That's the conjuctiva. Since you had something in the eye it likely was somewhat swollen. ReStasis would not cause that problem.
Thank you so much for your reply. It looked like the same thing was going on with the eye that didn't have anything in it too. Seems like the conjunctiva is loose or something. Like when I was getting that hair out it looked like it was folding/buckling on itself and looked like it had the potential to be peeled off but I doubt it. I guess I had never seen folds/hills in the conjunctiva before and it scared me. Should I be concerned and see a doctor or just not worry about it?
Usually its either allergy or irritation. Cold compresses and drops like zaditor often help. If it persists see an Eye MD. Weak steroid drops like Alrex or FML are almost always curative.