..... its a f*****g pie ....
I don't think he is saying YOU can't eat the pie. Just make it and eat it and share it with your friends who like it.
I'd make the pie and buy him a roll of TUMS if he's gonna complain lol.
i love that pie! I'd come and eat it with you. But since i am prob on the other side of the world, you can make the pie and share it with your friends or family. And you're lucky, my husband eats everything i make. I made a pumpkin pie one evening and when i woke up there was only one piece. (He worked the night shift and ate everything at 6am when he came back)
But i think even if you made the pie he would have some anyway. I make lots of things my husband says he doesnt like and he ends up eating it and liking it anyway.
Its just a pie. Remember that, if you can't eat a whole pie yourself. Make a smaller pie or tarts instead so you can eat it and he doesn't have too. If he really doesn't like it you can't force him to eat it.
Maybe he didn't lie to you; maybe when he ate it, he really did love it, but when the heartburn set in, it gave him a bad association with the pie. Just make another one and eat it yourself, if you have to, but try not to take this so personally.
I know but at the time I made it last time he told me he loved it and no I guess I am lucky that's our biggest problem but still I feel lied to and I guess I should be happy he even tried it too.... I tripped and fell on it and may have crushed like half of it before I got to his house... This was a while ago though and we just brought it up tonight while we were making the shopping list for the week :(
You are a lucky girl if this is the biggest problem you have. Try to relax. (In fact, that is not my favorite kind of pie, either. Something about the eggwhite topping.) It is certainly true that you can make it, cut off a day or two's worth, and freeze the rest. He should not feel forced to eat it.
Sweetie, just make it and keep it for yourself for however long you want! I'd say you're lucky! My boyfriend eats EVERYTHING and I never get a full anything to myself.
If it's the fact that he won't eat something important to you, I'd ask him to try to take some heart burn medication and just have a single slice. Let him know its really important to you to share it.