our blood sugars must be a perfect 90 at all times or horrible things are going to happen. It would be nice if it were possible, but it's not, even if you test a hundred times a day. Fortunately, HA1C is the measure of success in Diabetes control and you can have a very good HA1C without having a perfect blood sugar every time you take it.
Hypoglycemia is very scary to everyone involved and I do appreciate that. I guess I advocate for finding other safe, reliable means for dealing with this issue other than getting up every single night 2 o 3 times until your child is old enough to tell you to leave him alone. It is so very important to give your child all the tools he or she needs to live with Diabetes and I know personally so much of what you need to live successfully is the ability to make choices, to be flexible, to not have to be perfect and to ultimately find a way for Diabetes to live in the life you want to have rather than having Diabetes define your existence. The tools we have really make this possible, but at the extreme, they can also be another source of the torture and burden of living with Diabetes. Finding the right balance for you and your child is the key. Good Luck to all.
My seven-year-old son was diagnosed in June, 2003 and is still in his honeymoon. Despite every effort to keep things under control (and believe me, I am a Type A when it comes to my son's diabetes), his numbers still fluctuate wildly. He started day camp this week, with lots of outdoor activities, and his readings have ranged from 30 to the high 200s. My son's A1C test results have been excellent, so I don't particularly worry about the fluctuations. Having said all that, I do test him once a night because he is low at least twice a week despite having a Glucerna shake and a big serving of cheese right before bed. Granted, I get up at 3 a.m. to get ready for work anyway, which makes it easier on me than other parents. But we also test him on the weekend. Like one of the other parents said, I'd rather be safe than sorry.