Aa
Please help this father stay in Australia
I would like people to join a group on Facebook called "I'm INFURIATED at the Discrimination Against a Doctor & His Disabled Son. Dr Moeller moved from Germany to Horsham in rural Victoria to help with the Dr shortage. His visa expired and he applied for residency, but was declined due to his son Lukas's disability. The said with all the health problems that come with a DS child that is would be a great cost to the Australian taxpayer. I have cared for a downs boy and know what a blessing they are. Please join me in letting the Australian government that they were wrong.
The Facebook group membership has reached around the 1,800 mark and is rising every hour. Thanks so much for you support and keep it up.
This is an email from our local president of the DS chapter of the nat organization.
I just read about the Australian doctor possibly being deported. Absolutely disgusting to think they want to deport the dad based on a child's needs!
All I can think of is to contact the national organizations and see if they have any ideas. I'm thinking of National Down Syndrome Congress and the National Down Syndrome Society. We could also contact the media and raise a ruckus, but I'm not sure how much influence we would have.
I just read about the Australian doctor possibly being deported. Absolutely disgusting to think they want to deport the dad based on a child's needs!
All I can think of is to contact the national organizations and see if they have any ideas. I'm thinking of National Down Syndrome Congress and the National Down Syndrome Society. We could also contact the media and raise a ruckus, but I'm not sure how much influence we would have.
I sent off a letter to the herald Sun on this, I believe it is kinda like a letter to the editor, here is the artical
Doctor told to get out because of son with Down syndromeArticle from: Font size: Decrease Increase Email article: Email Print article: Print Submit comment: Submit comment Mark Dunn and Mike Edmonds
October 31, 2008 12:00am
A MIGRANT doctor and his family are being forced to leave Australia, and the Victorian town that desperately needs him, because his son has Down syndrome.
Dr Bernhard Moeller answered a call from the Federal Government and the Horsham community two years ago, and moved from Germany to become the town's only permanent specialist physician.
But the Department of Immigration and Citizenship this week rejected an application from Dr Moeller and his family for permanent residency because his 13-year-old son, Lukas, has Down syndrome and does not fit the bureaucracy's health criteria.
On advice from a government doctor, the department wrote to Dr Moeller saying his son had been assessed as a burden on Australian taxpayers and could not be granted permanent residency.
A copy of the decision said care for Lukas was "likely to result in significant costs to the Australian community in health care and community services".
Angry? Send Immigation Minister Chris Evans an email about this decision.
But Dr Moeller said his son would always be cared for by family and his needs at school were not prohibitive. "I have the means to look after him and I will look after him," he said.
Horsham, with a population of 20,000, is enraged at the prospect of losing its only internal medicine specialist and residents rallied outside Dr Moeller's practice yesterday, demanding the decision be overturned.
As well as his private practice, Dr Moeller fills a key role at the Wimmera Base Hospital, which serves 50,000 people in the region.
"We are desperate for doctors in the country and the Government says we must get skilled labour from overseas," said Business Horsham's Andrea Cross.
"The decision to reject residency is crazy. He has a disabled child but we've got great support for him here."
Dr Moeller said he was hurt by the rejection, but thanked the community for its support.
"We feel rejected, not welcome any more, by the Australian Government," Dr Moeller said.
"But we've had huge support here in the community."
Dr Moeller is in Australia on a 457 temporary working visa that expires in 2010.
He and his family searched for the best place to raise a family and his wife, Isabella, said Australia was the preferred choice because of the support it offered disabled children.
Lukas attends a mainstream primary school and has an integration aide and speech therapy.
He plays football, cricket, golf and table tennis, and his parents say he has no difficulties coping.
Ms Moeller said Down syndrome was graded from zero to 100, with zero representing a fully dependent sufferer and 100 the mildest affliction. Lukas was rated close to 100.
"It's the worst thing that's happened to me – worse even than when they told me Lukas had Down syndrome," she said.
"We fought for years against discrimination in Germany against Lukas.
"We wanted to make sure he got the best quality of life, and when we looked all over the world we decided Australia was the right place to live.
"We came to Australia in April 2006 on a temporary residency visa, and we told everybody then we wanted to stay in Australia as permanent residents, but they didn't mention anything like this even possibly happening.
"Now we have to start fighting all over again against discrimination."
