I'm not going to comment on what happens to other people and the things they describe. It is way too complicated. I feel I've answered your initial question as well as I can.
This thread is closed.
Terri
Hi Terri,
Are you able to explain your comment above in a little more detail. What other factors do you beleive need evaluation? It does worry me when people come forward and say they have successfully transferred the virus to other locations with a long standing previous oral infection.
Thanks.
Gusthebear, what you are describing is very unusual, and there are many things that should be evaluated before one comes to that conclusion.
Terri
I have had cold sores hsv1 for 15 years... I show symptoms 2-3 times a year and (regardless of good hygiene) I have successfully transferred the virus to my genital area.. So saying that one cannot infect another person genitally if the the receiving partner has oral hsv-1 is false I believe... ...seeing how I have auto-inoculated myself from one area to another. However if you are judging the presence of the virus through blood test only this may be a blind spot.
No,no herpes for as short a time as you describe.
Terri
Hi Terri,
I understand this thread is probably now considered closed so I am happy to pay again for you to answer this question.
Last week I got another symptom of a flushing/burning sensation that moved around my genital area (ie from scrotum to pubic area, and then back to the scrotum again). This lasted about an hour then I got about 2 days of localised itching in a spot in my pubic region. Nothing appeared but a bit of redness. I guess I wanted to know where to go from here because these symptoms don't seem normal to me?
What can be the cause of a flushing sensation in your genital area? Not herpes?
Thanks again
a follow up to this string of questions please -- if a girl with oral herpes french kisses and also performs oral sex on a man, isn't it true that it is likely the man will get oral herpes, but unlikely he will get genital herpes?
I don't know about over reactive, but I think the chances that you acquired HSV 1 genitally is incredibly small.
Terri
Hi Terri,
Firstly thanks for the very prompt response. Its much appreciated.
I have had cold sores since the age of 9. I am now 29 years of age. So Definately not sexually active at that age.
I guess if I didn't have any of these recurring symptoms I would have forgotten about it by now. Do you think I am being over reactive? What should I do if these symptoms continue to arise?
Thanks again for your assistance.
It is correct that it is virtually impossible to acquire HSV 1 genitally after having a well established oral infection. So the person who has had cold sores since childhood would be extremely unlikely to acquire HSV 1 genitally through receiving oral sex. In 30 years of practice, I have seen one person be positive genitally for HSV 1 who stated he had had cold sores since a child. However, his reported history of cold sores may not have been accurate, difficult to say. Anyway, if it does happen, I've not seen it except this once in 30 years and we diagnose herpes many times per week.
I'm not clear what the bump in your genital was about, but I would say it is likely more than a coincidence that this happened the day after shaving the pubic hair.
I appreciate all the details, but none of it really changes my mind about the chance of acquiring HSV 1 genitally after having it orally for many years.
How old were you when you got your first cold sore? Were you sexually active?
Terri