I've had the same issue. My nipples were extremely itchy and also dry. I applied a little cocoa butter after showers or whenever the itching became to much.
Your not alone, Mine are the same..... Not sore just itchy.... And when I do sleep I must scratch them to the point where I break the skin.... I've jst being using lots of moisturizer on them especially after shower and before bed, seems to be helping.
Tummy butter works great for me
My breast itch so bad all the time i thought i was the only one lol
I itch everywhere! Especially my nappies and thighs, aaarrrggghhhh!
I use cerave for breasts n baby oil for nipples..