Hepatitis C Community
13.4k Members
Avatar universal

Interesting Vertex Shareholders Article

Mike Simon posted this below with some other HCV links, but thought I'd post again for those following VX-950.


Interesting investor article in that it seems to cover a lot of the bases we've talked about. I take issue with the author, however, that things will rise and fall on Group "D" -- the 12-week group. While a success with Group "D" might be termed a home run, I think a success with the 24-week group would be certainly termed a game winner. And while I don't know any more about the Barcelona meeting than anyone else, I remain optimistic. I figure that if they had bad news they'd try and slip it in -- like the goverment LOL -- on a Friday afternoon after the markets closed and not at a major hepatitis conference. Not a very scientific analysis but trying to be optimisitc. The one thing the article does seem to emphaisze is investor jitteriness because so much is at stake. This could account for the current price with investors taking profits and all waiting on the sidelines until the Barcelona data is analyzed.

-- Jim
23 Responses
137025 tn?1217768341
I read the article and just wrote the gentleman a letter.  Mostly asking him to be clearer in his numbers.  And to help him understand better the side effects and the bigf freakin need for Telapravir.

The SVR rate is 40%, not 50%.

Rash as a side effect is not a deal killer, not if "suicidal ideation" can make it past the FDA when they approved IFN.  There is also a rash from riba, quite severe for some folks and riba made it past the FDA.

with numbers like 500,000 of us trying to clear or non-responding, Telapravir is on the lips of my doctor as being approved in 2 years.  The stock price can go to hell and come back between now and then, but ole Doc Scott is involved in the HALT-C trial, a Gilead trial and consults for a Vertex trial starting in Washington, so I believe the man.  

I was nice to the writer of the article, but I had many disagreements with what he was writing.  How much value is there in being able to bring an UND in four weeks, by itself? Even to a slow moving organization like the FDA?   And then let the SOC take over for 24 weeks?  Very much value, I think, just on that one aspect of Telapravir.  And to shorten time from 48 to 24 weeks of SOC?  More value, I believe.  Even if SVR rates didn't change one whit, to rewrite protocols to include Telapravir and only 24 weeks has much value, saves money and shortens our exposure to IFN and the damage it does.  Telapravir and it's rash....for me, the rash is would be welcome over what I still experience from IFN.  

It's all so interesting, stock price is irrelevant now tho in my mind.  The bigger picture, for those of us non-responders, Telapravir may add a great twist to the story.

Have a good one.

Ranting, wondering WIllow  
Avatar universal
Even the mother of all riba rashes doesn't come close to the rash the trial participants endured.
They really suffered and it required stopping meds for some. In addition the rash affects three times as many people taking VX as rashes affect those on SOC. Some had to be administered heavy doses of steroids just to try to control it. Rashes of this type that are confluent can be extremely dangerous. Our skin is our largest organ and the situation is a big concern. I was hospitalized once for a confluent rash and told it could kill me, so I know how serious they can be. As I recall from participants reports it took quite some time for it to resolve completely. That will trouble the FDA Im afraid. Im still optimistic that they can resolve the issue.
The fact that they approved SOC with "suicidal ideation" affecting a tiny percentage is no different than many many other drugs that have that listed in their warnings where everything and the kitchen sink is listed to avoid liability. Most all psychotropic drugs have this warning as well as sleep aids and Im sure many other types of drugs too. This is due I would think more to the fact that a large portion of the population suffers from depression and a fraction of those will have suicidal ideation  regardless of what meds they are taking.

In my view there is no way the drugs will be available in "two years" to everyone. The trials coming up don't even start until summer and then it will be weill into next year before they are even done.
Avatar universal
Thanks for the link to both Jim and Mike.

I too have watched the market closely lately and think it might be time to buy more Vertex, not sell off.  I don't think shareholders know any more than the rest of us, hungering for a better treatment.

The author did make some good points in watching the numbers they use to analyze their data.

Avatar universal
From what I've heard Kalio makes a very good point on the rash issue.  It's a bit disconcerning to see some many jumping on the bandwagon as though VX950 is the Holy Grail for HCV.  Makes me wonder if Pegylated Interferon received the same pandimonium when it was being tested?

If it makes tx more tolorable and increases the odds of slaying the dragon for many more than current tx regimen does, then it's great!  But it still seems to fall far short of being a silver bullet.  Is it really the blessing many seem to think it is if newer drugs like VX950 bring yet another round of sx's which makes tx impossible or more burdensome?
151263 tn?1243377877
willow's quote: "Rash as a side effect is not a deal killer...Telapravir and it's rash....for me, the rash is would be welcome over what I still experience from IFN. Give me the chance to be hospitalized from a Telapravir rash, I already know the consequences of my Hep C."

Be "wery wery" careful what you wish for! ;-)
Avatar universal
I think people have the idea it's like a "normal" rash or like something they have had that was similar. I don't think they can imagine just what you guys experienced. Words can't describe it!!

But thankfully you survived it and you are probably right now clear of this creepy virus! Even though the rash is discoraging for everyone waiting on it's approval, I am so encouraged by the fact that it looks like most reporting back are SVR. Even if it doesn't make it to market, at least you guys were cured!!

I hope you are hanging in there and things are going ok.
Have an Answer?
Top Hepatitis Answerers
317787 tn?1473362051
683231 tn?1467326617
Auburn, WA
Learn About Top Answerers
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Answer a few simple questions about your Hep C treatment journey.

Those who qualify may receive up to $100 for their time.
Explore More In Our Hep C Learning Center
image description
Learn about this treatable virus.
image description
Getting tested for this viral infection.
image description
3 key steps to getting on treatment.
image description
4 steps to getting on therapy.
image description
What you need to know about Hep C drugs.
image description
How the drugs might affect you.
image description
These tips may up your chances of a cure.
Popular Resources
A list of national and international resources and hotlines to help connect you to needed health and medical services.
Here’s how your baby’s growing in your body each week.
These common ADD/ADHD myths could already be hurting your child
This article will tell you more about strength training at home, giving you some options that require little to no equipment.
In You Can Prevent a Stroke, Dr. Joshua Yamamoto and Dr. Kristin Thomas help us understand what we can do to prevent a stroke.
Smoking substitute may not provide such a healthy swap, after all.