First of all, tell me how you were diagnosed with genital HSV 1 infection. Let's do that first and then let me address the pain issues.
First, thank you for your reply and starting at the begining. The diagnosis was a bit of a whirl wind.
Day 5 I began getting the above mentioned "1st outbreak" symptoms. I was immediatly put on acyclovir by my doctor, so no noticeable sores appeared. I came off of the anti-virals, after completing the course and about 4 days later the noted "2nd outbreak began". I did get (not mentioned above) some yellow crust on the shaft of my penis about 7 days into this 2nd bout, but when I wiped it way saw no sores, or bumps, just a bit red. I was not able to see my doctor, so I had to let it run its course. Over the next 5 months the "Ongoing symptoms" were constant. I had numerous biopsies and blood tests, which are listed below:
Hand biopsy: Spongiotic dermatitis
Pubic hair area bump: Unknown, but possible herpes. Sent to another lab who said unknown, but they were "not comfortable calling it hsv
Pubic hiar biopsy #2 area: Folliculitis
Buttocks biopsy: Folliculitis
3 days: IGG HSV-2 negative, IGM negative, IGG HSV-1 not tested
2 months: IGG HSV-2 negative, IGM negative, IGG HSV-1 positive 4.95
5 months: IGG HSV-2 negative, IGM negative, IGG HSV-1 positive # unknown
All other STDs clear
All other blood work and urine testing normal
I then, 5 1/2 moths in, got 4 itchy, but tiny (like the size if a needle tip) bumps on my knuckle and asked for a culture. It came back positive for HSV.
Upper spine Normal
I have been to one of the leading centers in the area and the ID doctor said there was no need to do anymore testing because due to all the symptoms being similar and starting at the same time, with the knuckle swap and blood tests that was enough. At the same center I saw of the nuerologists, and he is the one that prescribed the nuerotin I spoke of in the earlier post.
So, what next? Now that I have been on the Valtrex for about 3 weeks the rash on my hand(s) have stopped, but the pain in my groin, legs, hand, buttocks, and slightly in my arm are still there. I also have itching inbetween my testicals and legs, and throughout my pubic hair that does not seem to go away. The pain in my legs is now more like irritation and really sensative to any contact (clothing ect). It has dropped to this level before the Valtrex, but within a week I will get another major flare up where the pain gets unbarriable. I also still get periodic sharp stabbing pain/burning sensations inside my penis, and an ache in my pelvic area, near the base of my penis. It is a deep sharp ache. Most importantly, I need to get rid of this leg, buttocks pain, and pubic itching. Really driving me crazy at this point. I have "kind of" accepted the fact that I have HSV-1, but I do not know how to live until I can find a way to get rid of this constant reminder and pain.
Sorry for the book, but now you have the entire background.
OK, so we know that you have herpetic whitlow on your finger, and we know it is HSV 1 and that you don't have HSV 2.
There is no indication to me that you have genital infection or even oral infection.
Before universal precautions, many health care providers, for example, acquired HSV 1 on their hands, and had herpetic whitlow.
You've jumped to the conclusion, with the help of the ID doc, that all of your symptoms are related to an HSV 1 infection on your hand. I would disagree. There just isn't any evidence for that. Your hand rash stopped because you were taking antiviral therapy and you have hand infection. That all makes sense. But the rest of it really doesn't make sense to me. HSV 1 in the genital area rarely reactivates, and to have this much trouble that isn't relieved by antiviral medicine really makes no medical sense when the diagnosis is HSV 1 genitally.
Actually, your symptoms might be prostatic, have you had that evaluated?
the neurontin might help, but if you don't want to take it, you won't know.
If you were my patient, I would say that all your pain is very unlikely to be related to HSV 1 infection, and that you should give the neurontin and see how it goes.
Again there is nothing in here that says to me you have genital HSV 1 and several biopsies that says it isn't.
Finally, when you had the test 2 months after first symptoms appeared it was firmly positive. that means you could have acquired this as early as childhood, just no way to know!
Thanks again for the reply and all that you do.
I am having a lot of problems with this. Everything (hand, groin, leg, buttocks, fever, chils, yellow crust on penis), started directly following a sexual encounter. I know this all seems very unlikely (and I know most the research says that HSV-1 would not cause this many issues), but my sense would be that contracting it on my hand would be much harder then genitaly. So, If I got it on my hand during an encounter and had genital symptoms.....
I do not want to try to diagnos myself, but nothing else seems possible, as everthing else has come back good. I did go see a urologist, but I am not sure exactly what he checked. The nuerologist said that the virus can cause peripheral neuropathy. He is sure that the nuerotin will work, but I trying to get better, not just mask the pain (I know this may sound crazy). I just do not want to be on Nuerotin (9+ pills a day) with no clear end point, and never knowing if I am actually getting better.
Are you saying that genital hsv-1 can not cause this or it is just not seen very often? And based on the above I am going to ask my doctors for further investigation.
Have you ever read or treated a case where HSV-1 caused peripheral neuropathy. If so, how did it end? Any suggestions for recovery? Again, I am living extremely scared right now. Please be patient with me as this is uncharted territory for me.
One last thing: Where can I find a list of herpe specialists by location? I know there is only so much you can do over the internet.
I'm saying it is unlikely that your HSV 1 infection is causing all this pain, not totally impossible.
What city do you live in?
Do you know if the nueropathy or nerve pain will go away?
Do you have any recommendations?
Agian, I do not want to sound dramatic, but this is destroying my life.
Do you have some place I can send you a private message? I don't want my location plastered all over the internet.
I was just looking for a city so I might help to give you a reference for someone in your area who might help you.
I'm so sorry, but I can't tell you if the pain will go away because I don't really know what is causing it. Even though this began after a sexual encounter, we certainly don't know that this is herpes.
Sorry I can't help you more.
Yeah, figured that is what you wanted it for, but I know this is a public forum.
I don't know of a particular neurologist in the San Jose area, but I know of an excellent internist, Dr. Kuljeet Rai, he might be able to help you. You may let him know that I referred you. We used to do clinical research studies together.
Do you know of any good herpe specialists in the area?
Please keep us posted, I am experiencing almost identical symptoms but am at 3 months and blood tests neg for hsv. Rash on both hands, facial symptoms and shooting pain in legs, buttocks and pain b/t testes and leg. Hand biopsy due back next week. Have you tested for hiv? I've done 2, one at 14.5 wks and one at 15.5 wks., both neg. Starting to lose it. Have been to urologist, dermatologist, internist and even the emergency room. Blood drawn countless times. All started with genital pain, no diagnosis yet.
I don't know any specific specialists in your are, just Dr. Rai who knows a lot about herpes.