Down Syndrome Victoria yesterday slammed the Federal Government's decision.
"This decision is disgraceful and discriminatory," Down Syndrome Victoria executive officer Catherine McAlpine said.
"The department are not looking at Lukas as an individual or seeing his potential.
"Instead, they are making assumptions based on their outmoded understanding of intellectual disability."
Ms McAlpine said the case was one of a number where people with Down syndrome were refused residency automatically because they were judged to be a drain on Australian resources.
"It is outrageous that in the same year the Australian Government ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities, it is effectively stripping this young man of his human rights," Ms McAlpine said.
Immigration Minister Chris Evans's office referred questions regarding the Moeller case to his department.
A departmental spokesman said officials were legally bound to reject an application if a Commonwealth medical officer deemed the applicant posed a significant cost burden.
"It is long-standing government policy that high-cost medical conditions are a consideration in visa decisions," the spokesman said, adding that the family could appeal against the decision to the Migration Review Tribunal and, failing that, to the minister.
Dr Moeller said the family would appeal.
Horsham hospital Wimmera Health Group chief executive Chris Scott said he was very disappointed at the decision to refuse Dr Moeller's family permanent residency.
Mr Scott said Dr Moeller's was the only permanent position at the hospital, and two other vacancies were unfilled.
"We recruited him specifically from Germany," Mr Scott said.
"We think it's very disappointing that such a decision can be made when rural Victoria is crying out for senior medical appointments."
Share this article
What is this?
Add to MySpace Digg it Post to del.icio.us Post to Newsvine Post to Facebook Add to kwoff Stumble Upon
Exit: Dr Bernhard Moeller with son Lukas. Picture: Fiona Hamilton
related linksFightback: Send a protest email to the Minister
Video: 'We don't want your son'
Herald Sun accepts no responsibility for the content of any external sites we link to
Doctor told to get out because of son with Down syndromeArticle from: Font size: Decrease Increase Email article: Email Print article: Print Submit comment: Submit comment Mark Dunn and Mike Edmonds
October 31, 2008 12:00am
A MIGRANT doctor and his family are being forced to leave Australia, and the Victorian town that desperately needs him, because his son has Down syndrome.
Dr Bernhard Moeller answered a call from the Federal Government and the Horsham community two years ago, and moved from Germany to become the town's only permanent specialist physician.
But the Department of Immigration and Citizenship this week rejected an application from Dr Moeller and his family for permanent residency because his 13-year-old son, Lukas, has Down syndrome and does not fit the bureaucracy's health criteria.
On advice from a government doctor, the department wrote to Dr Moeller saying his son had been assessed as a burden on Australian taxpayers and could not be granted permanent residency.
A copy of the decision said care for Lukas was "likely to result in significant costs to the Australian community in health care and community services".
Angry? Send Immigation Minister Chris Evans an email about this decision.
But Dr Moeller said his son would always be cared for by family and his needs at school were not prohibitive. "I have the means to look after him and I will look after him," he said.
Horsham, with a population of 20,000, is enraged at the prospect of losing its only internal medicine specialist and residents rallied outside Dr Moeller's practice yesterday, demanding the decision be overturned.
As well as his private practice, Dr Moeller fills a key role at the Wimmera Base Hospital, which serves 50,000 people in the region.
"We are desperate for doctors in the country and the Government says we must get skilled labour from overseas," said Business Horsham's Andrea Cross.
"The decision to reject residency is crazy. He has a disabled child but we've got great support for him here."
Dr Moeller said he was hurt by the rejection, but thanked the community for its support.
"We feel rejected, not welcome any more, by the Australian Government," Dr Moeller said.
"But we've had huge support here in the community."
Dr Moeller is in Australia on a 457 temporary working visa that expires in 2010.
He and his family searched for the best place to raise a family and his wife, Isabella, said Australia was the preferred choice because of the support it offered disabled children.
Lukas attends a mainstream primary school and has an integration aide and speech therapy.
He plays football, cricket, golf and table tennis, and his parents say he has no difficulties coping.
Ms Moeller said Down syndrome was graded from zero to 100, with zero representing a fully dependent sufferer and 100 the mildest affliction. Lukas was rated close to 100.
"It's the worst thing that's happened to me – worse even than when they told me Lukas had Down syndrome," she said.
"We fought for years against discrimination in Germany against Lukas.
"We wanted to make sure he got the best quality of life, and when we looked all over the world we decided Australia was the right place to live.
"We came to Australia in April 2006 on a temporary residency visa, and we told everybody then we wanted to stay in Australia as permanent residents, but they didn't mention anything like this even possibly happening.
"Now we have to start fighting all over again against discrimination."
Down Syndrome Victoria yesterday slammed the Federal Government's decision.
"This decision is disgraceful and discriminatory," Down Syndrome Victoria executive officer Catherine McAlpine said.
"The department are not looking at Lukas as an individual or seeing his potential.
"Instead, they are making assumptions based on their outmoded understanding of intellectual disability."
Ms McAlpine said the case was one of a number where people with Down syndrome were refused residency automatically because they were judged to be a drain on Australian resources.
"It is outrageous that in the same year the Australian Government ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities, it is effectively stripping this young man of his human rights," Ms McAlpine said.
Immigration Minister Chris Evans's office referred questions regarding the Moeller case to his department.
A departmental spokesman said officials were legally bound to reject an application if a Commonwealth medical officer deemed the applicant posed a significant cost burden.
"It is long-standing government policy that high-cost medical conditions are a consideration in visa decisions," the spokesman said, adding that the family could appeal against the decision to the Migration Review Tribunal and, failing that, to the minister.
Dr Moeller said the family would appeal.
Horsham hospital Wimmera Health Group chief executive Chris Scott said he was very disappointed at the decision to refuse Dr Moeller's family permanent residency.
Mr Scott said Dr Moeller's was the only permanent position at the hospital, and two other vacancies were unfilled.
"We recruited him specifically from Germany," Mr Scott said.
"We think it's very disappointing that such a decision can be made when rural Victoria is crying out for senior medical appointments."
Share this article
What is this?
Add to MySpace Digg it Post to del.icio.us Post to Newsvine Post to Facebook Add to kwoff Stumble Upon
Exit: Dr Bernhard Moeller with son Lukas. Picture: Fiona Hamilton
related linksFightback: Send a protest email to the Minister
Video: 'We don't want your son'
Herald Sun accepts no responsibility for the content of any external sites we link to
To: Marty
Isn't that amazing. I was taking my daughter to school yesterday and heard that on the radio and was absolutely gobsmacked!! I could not believe it. How could they say that a DS child would cost anymore than anyone else?? And in the same breath they were saying how short of good doctors they are. Unbelievable.
You could contact the Australian Immigration Department. I know there were many phone calls into the radio station from people who were disgusted.
Look up
www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24580260-26103,00.html that has the story in it.
Love..Kim
Isn't that amazing. I was taking my daughter to school yesterday and heard that on the radio and was absolutely gobsmacked!! I could not believe it. How could they say that a DS child would cost anymore than anyone else?? And in the same breath they were saying how short of good doctors they are. Unbelievable.
You could contact the Australian Immigration Department. I know there were many phone calls into the radio station from people who were disgusted.
Look up
www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24580260-26103,00.html that has the story in it.
Love..Kim
This is so wrong !
Why does the Tax payer have to pay for people who murder and are in Jail?
This Dr is very much needed and he said he was going to pay for his sons needs anyway so what is the problem. I pray he will get to stay where he is needed!
I will have a look at the group on facebook
Take care Mid
this is ridiculous My son with Downs is 38 years old now, He has no more medical expenses than any of my other 4, I will write not only to Austrailia but to the national down syndrome agency. Good Luck
Hi! thanks for telling us all about this! I joined the group! That is horrible..I have been going through similar..I recently moved to Canada from the US, and my daughter having DS makes her inadmissable to Canada because of the health care. I have been fighting for 3 years with immigration to allow her to stay! It *****! I don't understand why this happens! Take care!!
Have an Answer?
You are reading content posted in the Down Syndrome Community
An interview with the co-discoverer of one of the biggest breakthroughs in cancer research
A list of national and international resources and hotlines to help connect you to needed health and medical services.
Herpes sores blister, then burst, scab and heal.
Herpes spreads by oral, vaginal and anal sex.
STIs are the most common cause of genital sores.
Condoms are the most effective way to prevent HIV and STDs.
